NYC’s 30 Essential Mexican Restaurants

Taqueria Coatzingo is actually a full blown Pueblan restaurant and not just a taqueria — so sit down and make yourself comfortable!
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Look back 35 years, and NYC’s Mexican restaurant scene was dominated by sizzling fajitas, cheese enchiladas, and nachos; the city now boasts restaurants specializing in many regions, rivaled in this country only by Los Angeles. That shift can be credited in part to the severe 10-year drought that plagued the Mexican state of Puebla, forcing residents to relocate here, and immigrants from states like Guerrero, Morelos, and Michoacán followed. New York City is now home to an amazing array of Mexican establishments, from tiny taquerias to full-blown restaurants, featuring regional fare from the Yucatan to Sinaloa — plus higher-end spots where thrilling culinary inventions are occurring.

Here’s our choice collection of New York City Mexican restaurants, including many classics along with new ones that appear on this list for the first time. Two quintessential food trucks are included, along with every size, type, and price point of restaurant.

The latest CDC guidance for vaccinated diners during the COVID-19 outbreak is here; dining out still carries risks for unvaccinated diners and workers. Please be aware of changing local rules, and check individual restaurant websites for any additional restrictions such as mask requirements. Find a local vaccination site here.

Taqueria Sinaloense

113 W 225th St
The Bronx, NY 10463

While much Mexican food in New York comes from the southern part of the country, Taqueria Sinaloense draws from Sinaloa, a coastal state situated in the northwest. It opened not long ago in Marble Hill, after an unrelated place with the same name closed in Elmhurst. This one specializes in tacos, including tacos canasta (“basket tacos”) filled with chorizo and grilled cheese and dipped in oil to keep them fresh, often sold by vendors or taken on picnics; and tacos gobernador (“governor’s tacos”), lusciously filled with shrimp and fresh chiles, reminding us of Sinaloa’s beaches.

Governor’s tacos at Taqueria Sinaloense
Robert Sietsema/Eater

La Morada

308 Willis Ave
The Bronx, NY 10454

This small cafe in the Mott Haven section of the Bronx has succeeded in popularizing the food of Oaxaca in NYC at very reasonable prices. The place also serves as a center of social activism under chef Natalia Mendez and family. Choose any of the colorful moles, or a flatbread tlayuda covered with toppings and considered a great drinking snack. Other expected antojitos are available, but I’m partial to the hand-patted, shoe-shaped huaraches.

Mole verde at La Morada
Alex Staniloff/Eater

Santa Clarita

237 Willis Ave #2
Bronx, NY 10454

Mott Haven in the Bronx, easily accessible by subway from all points in the city, has become a hotbed of Mexican restaurants in the last decade — and not just the Oaxacan gem La Morada. Santa Rita was founded in 1971 as a Puerto Rican and Dominican restaurant, but morphed into a Mexican one, joining a charming taco window with a more formal indoor dining room, with a relaxing porch in front connecting them. The al pastor cylinder twirling in the window is particularly good, but the tacos dorados (rolled tacos), enchiladas, or anything featuring shrimp are also recommended.

Santa Clarita, since 1971
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Las Delicias Mexicanas

2109 3rd Ave
New York, NY 10029

This East Harlem gem specializes in standard Mexican fare with a nod to Mexico City and a tip of the hat to southern state cuisines. The pozole and huaraches are distinguished, and this is one of those places that has always served birria — as a huge soup with warm tortillas on the side rather than as tacos. The meat is goat or lamb, rather than beef, and they provide plenty of finely chopped onions and cilantro, in addition to lime wedges. The birria also sports carrots for sweetness and tiny chickpeas.

Goat birria at Las Delicias Mexicanas
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Taco Mix

234 E 116th St #1
New York, NY 10029

This flagship of a mini-fleet of Pueblan taquerias owned by Alejo Sanchez specializes in al pastor, as you might guess from the giant pineapple-topped cone of pork swirling slowly in the window. Get the mini taco, by all means; the tortillas are better and show off the meat with a few shards of fruit to greater advantage. Eat at the counter, or grab the single table way in the back. A branch downtown on Delancey Street may have better tortillas, which are made periodically at the counter. But the East Harlem original rules where atmosphere is concerned.

Tacos al pastor at Taco Mix
Robert Sietsema/Eater

El Mitote

208 Columbus Ave
New York, NY 10023

Owned by Cristina Castaneda, El Mitote (named after an Aztec dance) partly focuses on the street food of her hometown of Guadalajara, but mounts a menu that includes classic Mexican fare from around the country. An early afternoon brunch served every day might include wild mushroom tinga tacos, huevos rancheros or chilaquiles, and this stunning red chicken pozole every bit as spicy as it looks, served with a crema-painted tostada on the side.

