clock menu more-arrow no yes

22 Superb Sandwich Shops in NYC

From old-school, meat-stuffed heroes to flavorful and affordable banh mi

View as Map

In New York, a sandwich is an argument waiting to happen. While Americans all over can name their favorites, in Manhattan alone, the variety of delis, pita shacks, torta-slinging Mexican cafes, and newfangled American lunch stands is enough to keep any enthusiast of the bread-based meal busy for years.

But each genre has its stars. These are the sandwich-devoted venues both old-school and new to check off the bucket list. And no, burgers still don’t count.

Note: This list is arranged geographically, north to south.

Read More
Note: Restaurants on this map are listed geographically.

1. Casa Della Mozzarella

Copy Link
604 E 187th St
Bronx, NY 10458
(718) 364-3867

The old-school shop in Bronx’s Little Italy gets all the credit it deserves for its housemade cheeses, sold alongside other Italian prepared foods and packaged goods. Have the staff fold its exceptional cream-filled burrata and prosciutto into a ciabatta with olives and peppers.

2. Sal, Kris & Charlie's Deli

Copy Link
33-12 23rd Ave
Astoria, NY 11105
(718) 278-9240

As if to outdo its many deli competitors, this Astoria shop introduced the Bomb, which quickly became cultishly beloved. The footlong beast is awe-inspiring even before consumption, filled with a veritable rainbow of meats and cheeses packed on a crusty sub roll with vegetables: pepperoni, ham, salami, turkey, mortadella, American, Swiss, and provolone. Finishing it deserves some kind of award. Cash only.

Sal, Kris & Charlie's Deli
Tonya J./Yelp

3. Salumeria Biellese Delicatessen

Copy Link
378 8th Ave
New York, NY 10001
(212) 736-7376
Visit Website

Since 1925, this salumeria has been dishing out traditional sausages and cured meats inspired by the Piedmont region of Italy. Its deli menu includes cold cuts, as well as hot heroes like the comforting meatball parm. Cash only.

Salumeria Biellese
Veronica S./Yelp

4. Shorty's

Copy Link
66 Madison Ave
New York, NY 10016
(212) 725-3900
Visit Website

Shorty’s claims to serve New York’s “most authentic” Philly-style cheesesteaks, and Philadelphians tend to agree. The mini-chain actually gets its bread shipped from the City of Brotherly Love and then bakes it onsite, making the melty, oozing sandwich truly the closest thing to catching a train for the specialty. There are additional locations in Hell’s Kitchen, the Financial District, and the Upper East Side.

Shorty's
Shorty’s

5. Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop

Copy Link
174 5th Ave
New York, NY 10010
(212) 675-5096
Visit Website

Open since 1929, this Flatiron diner seems to have changed little over time. The narrow luncheonette is stained in grease, and the servers are enjoyably sassy. The deli-style sandwiches are consistently superb, especially the Reuben, which is plenty of food for two.

Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop Photo via Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop/Facebook

6. Taïm

Copy Link
222 Waverly Pl
New York, NY 10014
(212) 691-1287
Visit Website

One thing New York is not short on is places to grab falafel. Taïm, which translates to tasty in Hebrew, stands out in the West Village not just for its signature chickpea-filled pita, but for the freshness and intense flavors of all its vegetarian dishes, including cauliflower shawarma. Chef Einat Admony and her husband Stefan Nafziger launched the original Nolita outpost in 2005 and are also behind Bar Bolonat. There are additional locations in Midtown East, with ones upcoming in the Financial District and Flatiron.

Taim cauliflower sandwich Courtesy of Einat Admony

7. Eastern District

Copy Link
1053 Manhattan Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11222
(718) 349-1432
Visit Website

Part grocery with growlers of beers on draft and a remarkable selection of cheeses, Greenpoint’s Eastern District also gets its dairy and meats into some tasty sandwiches. Wash down hot soppressata on a baguette with a local brew.

Eastern District
Steven M./Yelp

8. La Panineria Italiana

Copy Link
1 W 8th St
New York, NY 10011
(917) 388-3257
Visit Website

This Greenwich Village panini bar focuses on the pressed sandwich made simply with refined ingredients imported from Italy, though it has other options like pasta salads and pastries plus wine and beer.

