clock menu more-arrow no yes
Joe’s Pizza
Joe’s Pizza
Photo by Gary He

NYC’s Top Pizza Slices, Mapped

Pizzerias so splendid they can serve as destination dining spots

View as Map
Joe’s Pizza
| Photo by Gary He

Neighborhood pizzerias are the backbone of New York City’s vernacular cuisine — easily as important as hot dog carts, Chinese-American carry-outs, soul food cafes, and pastrami sandwiches in defining the city’s historic culinary landscape. Since the 1950s, these stalwarts have unceasingly provided delicious nourishment at astonishingly cheap prices to rich and poor alike, but their massive achievements have largely gone unsung.

What constitutes a neighborhood pizzeria? It must sell pizza by the slice; cook its pies in stacked gas ovens that burn at around 550 degrees or below; and, in general, not be part of a chain with multiple outlets. And the pizza must be good enough to eat with great pleasure, day after day, year after year. These are pizzerias so splendid they can serve as destination dining spots, conveniently mapped to find the nearest at any moment.

Note: This map is arranged geographically, north to south.

Cheap Eats
Read More
Note: Restaurants on this map are listed geographically.

1. Broadway Pizza & Pasta

Copy Link
192 W 231st St
Bronx, NY 10463
(718) 601-5000
Visit Website

Located in hilly Kingsbridge and boasting a big and comfortable dining room, BPP is deluxe for a neighborhood joint. The best slice wasn’t the Neapolitan pepperoni or the Sicilian cheese, but the lasagna slice, with gobs of mellow ricotta, splotches of sweet sauce, and herb-scented ground beef. You won’t miss the noodles. For a bigger meal and a spicy kick in the pants, try the chicken fra diavolo ala Rosa, one among many entrees served with spaghetti, ziti, or salad with garlic bread. The slogan of this delightful spot is, “The taste you always come back to,” and we will!

Broadway Pizza & Pasta Robert Sietsema

2. Brother’s

Copy Link
27 E Kingsbridge Rd
Bronx, NY 10468
(718) 295-3897

For 49 years Brother’s has occupied a prime spot in Fordham Manor, with the elevated 4 train towering overhead. The premises are very modest indeed. The plain slice is thin crusted and cheesy, and the sauce is practically unseasoned, which is just fine with me. Other pies beckon, more often available as whole pies rather than individual slices, including a lasagna pie, a salad pie, and a Hawaiian pie with ham and canned pineapple, a favorite in South America.

Plain cheese slice Robert Sietsema

3. University Pizza & Restaurant

Copy Link
574 E Fordham Rd
Bronx, NY 10458
(718) 220-1959
Visit Website

On the northern verge of Belmont facing Fordham University, this pizzeria has been a longtime favorite of students and working-class neighborhood residents. The topping selection is paltry by modern standards, but the plain cheese slice is truly excellent, with a thin and nicely browned crust, a tomato sauce that whispers rather than shouts, and a painstaking strew of cheese that makes for the perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio.

University Pizza & Restaurant Robert Sietsema

4. Ivana's Pizzeria

Copy Link
2373 Arthur Ave
Bronx, NY 10458
(718) 365-4322

This ancient pizzeria retains its nostalgic, time-worn décor, including dozens of framed photographs from the last six decades. The location is iconic: in the midst of the Bronx’s Little Italy (a/k/a Belmont or Arthur Avenue), the pizza here is much better than at surrounding, snazzier pizzerias. Start with the modest cheese slice, which glistens with exuded oils, necessitating the classic New York fold. The slice is salty, the crust nicely browned, the "bone" (circumferential crust) almost non-existent. This constitutes one of the Bronx’s best slices, idiosyncratic and made with evident pride.

Ivana's Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

5. Napoli's Best Pizza

Copy Link
521 E Tremont Ave
Bronx, NY 10457
(718) 299-0759

What a charming name! With a tip of the hat to Naples, this tiny pizzeria across the street from Tremont Park is usually thronged with locals enjoying the neighborhood’s best pizza. And this place doesn’t doll it up, either. There are two choices: a plain cheese wedge and a square, extra-thick Sicilian, unless you want pepperoni to be strewn across the top of your slice as an afterthought. The crust is the thing here, beautifully browned, with a little more dough around the circumference than you really need, in order to flaunt the crust’s excellence. And every morsel of crust gets eaten. Astonishingly, a whole 14-inch round pie can be had for $5.50.

Napoli’s Best Pizza Robert Sietsema

6. Como Pizza

Copy Link
4035 Broadway
New York, NY 10032
(212) 928-7867

The slogan of this Washington Heights pizzeria not far from Columbia Presbyterian Hospital is, “Keep this place in mind, a better pizza is hard to find.” Como is one of those tiny places where the main output is mainly cheese slices, with each pie being subdivided and scooped up the minute it comes from the oven. The crowd loves these plain pies, and you rarely see extra toppings, though if you consult the menu pies with names like Hawaiian, meat eaters, and genuine Mediterranean (eggplant, black olives, and “authentic feta”) are available. Founded 1963, near the start of the neighborhood pizza era.

Plain cheese slice Robert Sietsema

7. P&M Classic Pizza and Restaurant

Copy Link
1747 Amsterdam Ave
New York, NY 10031
(212) 926-3155
Visit Website

This two-decade old pizzeria bills itself as “A Taste of Italy in Harlem” — and it is indeed, with an extended menu of chicken, veal, seafood, and eggplant, with full dinners under $20. But most folks dash in for a slice, and the overwhelming favorite is the pepperoni, the sliced sausage vying with the profuse tomato sauce for pungency. Sicilian slices and calzones are also worth ordering.

P&M Classic Pizza and Restaurant Robert Sietsema

8. Olga's

Copy Link
3409 Broadway
New York, NY 10031
(212) 234-7878

Offering virtually no place to sit and eat, only a narrow shelf that runs around the room, Olga’s on Upper Broadway in Hamilton Heights is nevertheless mobbed during the day with neighborhood types, who use it as a sort of stand-up social club. The slice is uber-cheesy, the crust pale and doughy, the tomato sauce less profuse than usual, and yet it tastes fantastic, showing how a distinct point of view is always an asset to a great neighborhood pizzeria.

Olga’s Pizza Robert Sietsema

9. Best Italian Pizza

Copy Link
412 E 149th St
Bronx, NY 10455
(718) 585-6444

This mainstay with a self-congratulatory name sits just east of the South Bronx shopping district called the Hub. Open since 1958, it was founded at the dawn of the neighborhood pizzeria era, when the stacked pizza oven was first popularized, and the old-fashioned interior, with an order window on the street, shows it. The slices are thicker, with lusher toppings than usual, and the accommodating pizzaioli will ladle extra sauce on a slice at your request. Get the white spinach, which boasts clouds of soft ricotta and plenty of garlic.

Best Italian Pizza Robert Sietsema

10. Tom's Delicious Pizza

Copy Link
3161 Broadway
New York, NY 10027
(212) 932-2100
Visit Website

Founded just north of Columbia University in 1998 by brothers Tomas and Eduardo Ochoa, this small pizzeria turns out spectacular cheese slices. The crust is ultra-thin and crisp, the cheese thicker than usual, and the tomato sauce merely a pastel background to the rest. The smell of fresh garlic knots suffuses the air, and there’s a second branch in Union City, NJ, in case you happen to be in the town that’s right across the Hudson River.

Tom's Delicious Pizza Robert Sietsema

11. Golden Pizza

Copy Link
504 E 138th St
Bronx, NY 10454
(718) 665-8328

Golden is about as bare-bones as a pizzeria can be, yet it has obviously been feeding the populace of its Mott Haven neighborhood for a good long time. The dining room is standing-only, and the counter routinely displays only one kind of slice, yet what a slice it is. Trim, nicely clotted with good cheese, not quite thin-crusted but crisp and tasty nonetheless. You can have some pepperoni thrown on top, but it’s not necessary. And, miracle of miracles, an entire cheese pie can be had for $6.50, which is less than dollar slice places charge.

