clock menu more-arrow no yes
Park Avenue Autumn.
Park Avenue Autumn.
Bess Adler

Nine New Fall Cocktails to Drink Before the Season's Up

These new restaurants and bars are entering their first fall season. Here's what to drink at each one.

View as Map
Park Avenue Autumn.
| Bess Adler

Fall doesn't just mean lower temperatures and changing leaves— it's also the time to bring out new cocktail menus. Today, as a part of Eater's Cocktail Week, here's a look at some of the best of the boozy season from establishments that have opened in the past year. There's hyper-local maple syrup, root beer for adults, and even a tiki-inspired drink served inside a big striped squash. Got another new autumn favorite? Leave it in the comments.

Read More
Note: Restaurants on this map are listed geographically.
If you book a reservation through an Eater link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics policy.

1. SixtyFive Bar at The Rainbow Room

Copy Link
(212) 632-5000
Visit Website

This month, The Rainbow Room started serving again after a five-year closure. And with the historic restaurant— first opened in 1934— there's now new bar SixtyFive, open Monday through Friday from 5 p.m. to midnight. Here, try the Room With a View ($25): rum, Cointreau, cider, and nutmeg. [Krieger]

2. Empellón Al Pastor

Copy Link
132 Saint Marks Pl
New York, NY 10009
(212) 367-0999
Visit Website

In mid-October, Alex Stupak and his team opened the third Empellon at the corner of St. Mark's Place and Avenue A. It's the most casual of his restaurants, and has the biggest focus on drinks. While some of the cocktails will seem familiar to patrons of his other establishments, a few drinks can currently be found only at Al Pastor. These include a not-too-sweet and pleasantly spiced agave root beer ($10) with birch-infused blanco tequila and root liqueur. [Nick Solares]

3. The Gander

Copy Link
15 W 18th St
New York, NY 10011
(212) 229-9500
Visit Website

At Jesse Scenker's The Gander, try the Cold Toddy ($14). A take on the usually hot classic, this version has seasonal flavor staples like Earl Grey, honey, and lemon, plus dandelion and burdock bitters, amaro, and the guest's choice of vodka or gin. [Krieger]

4. Boqueria

Copy Link
1460 2nd Avenue
New York, NY
(212) 343-2227
Visit Website

At the latest outpost of Spanish crowd-pleaser Boqueria, which started serving at the beginning of October on the Upper East Side, there's a seasonal sangria de manzana ($11/$39) made with Basque cider, wine, apple juice, vanilla, honey, and a whiskey-apple puree. [Photo (SoHo location)]

5. Blenheim

Copy Link
Read Review |
283 W 12th St
New York, NY 10014
(212) 243-7073
Visit Website

About the rye Maple Flip ($13) at farm-to-table West Village spot Blenheim, bar manager Jonathan Russell says he uses "maple syrup from the farm, reduced down with fall spices— cinnamon, cloves, nutmeg, black pepper, white pepper, and orange peel, as well heirloom citrus peels." Egg whites add a creaminess to the drink that's balanced out with lemon. [Bess Adler]

6. Park Avenue Autumn

Copy Link
360 Park Avenue
New York, NY
(212) 951-7111
Visit Website

It's decorative gourd season, and Park Avenue Autumn is getting in on the celebration with this Mai Chai ($18), a drink consisting of rum, toasted pepita orgeat syrup, lime juice, and pumpkin butter— and an umbrella. But here's the real kicker: It's served in a hollowed out delicata squash. [Bess Adler]

7. Montana's Trail House

Copy Link
445 Troutman St.
Brooklyn, NY 11237
(917) 966-1666
Visit Website

While some of the drinks at this Bushwick bistro have spooky names fitting for the season— "Granny Witch" and the 30-day barrel-aged "Curse Thrower" among them— only a few are new additions to the menu. Try the Cure Light Wounds ($11), a highball of rye whiskey, smoked maple syrup, Fernet Branca, and ginger beer, or the boozier, stirred Natural Twenty ($10) with brown butter bourbon and orange liqueur. [Photo]

8. Featherweight

Copy Link
135 Graham Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11206
(202) 907-3372
Visit Website

Graham Avenue's Featherweight opened last fall in a space adjacent to Sweet Science. This season, look for The Scabbard ($11), a drink made with Pimm's, aged rum, house cinnamon falernum, fresh pineapple juice, and cinnamon and pineapple to garnish. There's also a Manhattan Special ($11) named after the espresso soda: blended scotch, espresso liqueur, coconut cream, and soda with a scotch float and chocolate powder.

