clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile
Pieces of salmon jut out of a bagel sandwich sliced in half, that’s placed on a white cermaic plate. A sign for Russ & Daughters hangs in the background.
Lox and cream cheese on a bagel at Russ & Daughters.
Bess Adler/Eater NY

23 Iconic Dishes to Try in New York

Where to find coal-oven pizza, fatty brisket, Jamaican beef patties, and al pastor tacos

View as Map
Lox and cream cheese on a bagel at Russ & Daughters.
| Bess Adler/Eater NY

The 23 dishes presented here provide a taste of New York City. They have achieved a distinguished reputation and shaped our modern dining scene. Many originated long ago, while others appeared more recently, and have blown up to legendary status. A few are expensive, while most can be obtained for a few dollars. All are worth trying, and together contribute to what makes our city the most exciting dining destination in the world.

For more information on NYC’s essential establishments, check out the Eater 38, critic Robert Sietsema’s list of inexpensive dining destinations, and guides to burgers, pizzerias, meats, and desserts.

Health experts consider dining out to be a high-risk activity for the unvaccinated; it also poses a risk for the vaccinated, especially in areas with substantial COVID transmission.

Read More

Beef patty at Concourse Jamaican Bakery

Copy Link

This yellow closet of a space a few blocks east of Grand Concourse in Morrisania excels at classic Jamaican baked goods like hardo bread, bulla cake, and coconut totoes, but its premier product is its patties, probably the best in the Bronx. Laced with scotch bonnet peppers, the spicy beef is a favorite, and many opt to make it a full meal by putting the patty — as is conventional — in a puffy coco bread, like a fastball hitting a catcher’s mitt.

A roll wrapped around a yellow empanada.
A beef patty in coco bread at Concourse Bakery.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Franks at Gray's Papaya

Copy Link

Snappy, all-beef hot dogs and gritty but somehow refreshing fruit drinks are the hallmarks of this Upper West Side old-timer founded by Paul Gray in 1973. It also reflects a distinctive New York City frankfurter that originated a century earlier in Coney Island. Topping choices are limited to mustard, sauerkraut, brown-stewed onions, and ketchup (though true New Yorkers would never use latter condiment).

A pair of hot dogs on a red counter with an orange drink.
A pair of franks with a papaya drink at Gray’s.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Soup dumplings at Joe's Shanghai

Copy Link

Plenty of restaurants serve good soup dumplings, but Joe's is the one that kickstarted New York's obsession with this delicacy when it opened in Flushing in 1994. Filled with a scalding broth, these purse-shaped dumplings became an immediate hit. Various branches of Joe’s Shanghai have appeared in Manhattan, still owned by Mei Ping Matsumura, with chef Kiu Sang “Joe” Si.

A wooden steamer basked with white parchment at the base. Eight off-white soup dumplings sit on top of it.
Xiao long bao at Joe’s Shanghai.
Nick Solares/Eater NY

Spicy cumin lamb noodles at Xi'an Famous Foods

Copy Link

Xi’an serves a variety of hand-pulled wheat noodles from northwestern China, but the spicy cumin lamb version rises above the rest. Shredded lamb gets mixed with rice wine, garlic, ginger, onions, chiles, and a whopping 30 different spices for a very fragrant finish. Though the original in the fabled Golden Mall, founded 2005 by David Shi, is now closed, you’ll find locations in three boroughs, managed by Jason Wang, the founder’s son.

Xi’an Famous Foods’ spicy cumin lamb noodles sit on a white plate as a person pulls them up.
Lamb noodles at Xi’an Famous Foods.
Nick Solares/Eater NY

Mutton chop at Keens Steakhouse

Copy Link

Keens, one of the oldest steakhouses in the country (it opened in 1885), is most famous for its mutton chop. This massive, flavorful cut, which is actually a saddle of lamb, is well worth a trip to the restaurant, especially when eaten with a wedge salad or a side of the famed prime-rib hash. Part of the fun is the clubby, 19th-century ambiance, from the days when Keens was a meeting place for actors and other theater professionals.