La Panineria
La Panineria/Yelp

9. Faicco's

Copy Link
260 Bleecker St
New York, NY 10014
(212) 243-1974

A West Village institution, Faicco’s serves its fragrant sausages and other meats to faithful customers, but it also assembles enviable sandwiches, including a mouth-watering Italian special that’s more animal than anything else, with a dense layering of prosciutto, ham, and soppressata.

Faicco's
Nate B./Yelp

10. Alidoro

Copy Link
105 Sullivan St # 2
New York, NY 10012
(212) 334-5179
Visit Website

Alidoro brings Italian delicacies to its over 40 sandwiches, from salami and soppressata to capicola and mortadella, all served on crusty white or whole wheat bread. Prepare for long lunchtime lines of die-hard fans. There are additional locations in Noho and Midtown.

11. Sunny & Annie's Deli

Copy Link
94 Avenue B
New York, NY 10009
(212) 677-3131
Visit Website

Rarely does a bodega sandwich linger in the mind, but this corner store blows away expectations with its crafty renditions. The popular Vietnamese-inspired Pho Real combines beef, cilantro, bean sprouts, basil, and Sriracha in a sub. It doesn’t hurt that the place is open 24 hours.

Sunny & Annie's Deli
Huy H./Yelp

12. Frankel's Delicatessen & Appetizing

Copy Link
631 Manhattan Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11222
(718) 389-2302
Visit Website

Upper West Side-raised brothers Zach and Alex Frankel opened Frankel’s to bring Jewish fare to Greenpoint, particularly smoked fish and meats. Get the pastrami with egg and cheese at breakfast, or opt for The Number One bagel with pastrami salmon and dill cucumber.

A pastrami and egg sandwich
Frankel's
Frankel’s

13. Russ & Daughters

Copy Link
179 E Houston St
New York, NY 10002
(212) 475-4880 ext. 1
Visit Website

The tiny Lower East Side shop, dating back to 1914, is still run by the same family and packed every weekend with devotees chatting as they wait in long lines for bagels stuffed with cream cheese and seafood specialties. The number of smoked salmons is dizzying, but also seek out the fish roe and indulgent belly lox. There’s a nearby sit-down cafe and an outpost in the Jewish Museum as well.

Russ & Daughters
Russ & Daughters/Instagram

14. Parisi Bakery

Copy Link
198 Mott St
New York, NY 10012
(212) 226-6378
Visit Website

A stroll through Little Italy isn’t quite the same without a stop into Parisi Bakery, a bakery established in 1903 that also turns out its own inimitable heros. The admirably uncompromising Dennis melds fried chicken cutlet, prosciutto, mozzarella, tomato, balsamic vinegar, and herbs into one joyful mess. Cash only.

Parisi Bakery Robert Sietsema

15. Tiny’s Giant Sandwich Shop

Copy Link
129 Rivington St
New York, NY 10002
(212) 228-4919
Visit Website

This small Lower East Side counter serves some genuinely hulking sandwiches. The broad menu of mostly American riffs goes from breakfast melts to lunch fare with worthy vegetarian choices. But meat-eaters should pick the tangy Spicy Rizzak, with turkey, bacon, cheddar, tomato, onion, and chipotle mayo on a toasted sesame semolina hero.

Tinys Giant Sandwich Shop
William C./Yelp

16. Foster Sundry

Copy Link
215 Knickerbocker Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11237
(718) 569-8426
Visit Website

While it may technically be a butcher shop, to Bushwick locals Foster Sundry is a destination for the sandwiches it stuffs with rich carnivorous delights. The kitchen slings various biscuits with eggs and ham all day, and its other options get thoughtful toppings, like the Vietnamese-inspired house roast beef with nuoc mam mayo, herbs, and pickled vegetables on a toasted hoagie.