A slice of plain cheese pizza sits on a white paper plate placed on a brown counter. Robert Sietsema

12. Mama's TOO!

Copy Link
2750 Broadway
New York, NY 10025
(212) 510-7256

Mama’s Too is one of the new crop of neighborhood pizzerias that have reconfigured their slices to be more modern and innovative than that of the classic neighborhood pizzeria. (The place is related to a more conventional pizzeria on Amsterdam Avenue.) This is all to the good, you’ll realize as you survey the collection of square pies with rich crusts and atypical toppings. The pepperoni slice uses a small-bore sausage packed tightly on the slice, weeping paprika oil down on the crust. Other pies include caramelized onion and mushroom, and zucchini with Kalamata olives.

Square pepperoni slice Robert Sietsema

13. Sal and Carmine Pizza

Copy Link
2671 Broadway
New York, NY 10025
(212) 663-7651
Visit Website

Pizzaiolo Sal Malanga opened this popular Upper West Side joint in 1959 and ran it until his death in 2011. His crust remains the quintessential element — "crisp on the outside and tender on the inside" as pizza fanatic Ed Levine once put it. Thereafter Sal’s grandson Lou keeps the place up and running, and the cheese slice is as good as always — great crust, with a tomato sauce and cheese that merge into a mysterious amalgam.

A white plate with a single slice of cheese pizza. Robert Sietsema

14. Sam’s Famous Pizzeria

Copy Link
150 E 116th St
New York, NY 10029
(212) 348-9437
Visit Website

Sam’s is a throwback to the ’60s, when East Harlem was one of the city’s most prominent Italian neighborhoods. Now it and Rao’s are two of the few surviving institutions of that era. The place is narrow and efficient, and turns out a bigger range of products than seems possible given the small space. The pizza crust is especially thin and crisp (the dough is made on premises), and the regular slice is on the cheesy side with a big thick “bone” (circumferential edge). Among specialty slices, the three meat (pepperoni, bacon, Italian sausages) is especially fine and greasy, and the chicken parm slice a nice invention. Garlic knots A+.

Sam’s Famous Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

15. Cheesy Pizza

Copy Link
2640 Broadway
New York, NY 10025
(212) 662-5223
Visit Website

The name says it all at this Upper West Side institution dedicated to the dairy component of the classic slice. The cheese here is so profuse, it threatens to roll off the pie. Sure, the crust is a bit doughy and pale ensuring the sauce recedes into the background. But gradually as you eat it, you’ll realize the other components have been formulated so you can better worship the molten cheese.

Cheesy Pizza Robert Sietsema

16. Luigi's Pizzeria

Copy Link
1701 1st Avenue
New York, NY 10128
(212) 410-1910

This Upper East Side mainstay has been pumping out the slices since 1997, offering a sauce slightly sweeter and chunkier than average. Our favorite is the grandma, a square slice in the upside down formation, meaning that the cheese is on the bottom and the sauce on top, so that the imperially thin crust doesn’t get soggy. That the crust is also on the thin size for a square slice, and a little bit oily, is an added bonus, and so is the shredded basil sprinkled on top.

Grandma slice Robert Sietsema

17. Delizia 73

Copy Link
1374 1st Avenue
New York, NY 10021
(212) 517-8888
Visit Website

A mural of Venice graces one wall of this venerable Upper East Side pizzeria — with Superman flying overhead, looking for criminals. If you want to feel like you’re sitting in a real restaurant while scarfing your two slices and a soft drink, this is your place. And the quality of the pies makes it a destination spot, too. Our favorite is the grandma slice: In the square format, it displays cheese-on-the-bottom pizza-tecture, with splotches of herb-y sauce on top.

Delizia 73 Robert Sietsema

18. Astoria Hot Pizza

Copy Link
32-04 30th Ave
Long Island City, NY 11102
(718) 545-1313

Who can resist the white slice at Astoria Hot Pizza, with its masses of ricotta and mozzarella on an un-tomatoed crust, like driven snow after a blizzard. The chicken slice is another favorite: a diced cutlet, tasting fresh from the fryer, scattered across what would otherwise be a regular cheese slice. It’s like a deconstructed chicken cutlet parm hero. This place shares space with a Middle Eastern grocery store, which allows an unusual latitude in the selection of beverages.

Astoria Hot Pizza Robert Sietsema

19. Luigi's Gourmet Pizza

Copy Link
936 8th Ave
New York, NY 10019
(212) 265-7159
Visit Website

This commodious pizzeria just south of Central Park has deep Sicilian roots and the slices show it magnificently. The best offerings fall among the square-slices including the musketa, which features chopped tomatoes and onions on a thick bed of cheese; and the oxymoronic Sicilian margarita slice, which melts artisanal mozzarella and shoots splotches of tomato sauce over an exceedingly well-browned crust.

Luigi's Gourmet Pizza Robert Sietsema

20. Famous Amadeus

Copy Link
840 8th Ave
New York, NY 10019
(212) 489-6187
Visit Website

This pizzeria not far from the Broadway theaters treats its output like a dramatic event. Dating from 1994, it flaunts a long glass counter with a ridiculous number of pie choices. Sometimes you just need lots of meat, and the meat lover’s pie features sausage, bacon, and pepperoni. Other sporadically available pies deploy Portuguese chorizo, Philly cheesesteak, lemony chicken Francese, and Tex-Mex jalapeños and seasoned ground beef.

Meat lover’s slice Robert Sietsema

21. Belmora

Copy Link
139 E 57th St
New York, NY 10022
(212) 935-2080
Visit Website

This agreeable East Side pizzeria offers a larger dining room than most and a sunny southern exposure. The slices are about average in thickness and crispness, with a tomato sauce rich and herbal but not sweet. Its forte is unexpected combinations of ingredients, including a great pepperoni and black olive slice that turns out to be fantastic. Plus, it's open at 8 a.m., seven days a week — in case you'd like a slice for breakfast.

Belmora Robert Sietsema

22. Steinway Pizza

Copy Link
31-51 Steinway St
Astoria, NY 11103
(718) 274-4250
Visit Website

Wavy orange seats on the formica booths are classic neighborhood pizzeria décor, and often cue you that a great slice is on the way. And so are the gargantuan stacks of pre-folded pizza boxes at this classic parlor on a busy Astoria shopping strip. Go straight for the plain cheese slice, with a magnificently thin and floppy crust, large bone (the circumferential edge), and unusually large quantity of cheese, which is not a burden but a pleasure. One of the mellowest slices in Queens.

Steinway Pizza Robert Sietsema

23. Polito's Pizza

Copy Link
38-12 Broadway
Astoria, NY 11103
(718) 626-6344

Though it was established in 1981 and not long ago appeared timeworn, a more recent renovation has left this Astorian stalwart handsome and comfortable, a place to linger. The grandma slice is the one to get. Perfect for its type, it sports a lush and deep red tomato sauce, flecked with little bits of garlic and onion that add sweetness, and the cheese is exemplary, too.

Polito's Pizza Robert Sietsema

24. Gianni's

Copy Link
81-13 Northern Blvd
Jackson Heights, NY 11372
(718) 478-4783
Visit Website

Gianni’s is a classic 1980 Jackson Heights pizzeria, heavy on the Sicilian influences, with an ambitious menu, but a premises that says “pizzeria” rather than “fancy restaurant.” There’s a nice little backyard, and the thing to not miss is the Sicilian slice. The bottom side of the crust is brown and crisp, the crumb light as air, the sauce on the sweet side, and the cheese tumbles over the side like a waterfall.