A white plate placed on a marble table, a silver fork and knife on either side. There’s a salad and a piece of lamb on the white plate.
The mutton chop at Keens Steakhouse.
Nick Solares/Eater NY

Adobada tacos at Los Tacos No. 1

Copy Link

Harlem’s Taco Mix may have popularized al pastor in New York City, but Los Tacos No. 1 perfected it. The small chain of Manhattan taquerias, often just called “número uno,” draws lines of tourists and office workers who often order its carne asada and chicken tacos. But pros know to skip those meats and stick to the adobada. The marinated pork is charred on a twirling spit, then sliced to order and hucked into a flour or corn tortilla (both equally good) with salsa, cilantro, onion, and a wedge of pineapple.

An overhead photograph of tacos, chips, guacamole, and plastic sides of salsa.
Adobada is a cousin of al pastor.
Gary He/Eater NY

Egg Cream at S&P

Copy Link

One of New York City’s most quizzical classic dishes is the egg cream, generally available in flavors that run to chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, and sometimes coffee. What’s so unusual about it? Despite the name, there’s no egg and no cream in the recipe, just seltzer, whole milk, and a flavoring (U-Bet syrup is the default) titrated with seltzer in a tall glass as a long-handled spoon is twirled. It’s a refreshing beverage that’s all the more enjoyable at the new place that’s already a classic, S&P, the next iteration of the old Eisenberg Sandwich Shop, from the owners of Court Street Grocers.

Banana pudding at Magnolia Bakery

Copy Link

The cupcakes at Magnolia Bakery may have become famous from a cameo in Sex and the City, but locals know to go for the banana pudding instead (the cupcakes are too sweet, with too much frosting). The pudding, by contrast, is packed with banana slices, lush vanilla pudding, and vanilla wafers that crumble and squish — the banana flavor is strong in every bite. Multiple locations.

A paper container of yellow pudding with fragmentary cookies embedded.
The banana pudding at Magnolia Bakery.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Khachapuri at Chito Gvrito

Copy Link

The city first became aware of khachapuri a dozen years ago via Georgian cafes in Brighton Beach, and the phenomenon quickly spread. Who wouldn’t love a bread boat filled with molten cheese? We eventually learned that several regional varieties of this national bread existed, but the one called adjaruli khachapuri continues to be foremost in our affection and Chito Gravito near Gramercy Park serves one of the best.

A round bread with two opposing bread handles and cheese and an uncooked egg yolk in a pool in the middle.
The khachapuri at Chito Gvrito.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Coal-oven pizza at John's of Bleecker Street

Copy Link

John’s of Bleecker Street was founded by John Sasso in 1929, making it one of the city’s oldest pizzerias, and one of the originators of the city’s original coal-oven style. The pies come in two sizes, smoking hot and dappled with char, with modest strews of ingredients that can be ordered individually, like black olives, ricotta, pepperoni, Italian sausage, crushed garlic, and sliced onions, in addition to very fresh mozzarella of pillowy softness.

A pizza with sausage and black olives and red sauce
A coal-oven pizza from John’s.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Falafel at Mamoun's

Copy Link

Mamoun's falafel is inexpensive, filling, and delicious. The original Mamoun's on MacDougal introduced the falafel sandwich to the city in 1971, and it became a mega hit, first with NYU students and hippies, but soon with the general public. Falafel also served as a wedge for the introduction of vegetarian dining in the city. With its abundance of fried chickpea fritters, nutty tasting tahini, and fresh greens, onions, and tomatoes, it redefined a quick bite for New Yorkers.

The exterior of Mamoun’s Macdougal Street shop, with a brown-and-white striped awning.
The original Mamoun’s is on MacDougal Street.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Pierogi at Veselka

Copy Link

Pierogi, or as the Ukrainians call them, varenyky, ranked among NYC’s most iconic foods long before the Russian war against Ukraine prompted diners to line up at Veselka. Besides this storied Ukrainian restaurant in the East Village, other Polish and Eastern European establishments have specialized in these stuffed half-moons of dough, which typically enfold ingredients like potatoes, sauerkraut, cheese, ground pork, and even sweet fruit fillings. Veselka has been serving them since 1954.