17. Bread & Spread

Copy Link
147 Front St
Brooklyn, NY 11201
(718) 625-2220
Visit Website

This Dumbo counter serves only what’s in its name, using local ingredients. In addition to breakfast-only offerings, the regular sandwich menu is concise and reliable. Get the popular and meaty porchetta, made with kurobuta pork belly, pickled red onion, arugula, red pepper spread, and aged provolone on ciabatta.

18. Defonte's Sandwich Shop

Copy Link
379 Columbia St
Brooklyn, NY 11231
(718) 625-8052

Since 1922, this local Italian sandwich shop has served heaping portions of cured pork on heros to workers and passersby in Red Hook. The signature sub is the colossal Nicky Special, layered with a trio of ham, salami, and capocollo, plus fried slices of eggplant, provolone, and hot peppers mixed with oregano and pickled vegetables. Cash only.

Defonte's Sandwich Shop
Wendy F./Yelp

19. Court Street Grocers

Copy Link
485 Court St
Brooklyn, NY 11231
(718) 722-7229
Visit Website

The ambitious menu of this Carroll Gardens lunch staple from Eric Finkelstein and Matt Ross, who have since expanded it beyond Brooklyn, varies from popular egg-based breakfast sandwiches to classic heroes, American classics, and vegetarian-friendly options including a broccoli reuben. There are additional locations in Red Hook and Greenwich Village, and soon, a Williamsburg outpost will open in the old Saltie space.

Court Street Grocers
Trevor L./Yelp

20. Ends Meat

Copy Link
254 36th St
Brooklyn, NY 11232
(718) 801-8895
Visit Website

This whole-animal salumeria in Sunset Park puts its strung-cured meats into some flavor-bomb sandwiches with unusual mixes of toppings. In one highlight, pork pate and bacon make friends with mortadella, kimchi, cilantro, red onions, and mayo.

Ends Meat
Brenda C./Yelp

21. Don Pepe Tortas y Jugos

Copy Link
3908 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11232
(718) 435-3326
Visit Website

This Sunset Park Mexican spot juices an epic number of fruits and vegetables, but it also makes some mean tortas, or rolls stuffed with an equally diverse number of ingredients, from chorizo to breaded chicken, thrown on a griddle.

Don Pepe Tortas y Jugos
Felicia S./Yelp

22. Ba Xuyên

Copy Link
4222 8th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11232
(718) 633-6601

While bánh mì may have become fashionable in all kinds of restaurants, this no-frills Vietnamese restaurant in Sunset Park delivers the sandwich in fine form with a number of variations but no unnecessarily fussy spins. Get one with pate and cold cuts, grilled pork, or meatballs. The pale-green, creamy avocado shake is a favorite accompaniment. Cash only.

Ba Xuyên
Liana L./Yelp

Loading comments...

1. Casa Della Mozzarella

604 E 187th St, Bronx, NY 10458

The old-school shop in Bronx’s Little Italy gets all the credit it deserves for its housemade cheeses, sold alongside other Italian prepared foods and packaged goods. Have the staff fold its exceptional cream-filled burrata and prosciutto into a ciabatta with olives and peppers.

604 E 187th St
Bronx, NY 10458

2. Sal, Kris & Charlie's Deli

33-12 23rd Ave, Astoria, NY 11105
Sal, Kris & Charlie's Deli
Tonya J./Yelp

As if to outdo its many deli competitors, this Astoria shop introduced the Bomb, which quickly became cultishly beloved. The footlong beast is awe-inspiring even before consumption, filled with a veritable rainbow of meats and cheeses packed on a crusty sub roll with vegetables: pepperoni, ham, salami, turkey, mortadella, American, Swiss, and provolone. Finishing it deserves some kind of award. Cash only.

33-12 23rd Ave
Astoria, NY 11105

3. Salumeria Biellese Delicatessen

378 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001
Salumeria Biellese
Veronica S./Yelp

Since 1925, this salumeria has been dishing out traditional sausages and cured meats inspired by the Piedmont region of Italy. Its deli menu includes cold cuts, as well as hot heroes like the comforting meatball parm. Cash only.