Gianni's Robert Sietsema

25. Kiss My Slice

Copy Link
274 W 40th St
New York, NY 10018
(212) 391-9524
Visit Website

There is a kind of modern neighborhood pizza parlor that flaunts its creativity, turning out oddball slices that seek to compete with other forms of fast food, either by poaching on their territory, or just by jumping up and down and shouting, "Me! Me! Me!" The sassily named Kiss My Slice does both, as seen by a careful examination of its epic fried chicken and waffle slice. The waffle has been minced into individual boxes, the fried chicken cut in cubes, and a drizzle of pancake syrup, probably constituting the first time syrup has been put on a slice of pizza. Pineapple-and-pepperoni is another strange slice choice.

Kiss My Slice Robert Sietsema

26. Uncle Paul's Pizza

Copy Link
70 Vanderbilt Ave
New York, NY 10017
(212) 922-1200
Visit Website

Clad in green marble, why is this pizzeria directly across the street from Grand Central so elegant? The interior gleams and the patrons are often well-dressed businesspeople. Yet they’re ordering slices like more typical pizza parlor patrons, though these slices often seem denser and fresher than usual. Our favorite is the lasagna slice, which emulates a serving of lasagna with its rich sauce, ground beef, and ricotta cheese that plays second fiddle to lots of mozzarella. Open 24 hours.

Uncle Paul's Pizza Robert Sietsema

27. Daro's Pizza & Chicken

Copy Link
4425 Kissena Blvd
Flushing, NY 11355
(718) 445-5572
Visit Website

Surrounded by Northern Chinese restaurants, Daro’s is tasked with fulfilling two pressing neighborhood needs: pizza and fried chicken, a combination common enough in Brooklyn’s Afghani-owned fried chicken joints. Here it seems like the pizza predated the bird, because the list of pies is far more sophisticated than the chicken menu. A case in point is the grandma slice, thin-crusted and utilizing fresh mozzarella, premium tomato sauce, and fresh basil — an herb not easy to find in these parts. Hot heroes are another strong point, especially the iconic egg and peppers.

Daro’s Pizza & Chicken Robert Sietsema

28. Bravo Pizza

Copy Link
6 E 42nd St
New York, NY 10017
(212) 867-4960
Visit Website

This especially comfortable pizzeria is part of a Manhattan mini-chain, with a deep dark interior kept cool in sweltering weather, and mounts an enticing display of by-the-slice pies to lure passersby, some of them rather creative. Of several sampled, the one topped with pepperoni and canned jalapeños was the most enthralling, mouth-tingling in the best possible way.

Bravo Pizza Robert Sietsema

29. Highline Pizzeria

Copy Link
503 W 28th St
New York, NY 10001
(212) 564-3330

Proving again that even today neighborhood pizzerias are opening up, Highline appeared not too long ago on the edge of Hudson Yards, peddling a menu of predictable slices with a few new twists. The pale crust is distinguished, and one of the best uses is in a pie topped with cubed chicken cutlet and fresh ripe tomato. This place floods with construction workers from nearby high-rises in the post-noon period.

Highline Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

30. NY Pizza Suprema

Copy Link
413 8th Ave
New York, NY 10001
(212) 594-8939
Visit Website

Located directly southwest of Penn Station since 1964, NY Pizza Suprema is undoubtedly one of the most celebrated neighborhood pizzerias in Manhattan. The lavish display of pies under glass right inside the front entrance provides a beguiling dilemma, but we generally spring for any of the Sicilian slices, which have a bit of oil in the dough and are thus crunchier than most. The sausage Sicilian is particularly dope, miring shavings of good fennel sausage in a profuse floe of cheese. Open until midnight, seven days.

NY Pizza Suprema Robert Sietsema

31. Mario's

Copy Link
77-09 37th Ave
Jackson Heights, NY 11372
(718) 446-8879
Visit Website

While most of the neighborhood pizzerias we extol originated in the ’50s, ’60s, and ’70s, when the neighborhood pizza parlor movement was at its height, here’s a new one — founded in 2015 in Jackson Heights — that proves the formula is still sound. The inside is brightly lit, the counter is at the rear of the space, and one wall is decorated with white paper plates painted by young Mario’s fans. Garlic knots and grandma slices are better than most, but the plain cheese slice is the real triumph here, more thin crusted than most, with a thick coating of slightly sweet and herby tomato sauce painted on the crust, and an average amount of cheese. A great slice to eat while walking down the street, not too messy.

Mario's Robert Sietsema

32. Pizza Bella

Copy Link
8130 Broadway
Flushing, NY 11373
(718) 507-1009

Flaunting a nautical theme, Pizza Bella stands out on Elmhurst’s Broadway among the mainly Southeast Asian cafes. The plain cheese slice is plain as plain can be, with a precise and carefully calculated inter-relationship of cheese, sauce, and crust. The crust itself is done to a premeditated brownness. This is pizza for folks who don’t like bells and whistles.

Pizza Bella Robert Sietsema

33. Stella's

Copy Link
110 9th Ave #1
New York, NY 10011
(212) 462-4444
Visit Website

Founded in 1997, this Chelsea mainstay seems far older. The regular slice is especially tomatoey and slightly salty, best enjoyed as part of the $5 lunch special (two slices and a can of soda). On the other hand, then you’d miss the dense white broccoli slice, which features cloudy masses of ricotta and mozzarella. Seating is limited to a gleaming metal counter, and you should see the line that winds out the door during mealtimes! Are those Roy Lichtenstein prints on the walls? He once lived nearby.

Stella’s Pizza Robert Sietsema

34. Giovanni’s Pizzeria

Copy Link
45-59 47th St
Woodside, NY 11377
(718) 609-1630

This Woodside pizzeria of ancient vintage always had a larger menu than most. On top of the regular pies, there are pastas, heroes, salads, steaks and chops, and belt-busting, all-in Italian dinners. But in addition, the place now serves Mexican food, so that you can have guac and chips alongside your Sicilian slice. The cemitas (round Pueblan sandwiches) have become neighborhood favorites. Hopefully, the Mexican and Italian menus will begin fusing, and we can expect a Mexican pizza strewn with chiles and cactus strips, or maybe chipotle chicken, in the future.

Giovanni’s Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

35. Marabella

Copy Link
4107 Greenpoint Ave
Sunnyside, NY 11104
(718) 786-4635
Visit Website

Debuting in 1984 and occupying a distinctive corner location in Sunnyside, Marabella is proud of its Sicilian roots, as evidenced by the choice of art and maps on the walls. The ovens stand right inside the front door to make it easy to dash in and out for a slice. You should look no further than the fine grandma slice, which is square and thin-crusted, sporting fresh mozzarella and thick, sweet tomato sauce. Unique to Marabella are sandwiches (the pizzeria calls focaccia) made by splitting a thick wedge of pizza and piling it with chicken parm and other fillings.

Marabella Robert Sietsema

36. Village Pizza

Copy Link
65 8th Ave
New York, NY 10014
(212) 243-4367

We have a particular affection for pizzerias squished into tiny spaces, where the ovens dominated the visual landscape and a single employee serves as pie wrangler and clerk. Just down the block from an important subway stop, Village Pizza is just such a place, with a surprisingly large collection of slices for its cramped premises. The buffalo chicken is one the best, featuring a cut-up chicken cutlet and tart sauce that delivers a spicy and vinegary tang. Some say this slice was invented by pizzerias trying to get in on the football-party delivery action without actually doing wings.

Village Pizza Robert Sietsema

37. Gino’s Pizza

Copy Link
86-35 Broadway
Elmhurst, NY 11373
(718) 672-8515

Since 1968, this quaint pizzeria has lingered beside Elmhurst’s busiest bus stop. Quaint because the limestone-faced walls and carriage lamps make it seem a bit like a village inside. Vegetarian is the way to go here, via a series of pies in a separate case of slightly smaller circumference, including an eggplant slice that looks to be almost a quarter of a pie — a bit more expensive than most slices, but also encompassing square inches of pizza territory.

