clock menu more-arrow no yes
All photos by Nick Solares

New York's Top 12 Steaks for Two

View as Map

2013_brunch_heatmap_helo.jpegThe porterhouse steak for two has long been a staple in traditional NYC chop houses, most notably popularized by Peter Luger Steakhouse. These days we are seeing a proliferation of steaks for two in all sorts of interesting places. And the porterhouse, once the king of beef cuts, might just be losing ground to the rib steak which is coming on strong as a steak to share.


Read More
Note: Restaurants on this map are listed geographically.

1. The Cote de Boeuf at Minetta Tavern

Copy Link
113 Macdougal St
New York, NY 10012
(212) 475-3850
Visit Website

When erstwhile chefs Lee Hanson and Riad Nasr unleashed this monstrous rib steak served with crossed marrow bones back 2009 we suddenly started seeing rib steaks and bone marrow all over town. The two had of course been serving a similarly appointed cote de boeuf sans marrow at Balthazar since the last century. Simply put it is a modern NYC classic, oft imitated, never equaled. ($145, served with marrow bones and gem lettuce salad, price per oz $4)

2. The Rib Steak at The Breslin Bar & Dining Room

Copy Link
16 W 29th St
New York, NY 10016
(212) 679-1939
Visit Website

April Bloomfield’s stripped down, rough and boisterous gastropub serves a glorious rib steak that is basted in its own fat and served with the heart stopping combination of béarnaise sauce and thrice cooked chips. ($4 per oz)

3. The Rib Steak at Restaurant Marc Forgione

Copy Link
134 Reade St.
New York, NY 10013
(212) 941-9401
Visit Website

While Marc Forgione recently opened American Cut, his take on the traditional steakhouse, the rib steak served around the corner at his eponymous restaurant uses the same prime beef but cooks it in a more diligent manner - in Swiss Steal pans rather than a massive broiler. Don't get us wrong, the steak at American Cut are excellent, but the one at Forgione is a cut above. ($144, comes with 2 sides. Cost per oz $3.28)

4. The Rib Steak at Costata

Copy Link
206 Spring St
New York, NY 10012
(212) 334-3320
Visit Website

Costata translates into rib steak from Italian and the costata at Costata is worth naming your restaurant after. Chefs Michael White and PJ Calapa serve up a tomahawk chop that is so long that it contains a generous portion of short rib meat at the end of the bone, a first in our experience. ($126, cost per oz $2.86)

5. The Rib Steak at Momofuku Ssäm Bar

Copy Link
207 2nd Ave
New York, NY 10003
(212) 254-3500
Visit Website

Like most everything at Momofuku traditional form is given new expression. The rib steak here is basted in thyme and garlic and includes the aged fat cap which is generally removed at other restaurants - it might not be as tender as the rest of the steak but it is profoundly funky tasting. The basting liquids - a murky brown bowl of aged beef fat and butter is served alongside making for some serious dunking. (Weight varies, $3 per oz)

6. The Porterhouse Steak at Carbone

Copy Link
181 Thompson St
New York, NY 10012
(212) 254-3000
Visit Website

Mario Carbone honors both his Italian American heritage and indeed his Italian ancestors (likely coal miners) with the porterhouse he serves at his West Village hot spot. Cooked over coals and anointed in lashings of olive oil the 60 day dry aged steak tastes better than the era it evokes, authenticity be damned. Note that the restaurant will make you an offer that you should not refuse - to make steak tartare with the filet side of the porterhouse before cooking the strip. ($150, price per oz $3.75)

7. The Rib Steak at Butter

Copy Link
70 W 45th St
New York, NY 10036
(212) 253-2828
Visit Website

Alex Guarnaschelli's relocated Butter serves up a simply prepared but ethereally tender tomahawk rib steak that tastes especially funky because the chef leaves the dry aged exterior largely untrimmed. She likes the way the “hair of the dog” fortifies the flavor of the steak, we think you will too. ($99, price per oz $2.48)

8. The Porterhouse at Keens Steakhouse

Copy Link
72 W 36th St
New York, NY 10018
(212) 947-3636
Visit Website

This way old school Midtown chop house is long known for its association with the theatrical trade. Fittingly the porterhouse for two here is paraded through the dining room — bone pointing straight up in the air on a sizzling platter that sputters and smokes angrily — a grand entrance for command performance of a porterhouse. ($96.50, price per oz $2.19)

9. Cote de Boeuf at Resto

Copy Link
111 E 29th St
New York, NY 10016
(212) 685-5585
Visit Website

This cut has been an enduring feature of Resto, which has seen more than its fair share of talented chefs come and go. The chefs may have changed but the steak remains a triumph of beef and frites and béarnaise. ($120, price per oz $3.33)

10. The Porterhouse at Peter Luger Steak House

Copy Link
178 Broadway
Brooklyn, NY 11211
(718) 387-7400
Visit Website

It doesn’t get any more classic than Peter Luger Steakhouse. The porterhouse for two here, sliced and doused in lashings of “shine" and hurled across the table at you by gruff but affable waiters, is a right of passage for any true New Yorker. ($99.50, price per oz $2.25)

11. The Porterhouse at Porter House NY

Copy Link
10 Columbus Circle
New York, NY 10019
(212) 823-9500
Visit Website

Porterhouse Steak. Michael Lomonaco named his restaurant not after the cut of beef but after the 19th century taverns which served porter style beer and were known for their hospitality. But that shouldn’t dissuaded you from ordering the porterhouse at Porter House NY which is as tasty as the restaurant is welcoming. ($106, price per oz $2.95)

12. NY Strip at Pietro's

Copy Link
232 East 43rd Street
New York, NY 10174
(212) 682-9760

This upscale red sauce restaurant bills itself as a “Northern Italian” steakhouse although they really only serve NY strips. But no matter — said strip is about as classic as it gets — a massive hunk of dry aged steer is presented whole at the table and is then whisked away for carving. Moments later it reappears as perfectly apportioned square slices. ($100, price per oz $2.24)

Loading comments...