Pierogies—white crescent-shaped dumplings — that have been pulled out fresh from being boiled.
Veselka’s pierogies hot out of the boiler.
Daniel Krieger/Eater NY

Cronut at Dominique Ansel Bakery

Copy Link

The Cronut has become quintessentially New York since its 2013 invention by French pastry chef Dominique Ansel in his Soho bakery. Soon after its birth, the croissant-doughnut hybrid became a viral sensation, spawned countless knockoffs, and attracted long lines. The flaky, layered dough comes filled with cream, and the bakery prepares a new flavor every month. Those in the know will order ahead to cut the line.

Circular fried doughnuts sit side-by-side with frosting on top.
Cronut at Dominique Ansel Bakery.
Getty

Bagel with lox and cream cheese at Russ & Daughters

Copy Link

NYC might have better bagels, but there is no better bagel and lox experience than the one at Russ & Daughters. Four generations of family ownership and over one hundred years of business give this place a certain sense of gravitas, but it's the quality that keeps people coming back.

Pastrami on rye at Katz's Deli

Copy Link

Katz's serves New York's favorite pastrami sandwich, a meat central to the city’s carnivorous identity, and indeed it may have originated here. At Katz’s it's not just a humongous pile of pink cured beef, but one in which the flavor is richer and emphatically smokier than other popular versions served around town. It's a dish that New Yorkers have craved and relished for over a hundred years. And this is one of the few places that still cuts it by hand.

A butcher chops up pastrami on a wooden block at Katz’s
Pastrami is king at Katz’s.
Eater NY

Big tray chicken at Spicy Village

Copy Link

The “big tray chicken” was introduced to New Yorkers at least a decade ago by Spicy Village. The dish’s origins trace back to the Uyghurs, and was popularized in Henan before it set down here at a restaurant run by Fujianese owners — illustrating the circuitous route by which many iconic dishes often undergo before landing in NYC. Owner Wendy Lian’s version features broad homemade wheat noodles, a fiery red broth laced with Sichuan peppercorns, and nuggets of dark meat chicken — bone-in for extra flavor. Spicy Village’s version is so good it has recently spawned copycats.

A wok brimming with red sauce, chicken tidbits, and pale noodles is served on a white surface.
Big tray chicken at Spicy Village.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Eggplant rollatini at Bamonte's

Copy Link

Many of Brooklyn’s vintage Italian American restaurants serve classics of the genre — like baked ziti, stuffed clams, lasagna, and pork chops with cherry peppers — but king of these dishes is eggplant rollatini. At Bamonte’s, founded by Pasquale Bamonte in 1900, sauteed eggplant is rolled around a ricotta filling, thickly covers it in marinara. The eggplant rollatini is a combination that’s mellow and pungent at the same time.

Two big humps of red sauce-cloaked eggplant has  ricotta cheese oozing out at the edges.
Eggplant rollatini at Bamonte’s.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Rice ball at Ferdinando's Focacceria

Copy Link

Other than the risotto of northern Italy, rice is not encountered too often in most Italian restaurants — but in Sicily it’s a staple, and became more so when Sicilian immigrants arrived here. With the ready availability of inexpensive rice, the rice ball ballooned in size, luxuriantly stuffed with ground beef and beef, and eventually smothered in tomato sauce and cheese. It is now found in pizza parlors and Sicilian restaurants all over the city.

A floral plate has a rice ball covered in red sauce and cheese in a bowl.
One rice ball is an entire meal at Ferdinando’s.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Fried chicken at Mitchell's Soul Food

Copy Link

Founded in the 1970s by James “JB” Bromell and Johnsie Mitchell, this is one of the few remaining Black-women-run soul food destinations that once dominated Harlem, Bedford-Stuyvesant, and Prospect Heights. The signature is fried chicken, cooked in the Carolina style, with only a light dusting of flour and a crisp, intact skin.