Gino’s Pizza Robert Sietsema

38. Lunetta

Copy Link
245 3rd Ave
New York, NY 10010
(212) 432-5200
Visit Website

The stylish pizzeria (the name means “Little Moon”) is on the verge of becoming an actual restaurant, but the emphasis remains staunchly on some excellent pies, with a sauce perhaps a little sweeter than usual. The margherita is a round, thin crust pie with fresh mozzarella and little wads of crushed tomatoes here and there, creating a prodigious mouth wallop. A larger than usual roster of apps, subs, hamburgers, heros, and cheesesteaks provide enhanced dinner options.

Lunetta Robert Sietsema

39. Triangolo Pizzeria

Copy Link
1017 Manhattan Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11222
(718) 389-5885

Located on the northern reaches of Manhattan Avenue, Triangolo is one of Greenpoint’s most distinguished neighborhood parlors. Look through the glass display counter and pick what looks best — on a recent visit, it was an extra thick slice with sauce and cheese, dotted with bacon, pepperoni, and ground beef. The cheese and spinach stromboli, with a particularly crisp crust, was also exemplary. Dig the lettering on the neon sign outside, and don’t miss the cryptic Steven Seagal shrine.

Triangolo Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

40. Joe's Pizza

Copy Link
7 Carmine St
New York, NY 10014
(212) 366-1182
Visit Website

King of the neighborhood pizza parlors, Manhattan edition, Joe’s offers a slice magnificent in its plainness, appreciated by generations of New Yorkers and visitors. No frou-frou here, just a well-pureed sauce and just enough cheese — but not too much — and one of the city’s most perfect crusts. On the other hand, for just a bit more you can get the fresh mozzarella slice, with little annealed gobs of newly minted cheese. But the best-selling slice, according to a counter guy I talked to, is the pepperoni slice. Miraculously, new branches of this place near Union Square, Times Square, and in Williamsburg have not diminished its brilliance.

A slice of pepperoni pizza on a white paper plate. Robert Sietsema

41. Franklin Pizza

Copy Link
109 Franklin St
Brooklyn, NY 11222
(718) 349-2472
Visit Website

Yes, the swells head further down Greenpoint Avenue for Paulie Gee’s, a wood oven place with some weird and sometimes spectacular pies. Franklin is conveniently located just across the street from the historic Pencil Factory bar, so that you can see beer fans knocking off a slice or two before scampering across the street. Featuring both ricotta and mozzarella, the broccoli slice is a particular fave, and the drinkers all know that one constitutes a perfectly balanced meal.

Franklin Pizza Robert Sietsema

42. Italy Pizza

Copy Link
800 Manhattan Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11222
(718) 383-9079

Are you a fan of the white slice? This narrow pizzeria — with a stamped-tin ceiling and other features that telegraph its age — specializes in these slices, with a white pie always displayed on the counter. The cheese is profusely laid on, with so much garlic, you’ll be burping it for hours if not days afterwards. Lasagna, garlic knots, and salads are also recommended at this establishment in the Greenpoint business district, close to bars and clubs.

Italy Pizza Robert Sietsema

43. TuArepa Pizza Cafe

Copy Link
100-22 67th Ave
Queens, NY 11375
(718) 766-8900
Visit Website

Taken over not too long ago by a Chinese-Venezuelan owner, this pizzeria just off Queens Boulevard in Forest Hills was already a historic and fully functioning institution. Now it also serves overstuffed arepa sandwiches, fried and baked empanadas, cheese-stuffed cachapas, and other Venezuelan fare as a sideline. The pizzas, though, remain uncommonly solid, including a plain slice with extra cheese, a narrow bone (the bare outside edge of the slice), and a bland tomato sauce that makes this example typical of great neighborhood slices. Other more contemporary slices include the baked ziti, the Hawaiian, and the bacon chicken ranch, the last slice gobbed with salad dressing.

TuArepa Pizza Cafe Robert Sietsema

44. Rosalia's Pizzeria

Copy Link
103-15 Queens Blvd
Forest Hills, NY 11375
(718) 459-0300
Visit Website

Proving that old-style neighborhood pizzerias are not a bygone phenomenon, Rosalia’s opened not long ago in Forest Hills, with the same owner as Luzzo’s in the East Village and Gansevoort Market. You can tell the proprietor is a Staten Islander the minute you bite into the spinach and artichoke slice: wads of spinach, a strew of chopped artichoke leaves and choke, little hills of melting ricotta, and a soupy greenish sauce. In Staten Island, the semi-liquid slice is king.

Spinach and artichoke slice Robert Sietsema

45. Rosario's Pizza

Copy Link
173 Orchard St
New York, NY 10002
(212) 777-9813

The crust is thicker, stiffer, and more browned at this Lower East Side stalwart founded in 1963. For the meat lover, there’s a slice with pepperoni and Italian sausage, buoyed by plenty of mozzarella. In fact, the pizzeria describes this slice and several others as deep dish, referencing a Chicago-style pizza rarely seen in New York, especially among neighborhood pizza parlors. We're lucky to be able to buy it by the slice.

Robert Sietsema

46. Gloria Pizza

Copy Link
108-22 Queens Blvd
Forest Hills, NY 11375
(718) 263-1100
Visit Website

This downtown Forest Hills fixture goes all the way back to 1960, but underwent a hiatus early in this century. Now it’s back and better than ever, offering a well-windowed dining room and the usual rich profusion of slice choices. Our fave is the grandma slice: a crisp, square crust with an impressive slab of mozzarella, a slice of fresh tomato, and strips of roasted red pepper, making for an unusual slice that tastes like an Italian street fair.

Gloria Pizza Robert Sietsema

47. Champion Pizza

Copy Link
187 Bedford Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11211
(929) 295-0191
Visit Website

Proving that neighborhood pizzerias are still viable, even as more expensive and pretentious pizzerias have become common, Champion is a mini-chain with a newish branch in Williamsburg. Sold by the slice, most of the pizzas are square, the crusts relatively thin, and done to a dark brown. Toppings are innovative, too, including one slice that features alternate bands of green pesto and red tomato sauce, like a Morris Lewis painting in the Museum of Modern Art.

Champion Pizza Robert Sietsema

48. Dona Bella Pizza

Copy Link
154 Church St
New York, NY 10007
(212) 374-1130
Visit Website

Holding down an incredibly expensive corner location in Tribeca, Dona Bella ("Beautiful Lady") puts an almost surreal amount of energy into its eye-socking window display. The crusts on the Neapolitan slices are a little thicker than usual, the toppings moister and more opulently applied. A case in point is the wonderful mushroom slice, to which a great heap of ‘shrooms has been applied, and plenty of cheese, too. The round fresh mozzarella pie is also great, with big splotches of sweet tomato sauce.

Dona Bella Pizza Robert Sietsema

49. San Marco Pizzería

Copy Link
577 Lorimer St
Brooklyn, NY 11211
(718) 387-4861
Visit Website

Named after a famous piazza in Venice and dating to 1969, Williamsburg’s San Marco Pizzeria is perhaps the most beautiful and elegant establishment of its type. Seating is mainly at a polished granite counter that faces the pizza oven; a series of signs display the menu, for which there is no paper equivalent; and pies are restricted, for all practical purposes, to plain cheese and plain Sicilian. The cheese slice is austere, with a tomato sauce not the slightest bit sweet, and plenty of salty cheese, making it an entirely savory experience.

San Marco Pizzería Robert Sietsema

50. Sal's Pizzeria

Copy Link
544 Lorimer St
Brooklyn, NY 11211
(718) 388-6838
Visit Website

This 1967 neighborhood pizzeria is more elegant than most, with views out the big picture windows (which open in fine weather) and good wine and beer available to wash pizza down. The eggplant slice features crisp, crumbed slices of vegetable, hillocks of ricotta, and a thin crust that invites you to eat the thing with a knife and fork. And nobody will laugh at you if you do.