1. The Cote de Boeuf at Minetta Tavern

113 Macdougal St, New York, NY 10012

When erstwhile chefs Lee Hanson and Riad Nasr unleashed this monstrous rib steak served with crossed marrow bones back 2009 we suddenly started seeing rib steaks and bone marrow all over town. The two had of course been serving a similarly appointed cote de boeuf sans marrow at Balthazar since the last century. Simply put it is a modern NYC classic, oft imitated, never equaled. ($145, served with marrow bones and gem lettuce salad, price per oz $4)

113 Macdougal St
New York, NY 10012

2. The Rib Steak at The Breslin Bar & Dining Room

16 W 29th St, New York, NY 10016

April Bloomfield’s stripped down, rough and boisterous gastropub serves a glorious rib steak that is basted in its own fat and served with the heart stopping combination of béarnaise sauce and thrice cooked chips. ($4 per oz)

16 W 29th St
New York, NY 10016

3. The Rib Steak at Restaurant Marc Forgione

134 Reade St., New York, NY 10013

While Marc Forgione recently opened American Cut, his take on the traditional steakhouse, the rib steak served around the corner at his eponymous restaurant uses the same prime beef but cooks it in a more diligent manner - in Swiss Steal pans rather than a massive broiler. Don't get us wrong, the steak at American Cut are excellent, but the one at Forgione is a cut above. ($144, comes with 2 sides. Cost per oz $3.28)

134 Reade St.
New York, NY 10013

4. The Rib Steak at Costata

206 Spring St, New York, NY 10012

Costata translates into rib steak from Italian and the costata at Costata is worth naming your restaurant after. Chefs Michael White and PJ Calapa serve up a tomahawk chop that is so long that it contains a generous portion of short rib meat at the end of the bone, a first in our experience. ($126, cost per oz $2.86)

206 Spring St
New York, NY 10012

5. The Rib Steak at Momofuku Ssäm Bar

207 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003

Like most everything at Momofuku traditional form is given new expression. The rib steak here is basted in thyme and garlic and includes the aged fat cap which is generally removed at other restaurants - it might not be as tender as the rest of the steak but it is profoundly funky tasting. The basting liquids - a murky brown bowl of aged beef fat and butter is served alongside making for some serious dunking. (Weight varies, $3 per oz)

207 2nd Ave
New York, NY 10003

6. The Porterhouse Steak at Carbone

181 Thompson St, New York, NY 10012

Mario Carbone honors both his Italian American heritage and indeed his Italian ancestors (likely coal miners) with the porterhouse he serves at his West Village hot spot. Cooked over coals and anointed in lashings of olive oil the 60 day dry aged steak tastes better than the era it evokes, authenticity be damned. Note that the restaurant will make you an offer that you should not refuse - to make steak tartare with the filet side of the porterhouse before cooking the strip. ($150, price per oz $3.75)

181 Thompson St
New York, NY 10012

7. The Rib Steak at Butter

70 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036

Alex Guarnaschelli's relocated Butter serves up a simply prepared but ethereally tender tomahawk rib steak that tastes especially funky because the chef leaves the dry aged exterior largely untrimmed. She likes the way the “hair of the dog” fortifies the flavor of the steak, we think you will too. ($99, price per oz $2.48)

70 W 45th St
New York, NY 10036

8. The Porterhouse at Keens Steakhouse

72 W 36th St, New York, NY 10018

This way old school Midtown chop house is long known for its association with the theatrical trade. Fittingly the porterhouse for two here is paraded through the dining room — bone pointing straight up in the air on a sizzling platter that sputters and smokes angrily — a grand entrance for command performance of a porterhouse. ($96.50, price per oz $2.19)

72 W 36th St
New York, NY 10018

9. Cote de Boeuf at Resto

111 E 29th St, New York, NY 10016

This cut has been an enduring feature of Resto, which has seen more than its fair share of talented chefs come and go. The chefs may have changed but the steak remains a triumph of beef and frites and béarnaise. ($120, price per oz $3.33)

111 E 29th St
New York, NY 10016

10. The Porterhouse at Peter Luger Steak House

178 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11211

It doesn’t get any more classic than Peter Luger Steakhouse. The porterhouse for two here, sliced and doused in lashings of “shine" and hurled across the table at you by gruff but affable waiters, is a right of passage for any true New Yorker. ($99.50, price per oz $2.25)

178 Broadway
Brooklyn, NY 11211

11. The Porterhouse at Porter House NY

10 Columbus Circle, New York, NY 10019

Porterhouse Steak. Michael Lomonaco named his restaurant not after the cut of beef but after the 19th century taverns which served porter style beer and were known for their hospitality. But that shouldn’t dissuaded you from ordering the porterhouse at Porter House NY which is as tasty as the restaurant is welcoming. ($106, price per oz $2.95)

10 Columbus Circle
New York, NY 10019

12. NY Strip at Pietro's

232 East 43rd Street, New York, NY 10174

This upscale red sauce restaurant bills itself as a “Northern Italian” steakhouse although they really only serve NY strips. But no matter — said strip is about as classic as it gets — a massive hunk of dry aged steer is presented whole at the table and is then whisked away for carving. Moments later it reappears as perfectly apportioned square slices. ($100, price per oz $2.24)

232 East 43rd Street
New York, NY 10174

Related Maps