A drumstick and thigh along with green vegetables sits on a white plate with a blue and red rim.
Fried chicken with sides and cornbread at Mitchell’s.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Fatty brisket at Hometown Bar-B-Que

Copy Link

It wasn’t until the ’90s that New York got real Texas barbecue at Stick to Your Ribs in Long Island City. Since then, Hometown Bar-B-Que has stolen the show. The massive Red Hook restaurant is widely considered to be the city’s best barbecue joint, and fans swear by the fatty brisket. It runs at an eye-popping $40 a pound — we know, we know — but it’s plenty filling with a spice-rubbed crust that’s superior to the other smoked meats here and elsewhere.

Three slabs of fatty brisket are arranged on a stainless steel lunch tray.
Ask for the fatty brisket at the counter.
Eater NY

Jerk chicken at Peppa's

Copy Link

Founded by Gavin Hussey (nicknamed Peppa) in the ‘90s, this storefront produces some of the city’s best Jamaican jerk chicken. And while jerk pork was the standard dish back in Jamaica, jerk chicken is more popular in Brooklyn. Finished over flame, Peppa’s rendition has a charred exterior and slight vinegary tang. The jerk sauce adds fiery notes of allspice and scotch bonnet pepper.

A hand wearing a white glove skewers pieces of charred jerk chicken on a grill.
Peppa’s jerk chicken.
Louise Palmberg/Eater NY

Roast beef sandwich at Brennan & Carr

Copy Link

Established in 1938 in Sheepshead Bay when the surrounding area was still farmland, Brennan & Carr provides NYC’s answer to LA’s fabled french dip sandwich. A flavorful pile of beef, awash in its steaming juices layers a kaiser roll. The beefy aroma arises from the sandwich like an early morning fog.

A roast beef sandwich drenched with beef broth on a plate is photographed in a cross section.
Roast beef at Brennan & Carr.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Spumoni at L&B Spumoni Gardens

Copy Link

Red-sauce restaurant and Gravesend institution L & B Spumoni Gardens comes alive in the summer when staff works the walk-up window selling its namesake spumoni. Chocolate, pistachio, and vanilla (with candied fruit) come together for a colorful, tri-colored treat that’s as photogenic as it is tasty. The spumoni is best enjoyed on a warm evening after a slice of the thick-crusted, rectangular Sicilian pizza.

A hand holds a white paper cup with three colors of ice cream in it, green, yellow, and brown.
A scoop of spumoni, and no you can’t have a spoon.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Beef patty at Concourse Jamaican Bakery

This yellow closet of a space a few blocks east of Grand Concourse in Morrisania excels at classic Jamaican baked goods like hardo bread, bulla cake, and coconut totoes, but its premier product is its patties, probably the best in the Bronx. Laced with scotch bonnet peppers, the spicy beef is a favorite, and many opt to make it a full meal by putting the patty — as is conventional — in a puffy coco bread, like a fastball hitting a catcher’s mitt.

A roll wrapped around a yellow empanada.
A beef patty in coco bread at Concourse Bakery.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Franks at Gray's Papaya

Snappy, all-beef hot dogs and gritty but somehow refreshing fruit drinks are the hallmarks of this Upper West Side old-timer founded by Paul Gray in 1973. It also reflects a distinctive New York City frankfurter that originated a century earlier in Coney Island. Topping choices are limited to mustard, sauerkraut, brown-stewed onions, and ketchup (though true New Yorkers would never use latter condiment).

A pair of hot dogs on a red counter with an orange drink.
A pair of franks with a papaya drink at Gray’s.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Soup dumplings at Joe's Shanghai

Plenty of restaurants serve good soup dumplings, but Joe's is the one that kickstarted New York's obsession with this delicacy when it opened in Flushing in 1994. Filled with a scalding broth, these purse-shaped dumplings became an immediate hit. Various branches of Joe’s Shanghai have appeared in Manhattan, still owned by Mei Ping Matsumura, with chef Kiu Sang “Joe” Si.