Sal's Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

51. Little Italy Pizza

Copy Link
11 Park Pl
New York, NY 10007
(212) 227-7077
Visit Website

All Little Italy franchises are not the same. In fact, some are superb while others awful, with doughy crusts and lifeless tomato sauces. The City Hall branch is one of the great ones, and you can tell the minute you step inside and see the elated diners. A favorite slice is the carbonara, which features two kinds of cheese along with shards of prosciutto, making it one of the city’s few pies to utilize that cold-cut cooked. Open 24 hours.

Little Italy Pizza Robert Sietsema

52. Sabrina's

Copy Link
294 Broadway
Brooklyn, NY 11211
(718) 387-7743

Founded in 1977 in the shadow of the M and J tracks, this parlor is young in pizzeria years, but excels at all the classic pies and hero sandwiches. Some of the best things on the menu, though, show a Latin bent. For example, the miniature pie called an onion pizzette is about as close as you can get to a real Buenos Aires fugazetta. Other favorites include a spinach-ricotta slice that seems positively healthy, and an idiosyncratic take on a hot dog, wrapping it in pizza dough with melted cheese. Delicious!

Sabrina's Robert Sietsema

53. Underground Pizza

Copy Link
3 Hanover Square
New York, NY 10004
(212) 425-4442
Visit Website

How does a simple independent slice joint stay in business in the Wall Street area? By serving some of the best pizza in town in a somewhat shabby and abject location a few steps below street level. Nevertheless, this is a frequently recommended favorite among brokers, clerks, digital journalists, and non-profit wonks who labor in the neighborhood. The fresh mozzarella slice is especially enticing, with splotches of sweet herby tomato sauce, great mozzarella that doesn’t go all soggy, and a memorably crisp, browned crust.

Underground Pizza Robert Sietsema

54. Georgio's Pizza

Copy Link
20 Beaver St
New York, NY 10004
(212) 361-6160
Visit Website

Founded in 2011, Georgio’s is master of the thick, lush pie, so expect to be fully fed on a single slice. The chicken and spinach, for example, matches breaded, fried, and diced bird with swirls of dense, dark spinach. This favorite of FiDi office workers is mobbed at lunch, nearly empty in the evening.

Georgio's Pizza Robert Sietsema

55. Sal's Pizzeria

Copy Link
119 Wyckoff Ave #1
Brooklyn, NY 11237
(718) 386-5299

This antediluvian Bushwick pizzeria that resides above the DeKalb stop on the L dates back to the days when this was an Italian neighborhood and its sausage roll was fabled. In terms of pizza, go for the Sicilian slice. It's thick and square and brown as a beetle, with little rivulets of sauce and cheese and a generous sprinkling of dried Romano for extra saltiness and flavor. It's worth traveling from another borough to try!

Sal's Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

56. Pranzo Pizza & Pasta

Copy Link
34 Water St
New York, NY 10004
(212) 344-8068
Visit Website

This ancient pizzeria, shuttered for nearly a year by Hurricane Sandy tucks way downtown in a Manhattan maritime location, a stone’s throw from the Staten Island Ferry. Around lunchtime lines are long. Slices are noticeably lush, with an average thickness, an extra-crisp crust and a nicely-browned bone or cornicione. A favorite slice features spinach and a tidal wave of cheese — but no tomato sauce. It's fit for a full meal.

Pranzo Pizza & Pasta Robert Sietsema

57. Tony’s Pizzeria and Restaurant

Copy Link
443 Knickerbocker Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11237
(718) 455-9664

Since the 1970s, when Bushwick was still an Italian stronghold, Tony’s Pizza has been turning out near-perfect pies on Knickerbocker Avenue, a stone’s throw from Maria Hernandez Park, once known as Bushwick Park. The slice is austere in its structure: the crust pale and thinner than most, but crisp; the sauce mild and only slightly sweet; the better-than-average cheese strewn with a generous hand. Devotees also extol the hot heroes, potato-lovers pie, and fried calamari.

Tony’s Pizza Bushwick and DeKalb Robert Sietsema

58. Tony's Pizza Spot

Copy Link
431 Dekalb Ave # A
Brooklyn, NY 11205
(718) 622-6395

This Clinton Hill pizzeria shows its extreme age, via a narrow sagging interior, intriguing clutter, and menu that doesn’t subscribe to the latest pizza fads (no buffalo chicken pizza, for example). This makes it a great place to imagine what neighborhood pizza was like 40 years ago, with a charming plainness in its sturdy crust, slightly sweet sauce, and liberal hand with the cheese. Want variety? Pile on the anchovies.

Tony's Pizza Spot Robert Sietsema

59. My Little Pizzeria

Copy Link
114 Court St
Brooklyn, NY 11201
(718) 643-6120
Visit Website

What pizza parlor boasts outdoor seating in the back? This one in downtown Brooklyn does, and also a large dining room perfect for accommodating lunchtime crowds. The supreme slice is the one to get, with an unusually thin crust for a fresh mozzarella slice, browned more than most and hence crisp. The cheese is cooked a little more, too. This is an atypical take on a classic slice, and six or seven more slices are commonly available at any given time.

My Little Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

60. Pipitone's Pizza Restaurant

Copy Link
100 Dekalb Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11201
(718) 858-4376
Visit Website

This stalwart on the edge of Fort Greene Park popular with Brooklyn Tech students offers neighborhood pizza with a distinctly Sicilian bent. The upside-down Sicilian has become something of a local legend — with the copious cheese nestling next to the crust, to preserve its adamantine crispness under the onslaught of the sweet, deeply red sauce.

Pipitone's Pizza Restaurant Robert Sietsema

61. Caruso's

Copy Link
150 Smith St
Brooklyn, NY 11201
(718) 797-2300
Visit Website

Proudly proclaiming itself the oldest pizzeria on Smith Street (there’s really not all that much competition), Caruso’s also functions as an a Italian restaurant, with an expanded roster of pastas and dinner entrees. These are all fine, but the pizza is particularly good, including several round pies featuring fresh mozzarella. The pie called “fresh mozzarella” is the most engaging, and it can be made with the restaurant’s signature sesame crust, whereby the ridge around the pie is implanted with seeds, probably a practice of Sicilian or even Greek origin. Whoever invented it, the slice is absolutely great.

Fresh mozzarella slice with sesame crust Robert Sietsema

62. Not Ray's Pizza

Copy Link
694 Fulton St
Brooklyn, NY 11217
(718) 330-2400
Visit Website

Making fun of the Famous Ray's and its imitators, Not Ray's is a normal neighborhood pizza parlor in a memorable, wedge-shaped space right on Fulton Street. The slice has a narrow "bone" (the bare circumference of the pie), the cheese is modestly applied, and the tomato sauce piquant and somewhat sweet. The slice is a little gloppier than usual and a molten cheese-sauce hybrid spills over the sides. Dying for novelty? Try the Buffalo chicken or Caesar salad pies.

Not Ray's Pizza Robert Sietsema

63. Armando's Pizza

Copy Link
1717 Broadway
Brooklyn, NY 11207
(718) 484-8500
Visit Website

This newish Ocean Hill establishment is a branch of a long-running Canarsie pizzeria that’s been in the D’Arpa family since 1968, now being run by a third generation. Like the sign outside says, the mini-chain’s specialty is the Sicilian slice (only $2.50!), and you’ve never tasted better. The bread is thick and bouncy, but paradoxically light-textured, and the sauce in the typical Sicilian style is a little on the sweet side. In addition, there’s a strong taste of oregano, which may or may not be due to the Greek origin of many Sicilians. Other specialties include a delicious, sesame-seeded ground beef stromboli, pepperoni pinwheels, and meatball rolls.