9. Bâtard

Copy Link
Read Review |
239 W Broadway
New York, NY 10013
(212) 219-2777
Visit Website

The drink menu at Batard focuses on classics, and for the season, the bar team has swapped out warmer weather favorites like the aviation and Pimm's cup for an Applejack Rabbit ($13) with bonded apple brandy, orange juice, maple syrup, and lemon as well as the Hanky Panky with gin, sweet vermouth, and Fernet Branca. [Adam Lerner]

1. SixtyFive Bar at The Rainbow Room

New York, NY

This month, The Rainbow Room started serving again after a five-year closure. And with the historic restaurant— first opened in 1934— there's now new bar SixtyFive, open Monday through Friday from 5 p.m. to midnight. Here, try the Room With a View ($25): rum, Cointreau, cider, and nutmeg. [Krieger]

2. Empellón Al Pastor

132 Saint Marks Pl, New York, NY 10009

In mid-October, Alex Stupak and his team opened the third Empellon at the corner of St. Mark's Place and Avenue A. It's the most casual of his restaurants, and has the biggest focus on drinks. While some of the cocktails will seem familiar to patrons of his other establishments, a few drinks can currently be found only at Al Pastor. These include a not-too-sweet and pleasantly spiced agave root beer ($10) with birch-infused blanco tequila and root liqueur. [Nick Solares]

132 Saint Marks Pl
New York, NY 10009

3. The Gander

15 W 18th St, New York, NY 10011

At Jesse Scenker's The Gander, try the Cold Toddy ($14). A take on the usually hot classic, this version has seasonal flavor staples like Earl Grey, honey, and lemon, plus dandelion and burdock bitters, amaro, and the guest's choice of vodka or gin. [Krieger]

15 W 18th St
New York, NY 10011

4. Boqueria

1460 2nd Avenue, New York, NY

At the latest outpost of Spanish crowd-pleaser Boqueria, which started serving at the beginning of October on the Upper East Side, there's a seasonal sangria de manzana ($11/$39) made with Basque cider, wine, apple juice, vanilla, honey, and a whiskey-apple puree. [Photo (SoHo location)]

1460 2nd Avenue
New York, NY

5. Blenheim

283 W 12th St, New York, NY 10014
Read Review |

About the rye Maple Flip ($13) at farm-to-table West Village spot Blenheim, bar manager Jonathan Russell says he uses "maple syrup from the farm, reduced down with fall spices— cinnamon, cloves, nutmeg, black pepper, white pepper, and orange peel, as well heirloom citrus peels." Egg whites add a creaminess to the drink that's balanced out with lemon. [Bess Adler]

283 W 12th St
New York, NY 10014

6. Park Avenue Autumn

360 Park Avenue, New York, NY

It's decorative gourd season, and Park Avenue Autumn is getting in on the celebration with this Mai Chai ($18), a drink consisting of rum, toasted pepita orgeat syrup, lime juice, and pumpkin butter— and an umbrella. But here's the real kicker: It's served in a hollowed out delicata squash. [Bess Adler]

360 Park Avenue
New York, NY

7. Montana's Trail House

445 Troutman St., Brooklyn, NY 11237

While some of the drinks at this Bushwick bistro have spooky names fitting for the season— "Granny Witch" and the 30-day barrel-aged "Curse Thrower" among them— only a few are new additions to the menu. Try the Cure Light Wounds ($11), a highball of rye whiskey, smoked maple syrup, Fernet Branca, and ginger beer, or the boozier, stirred Natural Twenty ($10) with brown butter bourbon and orange liqueur. [Photo]

445 Troutman St.
Brooklyn, NY 11237

8. Featherweight

135 Graham Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206

Graham Avenue's Featherweight opened last fall in a space adjacent to Sweet Science. This season, look for The Scabbard ($11), a drink made with Pimm's, aged rum, house cinnamon falernum, fresh pineapple juice, and cinnamon and pineapple to garnish. There's also a Manhattan Special ($11) named after the espresso soda: blended scotch, espresso liqueur, coconut cream, and soda with a scotch float and chocolate powder.

135 Graham Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11206

9. Bâtard

239 W Broadway, New York, NY 10013
Read Review |

The drink menu at Batard focuses on classics, and for the season, the bar team has swapped out warmer weather favorites like the aviation and Pimm's cup for an Applejack Rabbit ($13) with bonded apple brandy, orange juice, maple syrup, and lemon as well as the Hanky Panky with gin, sweet vermouth, and Fernet Branca. [Adam Lerner]

239 W Broadway
New York, NY 10013

Related Maps