A wooden steamer basked with white parchment at the base. Eight off-white soup dumplings sit on top of it.
Xiao long bao at Joe’s Shanghai.
Nick Solares/Eater NY

Spicy cumin lamb noodles at Xi'an Famous Foods

Xi’an serves a variety of hand-pulled wheat noodles from northwestern China, but the spicy cumin lamb version rises above the rest. Shredded lamb gets mixed with rice wine, garlic, ginger, onions, chiles, and a whopping 30 different spices for a very fragrant finish. Though the original in the fabled Golden Mall, founded 2005 by David Shi, is now closed, you’ll find locations in three boroughs, managed by Jason Wang, the founder’s son.

Xi’an Famous Foods’ spicy cumin lamb noodles sit on a white plate as a person pulls them up.
Lamb noodles at Xi’an Famous Foods.
Nick Solares/Eater NY

Mutton chop at Keens Steakhouse

Keens, one of the oldest steakhouses in the country (it opened in 1885), is most famous for its mutton chop. This massive, flavorful cut, which is actually a saddle of lamb, is well worth a trip to the restaurant, especially when eaten with a wedge salad or a side of the famed prime-rib hash. Part of the fun is the clubby, 19th-century ambiance, from the days when Keens was a meeting place for actors and other theater professionals.

A white plate placed on a marble table, a silver fork and knife on either side. There’s a salad and a piece of lamb on the white plate.
The mutton chop at Keens Steakhouse.
Nick Solares/Eater NY

Adobada tacos at Los Tacos No. 1

Harlem’s Taco Mix may have popularized al pastor in New York City, but Los Tacos No. 1 perfected it. The small chain of Manhattan taquerias, often just called “número uno,” draws lines of tourists and office workers who often order its carne asada and chicken tacos. But pros know to skip those meats and stick to the adobada. The marinated pork is charred on a twirling spit, then sliced to order and hucked into a flour or corn tortilla (both equally good) with salsa, cilantro, onion, and a wedge of pineapple.

An overhead photograph of tacos, chips, guacamole, and plastic sides of salsa.
Adobada is a cousin of al pastor.
Gary He/Eater NY

Egg Cream at S&P

One of New York City’s most quizzical classic dishes is the egg cream, generally available in flavors that run to chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, and sometimes coffee. What’s so unusual about it? Despite the name, there’s no egg and no cream in the recipe, just seltzer, whole milk, and a flavoring (U-Bet syrup is the default) titrated with seltzer in a tall glass as a long-handled spoon is twirled. It’s a refreshing beverage that’s all the more enjoyable at the new place that’s already a classic, S&P, the next iteration of the old Eisenberg Sandwich Shop, from the owners of Court Street Grocers.

Banana pudding at Magnolia Bakery

The cupcakes at Magnolia Bakery may have become famous from a cameo in Sex and the City, but locals know to go for the banana pudding instead (the cupcakes are too sweet, with too much frosting). The pudding, by contrast, is packed with banana slices, lush vanilla pudding, and vanilla wafers that crumble and squish — the banana flavor is strong in every bite. Multiple locations.

A paper container of yellow pudding with fragmentary cookies embedded.
The banana pudding at Magnolia Bakery.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Khachapuri at Chito Gvrito

The city first became aware of khachapuri a dozen years ago via Georgian cafes in Brighton Beach, and the phenomenon quickly spread. Who wouldn’t love a bread boat filled with molten cheese? We eventually learned that several regional varieties of this national bread existed, but the one called adjaruli khachapuri continues to be foremost in our affection and Chito Gravito near Gramercy Park serves one of the best.

A round bread with two opposing bread handles and cheese and an uncooked egg yolk in a pool in the middle.
The khachapuri at Chito Gvrito.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Coal-oven pizza at John's of Bleecker Street

John’s of Bleecker Street was founded by John Sasso in 1929, making it one of the city’s oldest pizzerias, and one of the originators of the city’s original coal-oven style. The pies come in two sizes, smoking hot and dappled with char, with modest strews of ingredients that can be ordered individually, like black olives, ricotta, pepperoni, Italian sausage, crushed garlic, and sliced onions, in addition to very fresh mozzarella of pillowy softness.