Armando's Pizza

64. Rocco Pizza III

Copy Link
330 Halsey St
Brooklyn, NY 11216
(718) 573-9200
Visit Website

Some say this sunken pizzeria on a side street was the inspiration for Spike Lee’s Do the Right Thing. Whether it was or not, the pizzas are damn good, with a slightly thicker crust than usual, and some fairly creative toppings. The margarita slice is memorable, pooled with fresh mozzarella and dotted with herbs, while the lasagna slice mimics that casserole with an insane amount of delicately seasoned ground beef and wads of fresh ricotta.

Rocco Pizza III Robert Sietsema

65. Bergen Pizza

Copy Link
67 6th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11217
(718) 636-4863
Visit Website

This quintessential Brooklyn pizzeria has seen progress overtake it. Where once its main feature was proximity to a police precinct, now it’s being engulfed by the nearby Atlantic Yards developments. For a neighborhood joint, it sure has a nice dining room, though perhaps a little more lit than you might like. The thing to get here is the Sicilian slice, which is nicely salty with more cheese than you usually get. The crumb is dense enough that one’s a meal. Salads are unexpectedly spot-on here.

Bergen Pizza Robert Sietsema

66. Pizza Town

Copy Link
85 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11217
(718) 789-4040

This lively pizzeria with some nifty murals has been a mainstay of 5th Avenue in the Slope since before that thoroughfare was even considered part of the Slope. The regular slice boasts a thicker and crisper crust than usual, and many patrons go for the extensive collection of novelties — such as the Buffalo chicken slice, the vodka slice, and the square Sicilian fried-eggplant slice with fresh mozzarella, surmounted by a very large basil leaf. But best of all is the stuffed slice, which features Italian sausage, pepperoni, potatoes, and cheese pressed between a double crust — it’s double delicious, and identifies the roots of Pizzatown in Abruzzi, where such pizzas are a specialty.

Pizza Town Robert Sietsema

67. Pizza Chef

Copy Link
1512 Fulton St
Brooklyn, NY 11213
(718) 774-3043

Occupying a prime location right on Fulton, Pizza Chef is an ancient pizza parlor taken over by Muslim proprietors, who have left the interior intact but removed pork products from the menu. Instead, they lavish each slice with extra cheese, and do a special job on such local favorites as barbecue pizza: chicken chunks swimming in sweet barbecue sauce positioned above the cheese so the slice doesn’t get soggy — brilliant pizza architecture.

Pizza Chef Robert Sietsema

68. Giardini Pizza

Copy Link
363 Smith St
Brooklyn, NY 11231
(718) 596-5320
Visit Website

Proving how a pizzeria can anchor an entire neighborhood — in this case Carroll Gardens — Giardini is a daytime haven for hungry school kids, card-playing seniors, and shoppers dashing in for a fortifying bite. In the evenings, dating couples and families fill the space, which boasts an outdoor garden. The pizza is made with great thought and care; the grandma slice here is in the upside-down Sicilian format, with a wealth of cheese beneath the tomato sauce, and a crust so good you’d eat it by itself.

Giardini Pizza Robert Sietsema

69. Tomato N Basil

Copy Link
226 4th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11215
(718) 596-8855
Visit Website

This pocket-size pizzeria right above the R stop at Union Street in Gowanus excels at modern notions of neighborhood pizza. Consistent with its name, the square, compact grandma slice is the one to get, with the cheese on the bottom, sauce on top, and several basil leaves imparting sweet flavor on top. The eggplant and chicken-ricotta pies are also worth sampling.

Tomato N Basil Robert Sietsema

70. Antonio's

Copy Link
318 Flatbush Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11217
(718) 398-2300

An old newspaper article pinned beside the door proclaims Antonio’s 50th anniversary, so by now it must be much older. The Park Slope stalwart is all over the map pizza-wise, even making an approximation of deep-dish Chicago pies, and regular pies with Alfredo and vodka sauces, as if pizza were pasta. Amid the welter of pizza forms is a perfect grandma — a paradoxically square and thin slice, with the crust like a piece of delicious cardboard. Splotches of mutz and torn basil leaves powerfully scent the pie.

Grandma slice Robert Sietsema

71. Tony’s

Copy Link
850 Nostrand Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11225
(718) 363-8300

Jeez there must be dozens of pizzerias in the five boroughs named Tony’s. This one distinctively occupies a rather grand corner double-storefront with plenty of windows, through which the snow looks rather dramatic as it falls softly on Crown Heights. The stacked ovens turn out all the usual pies, and there’s also a sideline in jerk chicken, a neighborhood favorite. Torn into pieces, that bird goes on a slice, with some barbecue sauce striped on for extra sweetness. Hey, it’s good!

Jerk chicken slice Robert Sietsema

72. Luigi's Pizza

Copy Link
686 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11215
(718) 499-3857
Visit Website

Just how many pizzerias named Luigi’s are there in the five boroughs? Plenty, we’re sure. Located in Greenwood Heights, this one (founded in 1973) functions as a sort of community center in a neighborhood increasingly uncertain how to define itself. The pizzas are especially good, with some relatively unusual toppings, including a wonderful pie with soppressata and jalapeños, fusing old and new aspects of the neighborhood.

Luigi's Pizza Robert Sietsema

73. Family Pizza

Copy Link
720 Flatbush Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11225
(718) 462-0639

What could be more perfect than a plain cheese slice, fabulously rendered? That’s the main output of Family Pizza on Flatbush Avenue. The crust is thin, but manages to be soft on the top and crisp on the bottom, a miraculous stratification in such a thin-crusted slice. The sauce is memorable by having no trace of sweetness; the cheese plain as plain can be. It’s as if the god of all pizza had asked that a slice be reduced to its simplest and most perfect formulation.

Plain cheese slice Robert Sietsema

74. Xochil Pizzeria

Copy Link
4613 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11220
(718) 435-2288

This delightful Sunset Park pizzeria has been taken over by Pueblans, who have mounted a griddle in the window — actually, sticking out of the window — where tlaycoyos are grilled and then topped with queso seco and salsa. The conventional pizza slices are fine, too, especially an unusual stuffed-crust pie. Filled with sausage and potatoes, it probably originated in Abruzzo, where such pizzas are common.

Xochil Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

75. Rocky’s Pizzeria

Copy Link
474 Coney Island Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11218
(718) 854-9270
Visit Website

This Kensington establishment at the corner of Church and C.I.A. (Coney Island Avenue) has been around since the days of the original Rocky movie, and the interior — ablaze in neon — features boxing memorabilia. The plain cheese slice is great, but why not go for the more spectacular ziti slice. Contrary to type, it also features lots of meat sauce to go with the pasta, making it a real pizza-pasta hybrid. Just try to eat more than one slice.

Rocky’s Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

76. Korner Pizza

Copy Link
226 Church Ave # 1
Brooklyn, NY 11218
(718) 853-3755

Open since 1966 on Kensington’s main drag, Korner is a neighborhood pizzeria par excellence, with a corner location boasting garden-style concrete tables out front for scarfing your slices, calzones, pastas, and heroes in fine weather. The inside dining room with the usual wavy-benched orange booths is equally comfortable, the walls plastered with photos and other reminiscences of Sicily. The regular cheese slice is perfection itself, with a lighter-than-air crust, thin coating of tomato sauce, and an extravagance of good cheese. For vegans, the broccoli rabe hero is recommended.

Korner Pizza Robert Sietsema

77. San Remo

Copy Link
1408 Cortelyou Rd
Brooklyn, NY 11226
(718) 282-4915

Established in 1976, San Remo offers a deep dining room favored by Ditmas Park families, and all the usual modern pies, including lasagna pizza, the everything pie, deep dish veggie (Chicago style), Buffalo chicken pizza, and vodka pie. The best, though, is the grandma, a variation on the regular Sicilian with a thinner crust, a more herbal sauce, and black pepper. It’s scrumptious.

