clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile
Marlow & Sons by Krieger

The Ultimate NYC Thanksgiving Pie-Buying Guide 2013

View as Map

2013_white_gtruffle_fix13.jpgWith Thanksgiving a little over a week a way, it's time to start thinking about dessert. There's no shortage of pie to be had in this city, but the bakers are taking pre-orders now and the best pies go fast. With that in mind, here's a map of 15 solid bakeries and restaurants that are offering whole pies for the holiday. The list includes pies that range from your classic apple and pumpkin to s'mores, poached pear, and even a few savory options, plus all the crucial info on how and when to order. Take a look:

Read More
Eater maps are curated by editors and aim to reflect a diversity of neighborhoods, cuisines, and prices. Learn more about our editorial process.

Four & Twenty Blackbirds

Copy Link
[Photo]

Dominique Ansel Bakery

Copy Link

The Cronut man himself is making both pumpkin and pecan pies for $38 each, plus apple tartes tatin for $40. Pre-order online for pickup between November 26 and 28. All orders must be placed at least two days in advance.

Pies 'n' Thighs

Copy Link
[Photo]
[Photo]

Marlow & Sons

Copy Link
[Photo]

Bien Cuit

Copy Link
[Photo]

Roni-Sue's Chocolates

Copy Link
[Photo]

Pie Corps

Copy Link
[Photo]

Épicerie Boulud

Copy Link
[Photo]

Bouchon Bakery

Copy Link

Classic apple, pumpkin and pecan pies are $28 each from both New York outposts of Thomas Keller's cafe/bakery mini chain. Order by phone or email cateringnyc@bouchonbakery.com by November 22 at 5 p.m. for pickup November 27 or 28.

Balthazar Boulangerie

Copy Link

The options at Balthazar range from classic pumpkin, apple, or chocolate bourbon pecan pie for $40, to a poached pear galette or a maple-pecan and sweet potato pie mashup for $36 each. Take a look at the full menu, which also includes some non-pie options on the website. Order at least 24 hours in advance for pickup November 27 or 28.

The City Bakery

Copy Link
[Photo]

Momofuku Milk Bar

Copy Link
[Krieger]

BKLYN Larder

Copy Link
[Photo]

Yura On Madison

Copy Link
[Photo]

Loading comments...

Four & Twenty Blackbirds

[Photo]

Dominique Ansel Bakery

The Cronut man himself is making both pumpkin and pecan pies for $38 each, plus apple tartes tatin for $40. Pre-order online for pickup between November 26 and 28. All orders must be placed at least two days in advance.

Pies 'n' Thighs

[Photo]

Baked

[Photo]

Marlow & Sons

[Photo]

Bien Cuit

[Photo]

Roni-Sue's Chocolates

[Photo]

Pie Corps

[Photo]

Épicerie Boulud

[Photo]

Bouchon Bakery

Classic apple, pumpkin and pecan pies are $28 each from both New York outposts of Thomas Keller's cafe/bakery mini chain. Order by phone or email cateringnyc@bouchonbakery.com by November 22 at 5 p.m. for pickup November 27 or 28.

Balthazar Boulangerie

The options at Balthazar range from classic pumpkin, apple, or chocolate bourbon pecan pie for $40, to a poached pear galette or a maple-pecan and sweet potato pie mashup for $36 each. Take a look at the full menu, which also includes some non-pie options on the website. Order at least 24 hours in advance for pickup November 27 or 28.

The City Bakery

[Photo]

Momofuku Milk Bar

[Krieger]

BKLYN Larder

[Photo]

Yura On Madison

[Photo]

Related Maps