A pizza with sausage and black olives and red sauce
A coal-oven pizza from John’s.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Falafel at Mamoun's

Mamoun's falafel is inexpensive, filling, and delicious. The original Mamoun's on MacDougal introduced the falafel sandwich to the city in 1971, and it became a mega hit, first with NYU students and hippies, but soon with the general public. Falafel also served as a wedge for the introduction of vegetarian dining in the city. With its abundance of fried chickpea fritters, nutty tasting tahini, and fresh greens, onions, and tomatoes, it redefined a quick bite for New Yorkers.

The exterior of Mamoun’s Macdougal Street shop, with a brown-and-white striped awning.
The original Mamoun’s is on MacDougal Street.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Pierogi at Veselka

Pierogi, or as the Ukrainians call them, varenyky, ranked among NYC’s most iconic foods long before the Russian war against Ukraine prompted diners to line up at Veselka. Besides this storied Ukrainian restaurant in the East Village, other Polish and Eastern European establishments have specialized in these stuffed half-moons of dough, which typically enfold ingredients like potatoes, sauerkraut, cheese, ground pork, and even sweet fruit fillings. Veselka has been serving them since 1954.

Pierogies—white crescent-shaped dumplings — that have been pulled out fresh from being boiled.
Veselka’s pierogies hot out of the boiler.
Daniel Krieger/Eater NY

Cronut at Dominique Ansel Bakery

The Cronut has become quintessentially New York since its 2013 invention by French pastry chef Dominique Ansel in his Soho bakery. Soon after its birth, the croissant-doughnut hybrid became a viral sensation, spawned countless knockoffs, and attracted long lines. The flaky, layered dough comes filled with cream, and the bakery prepares a new flavor every month. Those in the know will order ahead to cut the line.

Circular fried doughnuts sit side-by-side with frosting on top.
Cronut at Dominique Ansel Bakery.
Getty

Bagel with lox and cream cheese at Russ & Daughters

NYC might have better bagels, but there is no better bagel and lox experience than the one at Russ & Daughters. Four generations of family ownership and over one hundred years of business give this place a certain sense of gravitas, but it's the quality that keeps people coming back.

Pastrami on rye at Katz's Deli

Katz's serves New York's favorite pastrami sandwich, a meat central to the city’s carnivorous identity, and indeed it may have originated here. At Katz’s it's not just a humongous pile of pink cured beef, but one in which the flavor is richer and emphatically smokier than other popular versions served around town. It's a dish that New Yorkers have craved and relished for over a hundred years. And this is one of the few places that still cuts it by hand.

A butcher chops up pastrami on a wooden block at Katz’s
Pastrami is king at Katz’s.
Eater NY

Related Maps

Big tray chicken at Spicy Village

The “big tray chicken” was introduced to New Yorkers at least a decade ago by Spicy Village. The dish’s origins trace back to the Uyghurs, and was popularized in Henan before it set down here at a restaurant run by Fujianese owners — illustrating the circuitous route by which many iconic dishes often undergo before landing in NYC. Owner Wendy Lian’s version features broad homemade wheat noodles, a fiery red broth laced with Sichuan peppercorns, and nuggets of dark meat chicken — bone-in for extra flavor. Spicy Village’s version is so good it has recently spawned copycats.

A wok brimming with red sauce, chicken tidbits, and pale noodles is served on a white surface.
Big tray chicken at Spicy Village.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Eggplant rollatini at Bamonte's

Many of Brooklyn’s vintage Italian American restaurants serve classics of the genre — like baked ziti, stuffed clams, lasagna, and pork chops with cherry peppers — but king of these dishes is eggplant rollatini. At Bamonte’s, founded by Pasquale Bamonte in 1900, sauteed eggplant is rolled around a ricotta filling, thickly covers it in marinara. The eggplant rollatini is a combination that’s mellow and pungent at the same time.