San Remo Robert Sietsema

78. Original Pizza

Copy Link
6823 4th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11220
(718) 836-8055
Visit Website

Was the name, like Not Ray’s, created to thumb its nose at the once-mighty Ray’s Original chain? The pizza here is far better, with a thinner crust though still of the plain, old-fashioned slice sort. As in many neighborhood joints, the cheese is the thing — a lake of it, ramping up the protein component and the richness so that one slice is likely to do you for lunch. The location directly over the R train stop at Bay Ridge Avenue is a big asset.

Original Pizza Robert Sietsema

79. Bari Pasta & Pizza

Copy Link
596 Bay St
Staten Island, NY 10304
(718) 876-0002
Visit Website

In an iconic Stapleton location across the street from Tappen Park, Bari’s specializes in an indigenous type of Staten Island pie that features dense, dairy-driven toppings. Shown here are two representative slices: One is a pizza-fication of the Philly cheesesteak, swamped with thin-sliced steak, caramelized onions and peppers, and a Whiz-type cheese; the other attempts to mimic a pasta Alfredo in slice form. Both are rich and taste better than they look. The pizzeria is named after the capital of Apulia, the homeland of many Staten Islanders and Brooklynites.

Bari Pasta & Pizza Robert Sietsema

80. Pizza Wagon

Copy Link
8610 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11209
(718) 836-5725

Placing it among the most ancient and venerable of early neighborhood pizzerias, which saw their heyday in the 1950s and 1960s, Pizza Wagon was founded in 1966. It possesses one of the most convivial dining rooms in Bay Ridge, and doesn’t bother with a vast range of pie choices. Thus, most slices are served still warm from the oven, and a favorite is the Sicilian (only $2.50!): with a crisp and light crust, plenty of sweet tomato sauce, and a thick mantle of cheese. Open late.

Pizza Wagon Robert Sietsema

81. Mr. Phil's Pizza

Copy Link
7212 New Utrecht Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11228
(718) 234-4106
Visit Website

The upside-down Sicilian is star of the show at this classic Dyker Heights pizzeria (established in the ‘90s), which is more glitzy and comfortable than its brethren along New Utrecht Avenue, an ancient Dutch thoroughfare that dates to the 17th century. The slice in question is square, thinner, and crisper than most Sicilians, with the mozzarella next to the crust; the rich, thick, sweet tomato sauce on top of that; and a scatter of parmesan on top for enhanced saltiness and cheesiness. The garlic knots are especially good and so are the outsize, deep-fried rice balls, once again demonstrating Sicilian heritage of this excellent place.

Mr. Phil’s Pizza Robert Sietsema

82. Espresso Pizzeria

Copy Link
9403 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11209
(718) 833-8750

This Bay Ridge pizzeria elicits hyperbolic praise from its many fans, especially for its standard thin-crust cheese pie, with tomato sauce not too sweet, mozzarella not too rich or profuse, and a very light hand with the herbs. In fact, if we were to select a candidate for best cheese slice in Brooklyn, Espresso might win, representing a Platonic ideal of plainness. Says one fan, "It's pizza done simple, good, and right."

Espresso Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

83. King's Pizza

Copy Link
1688 East 16th Street
Brooklyn, NY 11229
(718) 627-8434
Visit Website

Located right around the corner from Kings Highway — hence the name — this grandstanding pizza parlor is especially orange in décor and delivers equally bold flavor. The bacon slice is wondrous, carpeted with smoked and crumbled pork belly, a greater quantity than you’d expect. The standard slice is of average thickness, with more cheese than usual and a little less sauce. Between 3 p.m. and 4 p.m., a tsunami of students, construction workers, and tradespeople blow in and throng the tiny shop.

King's Pizza Robert Sietsema

84. Pizza D'Oro

Copy Link
3115 Victory Blvd #1
Staten Island, NY 10314
(718) 698-8873
Visit Website

Lush, lush, lush, and thick-crusted, too, is the style of most Staten Island pizzerias (if you leave out places like Lee’s and Denino’s that specialize in cracker-type bar pies). Several notches above its neighborhood brethren, deades-old Pizza D’Oro (“Pie of Gold”) displays a glass case filled with pies that ramp up pizza’s richness, many available by the slice. One of the favorites is the lasagna pizza, multiplying cheeses and meats heaped high on the crust. Located in an old house now surrounded by a strip shopping center on the northwestern part of the island.

Pizza D’Oro Robert Sietsema

85. Bad Boys Pizza

Copy Link
2313 86th St
Brooklyn, NY 11214
(718) 266-4848
Visit Website

Situated in the midst of what is rapidly becoming the city’s fifth Chinatown, Bad Boys is a classic full-service pizzeria, rolling out such sidelines as baked manicotti, pepper-and-egg heros, and fried calamari. But the star of the show remains the pizzas, especially the fresh mozzarella pie with a soupçon of olive oil dribbled atop the cheese, and the square Sicilian, with a crust a little thinner and crunchier than most and a fragrant scatter of dried herbs.

Bad Boys Pizza Robert Sietsema

Loading comments...

1. Broadway Pizza & Pasta

192 W 231st St, Bronx, NY 10463
Broadway Pizza & Pasta Robert Sietsema

Located in hilly Kingsbridge and boasting a big and comfortable dining room, BPP is deluxe for a neighborhood joint. The best slice wasn’t the Neapolitan pepperoni or the Sicilian cheese, but the lasagna slice, with gobs of mellow ricotta, splotches of sweet sauce, and herb-scented ground beef. You won’t miss the noodles. For a bigger meal and a spicy kick in the pants, try the chicken fra diavolo ala Rosa, one among many entrees served with spaghetti, ziti, or salad with garlic bread. The slogan of this delightful spot is, “The taste you always come back to,” and we will!

192 W 231st St
Bronx, NY 10463

2. Brother’s

27 E Kingsbridge Rd, Bronx, NY 10468
Plain cheese slice Robert Sietsema

For 49 years Brother’s has occupied a prime spot in Fordham Manor, with the elevated 4 train towering overhead. The premises are very modest indeed. The plain slice is thin crusted and cheesy, and the sauce is practically unseasoned, which is just fine with me. Other pies beckon, more often available as whole pies rather than individual slices, including a lasagna pie, a salad pie, and a Hawaiian pie with ham and canned pineapple, a favorite in South America.

27 E Kingsbridge Rd
Bronx, NY 10468

3. University Pizza & Restaurant

574 E Fordham Rd, Bronx, NY 10458
University Pizza & Restaurant Robert Sietsema

On the northern verge of Belmont facing Fordham University, this pizzeria has been a longtime favorite of students and working-class neighborhood residents. The topping selection is paltry by modern standards, but the plain cheese slice is truly excellent, with a thin and nicely browned crust, a tomato sauce that whispers rather than shouts, and a painstaking strew of cheese that makes for the perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio.

574 E Fordham Rd
Bronx, NY 10458

4. Ivana's Pizzeria

2373 Arthur Ave, Bronx, NY 10458
Ivana's Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

This ancient pizzeria retains its nostalgic, time-worn décor, including dozens of framed photographs from the last six decades. The location is iconic: in the midst of the Bronx’s Little Italy (a/k/a Belmont or Arthur Avenue), the pizza here is much better than at surrounding, snazzier pizzerias. Start with the modest cheese slice, which glistens with exuded oils, necessitating the classic New York fold. The slice is salty, the crust nicely browned, the "bone" (circumferential crust) almost non-existent. This constitutes one of the Bronx’s best slices, idiosyncratic and made with evident pride.

2373 Arthur Ave
Bronx, NY 10458

5. Napoli's Best Pizza

521 E Tremont Ave, Bronx, NY 10457
Napoli’s Best Pizza Robert Sietsema

What a charming name! With a tip of the hat to Naples, this tiny pizzeria across the street from Tremont Park is usually thronged with locals enjoying the neighborhood’s best pizza. And this place doesn’t doll it up, either. There are two choices: a plain cheese wedge and a square, extra-thick Sicilian, unless you want pepperoni to be strewn across the top of your slice as an afterthought. The crust is the thing here, beautifully browned, with a little more dough around the circumference than you really need, in order to flaunt the crust’s excellence. And every morsel of crust gets eaten. Astonishingly, a whole 14-inch round pie can be had for $5.50.