Pozole rojo at El Mitote
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Tulcingo Del Valle

665 10th Ave
New York, NY 10036

The mother of all Puebla bodega taquerias in town is Hell’s Kitchen’s Tulcingo del Valle, name-checking a town in the arid southern part of the state and offering a full Pueblan menu from mole de olla to costillas en salsa verde. It’s also one of the best places in town to score a vegetarian chile relleno, stuffed with cheese and smothered in a sprightly tomato sauce. Keep your eye on chalkboard specials. It’s owned and operated by Irma Verdejo and family.

Vegetarian chile relleno at Tulcingo Del Valle
Robert Sietsema/Eater

Ruta Oaxaca

35-03 Broadway
Queens, NY 11106

With a zingy design featuring the color pink and a bar emphasizing mezcal and tequila (and an array of flavored salts to give them oomph), Ruta Oaxaca is one of the city’s best evocations of the cuisine of that southern Mexican state, one of country’s tastiest. Moles come in a rainbow of colors, representing ancient sauces whose history goes back to pre-Columbian times, and you can’t go wrong with chicken bunuelos with mole Oaxaca (a very dark mole), or the brighter mole verde, poured with extra panache over a fish filet tableside.

Fish with mole verde at Ruta Oaxaca
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

La Estancia de la Espiga

42-11 102nd St
Corona, NY 11368

Mexican food fans are faced with the perpetual question of where to get great barbacoa on the weekends; La Estancia de la Espiga (La Espiga for short) is the best answer. Right in the window, watch the goat or lamb steaming, then select the semi-subterranean dining room or cheery outdoor area, both often filled with families from Guerrero, where proprietor Tomás Gonzalez is from. You get a pound of goat; pile of fresh, hand-pressed tortillas (also cooked in the window); along with chopped cilantro and onions, lemon wedges, radishes, and a couple of salsas — one of Queens’ finest DIY meals.

Weekend lamb barbacoa at La Espiga
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Taqueria Coatzingo

7605 Roosevelt Ave
Jackson Heights, NY 11372

This two-decade-old taqueria run by Rufino Zapata and family has been a beacon for Pueblan food in Jackson Heights. “Taqueria” is perhaps too modest a term, since the current establishment occupies two storefronts, one of which doubles as a bar and dance hall. The cemitas are made on bread baked in the restaurant’s own panaderia. This is one of the city’s best and most reasonably priced Mexican restaurants in the city, and the tacos come with guac. ‘Nuff said.

Cow foot tostada at Taqueria Coatzingo
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Birria-Landia

77-99 Roosevelt Ave
Jackson Heights, NY 11372

When this truck slid up to 78th Street right on Roosevelt Avenue in Jackson Heights not long ago, it was laden with beef birria in the style of Tijuana and Los Angeles, and the lively red soup (really, the braising liquid) that goes with it. The crew has earned a cult following for methodically turning out tacos and mulitas late into the night. The truck is operated by José Moreno, former chef at Del Posto, and his brother Jesús. A further truck in Williamsburg serves a similar menu. Now birria is found all over the city, and beyond.

Birria tacos at Birria-Landia
Robert Sietsema/Eater

Cienega Las Tlayudas de Oaxaca Mexican Cuisine

10432 Corona Ave
Corona, NY 11368

This informal, colorfully decorated restaurant open since 2013 specializes in tlayudas. These giant rounds of masa dough are rolled thin, cooked to near crispness, and topped with ingredients that often include quesillo, black beans, cactus strips, jalapeños, tomato, and avocado — plus meat or poultry. Other good choices include monster tacos placeros, chilaquiles, and enmoladas (mole enchiladas).

Cienega Las Tlayudas de Oaxaca Mexican Cuisine
Robert Sietsema/Eater

Casa Enrique

5-48 49th Ave
Long Island City, NY 11101

A shaggy dog wearing a sombrero is the logo for Casa Enrique, a small but celebrated restaurant in Long Island City. Chef Cosme Aguilar’s menu includes cochinito Chiapeneco, pork braised in bright red guajillo chile sauce, among other dishes from his hometown in Chiapas, Mexico’s southernmost state.

Cochinito Chiapeneco at Casa Enrique
Robert Sietsema/Eater

Los Tacos No. 1

75 9th Ave
New York, NY 10011

Evoking a beachside taco stand in Baja or maybe San Diego, Los Tacos No. 1 is a corrugated metal structure within Chelsea Market that draws long lines at lunch and dinner. It does only a few things, but does them very well. Fresh flour and corn tortillas form the basis for pork adobada tacos, which will remind you of the pineapple-tenderized al pastor of Puebla. The beach favorite of grilled steak (carne asada) is also available, and either filling can be used to make a double-tortilla mula), gluing its tortillas with cheese. Find other locations in Times Square, Grand Central, and Tribeca.