378 8th Ave
New York, NY 10001

4. Shorty's

66 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016
Shorty's
Shorty’s

Shorty’s claims to serve New York’s “most authentic” Philly-style cheesesteaks, and Philadelphians tend to agree. The mini-chain actually gets its bread shipped from the City of Brotherly Love and then bakes it onsite, making the melty, oozing sandwich truly the closest thing to catching a train for the specialty. There are additional locations in Hell’s Kitchen, the Financial District, and the Upper East Side.

66 Madison Ave
New York, NY 10016

5. Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop

174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010
Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop Photo via Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop/Facebook

Open since 1929, this Flatiron diner seems to have changed little over time. The narrow luncheonette is stained in grease, and the servers are enjoyably sassy. The deli-style sandwiches are consistently superb, especially the Reuben, which is plenty of food for two.

174 5th Ave
New York, NY 10010

6. Taïm

222 Waverly Pl, New York, NY 10014
Taim cauliflower sandwich Courtesy of Einat Admony

One thing New York is not short on is places to grab falafel. Taïm, which translates to tasty in Hebrew, stands out in the West Village not just for its signature chickpea-filled pita, but for the freshness and intense flavors of all its vegetarian dishes, including cauliflower shawarma. Chef Einat Admony and her husband Stefan Nafziger launched the original Nolita outpost in 2005 and are also behind Bar Bolonat. There are additional locations in Midtown East, with ones upcoming in the Financial District and Flatiron.

222 Waverly Pl
New York, NY 10014

7. Eastern District

1053 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222
Eastern District
Steven M./Yelp

Part grocery with growlers of beers on draft and a remarkable selection of cheeses, Greenpoint’s Eastern District also gets its dairy and meats into some tasty sandwiches. Wash down hot soppressata on a baguette with a local brew.

1053 Manhattan Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11222

8. La Panineria Italiana

1 W 8th St, New York, NY 10011
La Panineria
La Panineria/Yelp

This Greenwich Village panini bar focuses on the pressed sandwich made simply with refined ingredients imported from Italy, though it has other options like pasta salads and pastries plus wine and beer.

1 W 8th St
New York, NY 10011

9. Faicco's

260 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
Faicco's
Nate B./Yelp

A West Village institution, Faicco’s serves its fragrant sausages and other meats to faithful customers, but it also assembles enviable sandwiches, including a mouth-watering Italian special that’s more animal than anything else, with a dense layering of prosciutto, ham, and soppressata.

260 Bleecker St
New York, NY 10014

10. Alidoro

105 Sullivan St # 2, New York, NY 10012

Alidoro brings Italian delicacies to its over 40 sandwiches, from salami and soppressata to capicola and mortadella, all served on crusty white or whole wheat bread. Prepare for long lunchtime lines of die-hard fans. There are additional locations in Noho and Midtown.

105 Sullivan St # 2
New York, NY 10012

11. Sunny & Annie's Deli

94 Avenue B, New York, NY 10009
Sunny & Annie's Deli
Huy H./Yelp

Rarely does a bodega sandwich linger in the mind, but this corner store blows away expectations with its crafty renditions. The popular Vietnamese-inspired Pho Real combines beef, cilantro, bean sprouts, basil, and Sriracha in a sub. It doesn’t hurt that the place is open 24 hours.

94 Avenue B
New York, NY 10009

12. Frankel's Delicatessen & Appetizing

631 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222
A pastrami and egg sandwich
Frankel's
Frankel’s

Upper West Side-raised brothers Zach and Alex Frankel opened Frankel’s to bring Jewish fare to Greenpoint, particularly smoked fish and meats. Get the pastrami with egg and cheese at breakfast, or opt for The Number One bagel with pastrami salmon and dill cucumber.

631 Manhattan Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11222

13. Russ & Daughters

179 E Houston St, New York, NY 10002
Russ & Daughters
Russ & Daughters/Instagram

The tiny Lower East Side shop, dating back to 1914, is still run by the same family and packed every weekend with devotees chatting as they wait in long lines for bagels stuffed with cream cheese and seafood specialties. The number of smoked salmons is dizzying, but also seek out the fish roe and indulgent belly lox. There’s a nearby sit-down cafe and an outpost in the Jewish Museum as well.