Pork adobada mula at Los Tacos No. 1
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

La Fondita Restaurant

49-11 69th St
Woodside, NY 11377

This Woodside wonder near the Maspeth border specializes in food from the southwestern state of Guerrero, where chef Adela Arias-Galvez was born. The spicy red weekend pozole is not to be missed, but even better is an off-menu item called mole de guerrero, a thick red sauce that tastes great on pork ribs (shown) or chicken, in a recipe attributed to the chef’s grandmother.

Pork ribs at La Fondita Restaurant
Robert Sietsema/Eater

El Cantinero

86 University Pl
New York, NY 10003

Before the city had food from Puebla, it had Tex-Mex. One of our oldest purveyors is El Cantinero, a dark, bi-level den just south of Union Square that excels at sizzling fajitas, cheese enchiladas, and hard shell tacos, three staples of Tex-Mex cuisine. Nachos are carefully laid out the old fashioned way, and yes, there are frozen margaritas by the bucketful.

Nachos at El Cantinero
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Oxomoco

128 Greenpoint Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11222

With its austere white facade, set back from the street and occupied by an open-air seating area, Oxocmoco channels LA’s outdoor Mexican cafes. A wood-fired oven scents the air, and from it chef Justin Bazdarich pulls pork cheek carnitas, flank steak, and tender lamb barbacoa, all stuffed in tacos. Bigger feeds include a whole roasted branzino and bavette steak with chile ancho butter. Plenty of less-traditional inventions worth tasting include a charred carrot tamal smothered in hoja santa sauce, and a beef tartare tostada.

Whole branzino at Oxomoco

Atla

372 Lafayette St
New York, NY 10012

As a sort of casual counterweight to the formality and expense of Cosme, Enrique Olvera and Daniela Soto-Innes opened this small and sunny spot near Cooper Square, though Soto-Innes departed recently. The menu often gets playful, with a cauliflower al pastor taco, for example, or fish milanese, or a kale tamal, and a faddish birria service was recently added. But much of the menu is more doctrinaire, with beverages that run from espresso to invented cocktails.

Avocado toast
Photo by Nick Solares

Lupe's East L.A. Kitchen

110 6th Ave #1607
New York, NY 10013

For homesick Angelinos and San Franciscans, New York boasts a couple of Cal-Mex spots, foremost of which is Lupe’s East L.A. Kitchen, where you can get cheese enchiladas in chile colorado, rolled potato taquitos, chile verde, and a full range of bulbous Mission burritos — a Cal-Mex invention — in a trippy diner setting with a view of Sixth Avenue, operated by David Seixas. 

Rolled potato taquitos at Lupe’s East L.A. Kitchen
Robert Sietsema/Eater

Paloma’s Bk

1 Knickerbocker Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11237

This descendent of the Ridgewood restaurant also called Paloma’s, from owner and chef Fabiola Maldonado, has a much more ambitious menu than its predecessor and a cocktail-lounge atmosphere featuring a giant painting of a chanteuse behind the bar, and a musical performance space adjacent to the dining room. The menu strays to all sorts of regional Mexican places, though anchored in a small collection of Oaxacan moles. The scallop aguachile is particularly appealing, and one can’t go wrong with the tacos gobernador, a specialty of Sinaloa spilling buttery and tender shrimp out their ends.

Crab tostada at Paloma’s BK
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Santa Ana Deli & Grocery

171 Irving Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11237

Bodega taquerias from the state of Puebla abound in Bushwick, including this one named after the town of Santa Ana Xalmimilulco. The groceries at Santa Ana Deli & Grocery have withered to a few shelves, but still display a killer collection of dried and canned chiles. The menu, stenciled over the counter at the end of the room, is expansive, including rolled tacos arabes in flour tortillas; rice-bearing tacos placeros that enfold other homely fillings like boiled egg and chiles relleno; and a wonderful burrito Santa Ana, sauced with the colors of the Mexican flag. The grocery was founded in the 1980s and is still owned and operated by Polo Teco and family.

Tacos arabes at Santa Ana Deli & Grocery
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Nene’s Deli Taqueria

14 Starr St
Brooklyn, NY 11237

Sometimes it seems like Bushwick is nothing but a mass of birria, offered in nearly every corner of the neighborhood. Nene’s is wedged into a narrow bodega south of Maria Hernandez Park, where chef Andrés Tonatiuh Galindo Maria relocated his birria operation not too long ago, making a bewildering number of antojitos featuring his beef birra, running from mulitas to burritos to (gasp!) birria ramen. The mulita is particularly recommended due to its double complement of tortillas and generally soggy (in a good way) demeanor, and its surprise inclusion of guac.

Mulita at Nene’s Deli Taqueria
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Purépecha

213 Smith St
Brooklyn, NY 11201

This Cobble Hill restaurant owned by siblings Sandra and Willson Lopez is decorated with a colorful mural of Mexican motifs: a sugar skull, agave cactus, and ear of maize. It mounts a menu with many specialties from the state of Michoacán, directly west of Mexico City. Carnitas is a dish associated with the state, a pork confit that can be dry or almost soupy, here loaded into tacos and topped with guacamole. Other standouts include a Maruata taco of fried fish named after a beach town, and a grandma recipe of bean-stuffed enchiladas with a mild tomato sauce called enchiladas placeras.

Carnitas tacos at Purépecha
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Claro

284 3rd Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11215

This cozy and innovative spot near the Gowanus Canal partly specializes in Oaxacan food via chef T.J. Steele. Sure, there are moles, chorizo memelas, and the dressed flatbreads called tlayudas, but there are also hand-patted tortillas and shrimp tacos made therefrom, washed down with beer and mezcal. The logo is a woodcut of a happy goat paradoxically relaxing in a stewpot, and a backyard seating area is one of Brooklyn’s most glorious when summer rolls around.

Tuna tostada from Claro

Antojitos del Patron Mexican Snacks

52 Lincoln Rd
Brooklyn, NY 11225

Part of a cluster of three restaurants on the same block owned by a pair of Guatemalan sisters, Brenda Castellanos and Ana Prince, Antojitos del Patron is a cozy cafe offering homestyle, corn-based Mexican food. Steamed in a banana leaf, the Oaxacan tamal is magnificent, a massive cylinder of masa drenched in a chunky pork sauce, a full meal in itself. Special types of tacos are available, including tacos arabes and tacos al pastor, both originating in Puebla.

Oaxacan tamal at Antojitos del Patron
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Tacos El Bronco

860 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11232

I guess by now everyone knows to get the tiny tripa tacos at this amazing taco truck that parks opposite the Jackie Gleason Bus Depot, a stone’s throw from the Green-Wood Cemetery in Sunset Park. Note that the tripa here is not of the honeycomb variety, but is instead made from veal intestines. I guarantee both substances are equally good in a taco. Otherwise, steer in the direction of goat, calf tongue, veal head, or pork skin.

Tacos El Bronco
Robert Sietsema/Eater

Don Pepe Tortas Y Jugos

3908 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11232

Opened in 2003, Don Pepe presaged an era when the Mexican sandwiches called tortas were super-sized and rendered glamorous as massive feeds for any meal. Dozens upon dozens of sandwiches are offered, often bearing the names of Mexican states or foreign countries and laden with multiple meats. Juices are another focus of this rollicking cafe that also offers commonplace antojitos in an orange-colored dining room.

A torta at Don Pepe Tortas Y Jugos
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Taqueria El Gallo Azteca

75 Victory Blvd
Staten Island, NY 10301

A nice walk from the ferry on soaring Victory Boulevard, tiny corner El Gallo, with only three tables and a few counter seats, has long been serving the taco needs of Staten Islanders. The quesadillas are equally celebrated, and Pueblan cemitas (round sandwiches on seeded rolls) are served complete with papalo leaves. Don’t miss the fabled hot dog torta.

Hot dog torta at Taqueria El Gallo Azteca
Robert Sietsema/Eater

Coszcal De Allende

6824 3rd Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11220

After a career operating restaurants in Manhattan, Veronica and Luis Felipe moved to Bay Ridge in 2010 and opened Coszcal de Allende, a delightful place that evokes the atmosphere of arts center San Miguel de Allende, Guanajuato. Tacos de cazadores (“hunters’ tacos”) feature a filling of chorizo, avocados, and cheese, while quesadillas arrive stuffed with mushrooms, squash flowers, or huitlacoche. The dish most characteristic of the city is enchiladas de Allende (also referred to as enchiladas Sanmiguelense), stuffed with cheese, mantled with more cheese, and smothered in a piquant salsa verde.

Enchiladas de Allende at Coszcal De Allende
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Doña Zita

1221 Bowery St
Brooklyn, NY 11224

For a dozen years, this wonderful canteen has lingered among the back alleys of Coney Island (on a thoroughfare absurdly called Bowery Street), dishing up gigantic versions of tacos, quesadillas, sopes, and other antojitos, but its most glorious production may be the Pueblan cemita, a sandwich so big your mouth can’t fit around it, with such a wad of fresh papalo leaves you can smell them as the sandwich is handed over the counter.

Pollo milanesa cemita
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Comments

Tacombi is a glaring omission, as per usual for some strange reason.

Birria is the only destination food truck in the world.

It’s missing so many places in East Harlem lol

When are we going to just admit that no one likes Javelina except the bro crowd and ex-Texans. And even the ex-Texans complain about it.

View All Comments
Back to top ↑