179 E Houston St
New York, NY 10002

14. Parisi Bakery

198 Mott St, New York, NY 10012
Parisi Bakery Robert Sietsema

A stroll through Little Italy isn’t quite the same without a stop into Parisi Bakery, a bakery established in 1903 that also turns out its own inimitable heros. The admirably uncompromising Dennis melds fried chicken cutlet, prosciutto, mozzarella, tomato, balsamic vinegar, and herbs into one joyful mess. Cash only.

198 Mott St
New York, NY 10012

15. Tiny’s Giant Sandwich Shop

129 Rivington St, New York, NY 10002
Tinys Giant Sandwich Shop
William C./Yelp

This small Lower East Side counter serves some genuinely hulking sandwiches. The broad menu of mostly American riffs goes from breakfast melts to lunch fare with worthy vegetarian choices. But meat-eaters should pick the tangy Spicy Rizzak, with turkey, bacon, cheddar, tomato, onion, and chipotle mayo on a toasted sesame semolina hero.

129 Rivington St
New York, NY 10002

Related Maps

16. Foster Sundry

215 Knickerbocker Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237

While it may technically be a butcher shop, to Bushwick locals Foster Sundry is a destination for the sandwiches it stuffs with rich carnivorous delights. The kitchen slings various biscuits with eggs and ham all day, and its other options get thoughtful toppings, like the Vietnamese-inspired house roast beef with nuoc mam mayo, herbs, and pickled vegetables on a toasted hoagie.

215 Knickerbocker Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11237

17. Bread & Spread

147 Front St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

This Dumbo counter serves only what’s in its name, using local ingredients. In addition to breakfast-only offerings, the regular sandwich menu is concise and reliable. Get the popular and meaty porchetta, made with kurobuta pork belly, pickled red onion, arugula, red pepper spread, and aged provolone on ciabatta.

147 Front St
Brooklyn, NY 11201

18. Defonte's Sandwich Shop

379 Columbia St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Defonte's Sandwich Shop
Wendy F./Yelp

Since 1922, this local Italian sandwich shop has served heaping portions of cured pork on heros to workers and passersby in Red Hook. The signature sub is the colossal Nicky Special, layered with a trio of ham, salami, and capocollo, plus fried slices of eggplant, provolone, and hot peppers mixed with oregano and pickled vegetables. Cash only.

379 Columbia St
Brooklyn, NY 11231

19. Court Street Grocers

485 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Court Street Grocers
Trevor L./Yelp

The ambitious menu of this Carroll Gardens lunch staple from Eric Finkelstein and Matt Ross, who have since expanded it beyond Brooklyn, varies from popular egg-based breakfast sandwiches to classic heroes, American classics, and vegetarian-friendly options including a broccoli reuben. There are additional locations in Red Hook and Greenwich Village, and soon, a Williamsburg outpost will open in the old Saltie space.

485 Court St
Brooklyn, NY 11231

20. Ends Meat

254 36th St, Brooklyn, NY 11232
Ends Meat
Brenda C./Yelp

This whole-animal salumeria in Sunset Park puts its strung-cured meats into some flavor-bomb sandwiches with unusual mixes of toppings. In one highlight, pork pate and bacon make friends with mortadella, kimchi, cilantro, red onions, and mayo.

254 36th St
Brooklyn, NY 11232

21. Don Pepe Tortas y Jugos

3908 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232
Don Pepe Tortas y Jugos
Felicia S./Yelp

This Sunset Park Mexican spot juices an epic number of fruits and vegetables, but it also makes some mean tortas, or rolls stuffed with an equally diverse number of ingredients, from chorizo to breaded chicken, thrown on a griddle.

3908 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11232

22. Ba Xuyên

4222 8th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232
Ba Xuyên
Liana L./Yelp

While bánh mì may have become fashionable in all kinds of restaurants, this no-frills Vietnamese restaurant in Sunset Park delivers the sandwich in fine form with a number of variations but no unnecessarily fussy spins. Get one with pate and cold cuts, grilled pork, or meatballs. The pale-green, creamy avocado shake is a favorite accompaniment. Cash only.

4222 8th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11232

Related Maps