521 E Tremont Ave
Bronx, NY 10457

6. Como Pizza

4035 Broadway, New York, NY 10032
Plain cheese slice Robert Sietsema

The slogan of this Washington Heights pizzeria not far from Columbia Presbyterian Hospital is, “Keep this place in mind, a better pizza is hard to find.” Como is one of those tiny places where the main output is mainly cheese slices, with each pie being subdivided and scooped up the minute it comes from the oven. The crowd loves these plain pies, and you rarely see extra toppings, though if you consult the menu pies with names like Hawaiian, meat eaters, and genuine Mediterranean (eggplant, black olives, and “authentic feta”) are available. Founded 1963, near the start of the neighborhood pizza era.

4035 Broadway
New York, NY 10032

7. P&M Classic Pizza and Restaurant

1747 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031
P&M Classic Pizza and Restaurant Robert Sietsema

This two-decade old pizzeria bills itself as “A Taste of Italy in Harlem” — and it is indeed, with an extended menu of chicken, veal, seafood, and eggplant, with full dinners under $20. But most folks dash in for a slice, and the overwhelming favorite is the pepperoni, the sliced sausage vying with the profuse tomato sauce for pungency. Sicilian slices and calzones are also worth ordering.

1747 Amsterdam Ave
New York, NY 10031

8. Olga's

3409 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
Olga’s Pizza Robert Sietsema

Offering virtually no place to sit and eat, only a narrow shelf that runs around the room, Olga’s on Upper Broadway in Hamilton Heights is nevertheless mobbed during the day with neighborhood types, who use it as a sort of stand-up social club. The slice is uber-cheesy, the crust pale and doughy, the tomato sauce less profuse than usual, and yet it tastes fantastic, showing how a distinct point of view is always an asset to a great neighborhood pizzeria.

3409 Broadway
New York, NY 10031

9. Best Italian Pizza

412 E 149th St, Bronx, NY 10455
Best Italian Pizza Robert Sietsema

This mainstay with a self-congratulatory name sits just east of the South Bronx shopping district called the Hub. Open since 1958, it was founded at the dawn of the neighborhood pizzeria era, when the stacked pizza oven was first popularized, and the old-fashioned interior, with an order window on the street, shows it. The slices are thicker, with lusher toppings than usual, and the accommodating pizzaioli will ladle extra sauce on a slice at your request. Get the white spinach, which boasts clouds of soft ricotta and plenty of garlic.

412 E 149th St
Bronx, NY 10455

10. Tom's Delicious Pizza

3161 Broadway, New York, NY 10027
Tom's Delicious Pizza Robert Sietsema

Founded just north of Columbia University in 1998 by brothers Tomas and Eduardo Ochoa, this small pizzeria turns out spectacular cheese slices. The crust is ultra-thin and crisp, the cheese thicker than usual, and the tomato sauce merely a pastel background to the rest. The smell of fresh garlic knots suffuses the air, and there’s a second branch in Union City, NJ, in case you happen to be in the town that’s right across the Hudson River.

3161 Broadway
New York, NY 10027

11. Golden Pizza

504 E 138th St, Bronx, NY 10454
A slice of plain cheese pizza sits on a white paper plate placed on a brown counter. Robert Sietsema

Golden is about as bare-bones as a pizzeria can be, yet it has obviously been feeding the populace of its Mott Haven neighborhood for a good long time. The dining room is standing-only, and the counter routinely displays only one kind of slice, yet what a slice it is. Trim, nicely clotted with good cheese, not quite thin-crusted but crisp and tasty nonetheless. You can have some pepperoni thrown on top, but it’s not necessary. And, miracle of miracles, an entire cheese pie can be had for $6.50, which is less than dollar slice places charge.

504 E 138th St
Bronx, NY 10454

12. Mama's TOO!

2750 Broadway, New York, NY 10025
Square pepperoni slice Robert Sietsema

Mama’s Too is one of the new crop of neighborhood pizzerias that have reconfigured their slices to be more modern and innovative than that of the classic neighborhood pizzeria. (The place is related to a more conventional pizzeria on Amsterdam Avenue.) This is all to the good, you’ll realize as you survey the collection of square pies with rich crusts and atypical toppings. The pepperoni slice uses a small-bore sausage packed tightly on the slice, weeping paprika oil down on the crust. Other pies include caramelized onion and mushroom, and zucchini with Kalamata olives.

2750 Broadway
New York, NY 10025

13. Sal and Carmine Pizza

2671 Broadway, New York, NY 10025
A white plate with a single slice of cheese pizza. Robert Sietsema

Pizzaiolo Sal Malanga opened this popular Upper West Side joint in 1959 and ran it until his death in 2011. His crust remains the quintessential element — "crisp on the outside and tender on the inside" as pizza fanatic Ed Levine once put it. Thereafter Sal’s grandson Lou keeps the place up and running, and the cheese slice is as good as always — great crust, with a tomato sauce and cheese that merge into a mysterious amalgam.

2671 Broadway
New York, NY 10025

14. Sam’s Famous Pizzeria

150 E 116th St, New York, NY 10029
Sam’s Famous Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

Sam’s is a throwback to the ’60s, when East Harlem was one of the city’s most prominent Italian neighborhoods. Now it and Rao’s are two of the few surviving institutions of that era. The place is narrow and efficient, and turns out a bigger range of products than seems possible given the small space. The pizza crust is especially thin and crisp (the dough is made on premises), and the regular slice is on the cheesy side with a big thick “bone” (circumferential edge). Among specialty slices, the three meat (pepperoni, bacon, Italian sausages) is especially fine and greasy, and the chicken parm slice a nice invention. Garlic knots A+.

150 E 116th St
New York, NY 10029

15. Cheesy Pizza

2640 Broadway, New York, NY 10025
Cheesy Pizza Robert Sietsema

The name says it all at this Upper West Side institution dedicated to the dairy component of the classic slice. The cheese here is so profuse, it threatens to roll off the pie. Sure, the crust is a bit doughy and pale ensuring the sauce recedes into the background. But gradually as you eat it, you’ll realize the other components have been formulated so you can better worship the molten cheese.

2640 Broadway
New York, NY 10025

Related Maps

16. Luigi's Pizzeria

1701 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10128
Grandma slice Robert Sietsema

This Upper East Side mainstay has been pumping out the slices since 1997, offering a sauce slightly sweeter and chunkier than average. Our favorite is the grandma, a square slice in the upside down formation, meaning that the cheese is on the bottom and the sauce on top, so that the imperially thin crust doesn’t get soggy. That the crust is also on the thin size for a square slice, and a little bit oily, is an added bonus, and so is the shredded basil sprinkled on top.

1701 1st Avenue
New York, NY 10128

17. Delizia 73

1374 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10021
Delizia 73 Robert Sietsema

A mural of Venice graces one wall of this venerable Upper East Side pizzeria — with Superman flying overhead, looking for criminals. If you want to feel like you’re sitting in a real restaurant while scarfing your two slices and a soft drink, this is your place. And the quality of the pies makes it a destination spot, too. Our favorite is the grandma slice: In the square format, it displays cheese-on-the-bottom pizza-tecture, with splotches of herb-y sauce on top.

1374 1st Avenue
New York, NY 10021

18. Astoria Hot Pizza

32-04 30th Ave, Long Island City, NY 11102
Astoria Hot Pizza Robert Sietsema

Who can resist the white slice at Astoria Hot Pizza, with its masses of ricotta and mozzarella on an un-tomatoed crust, like driven snow after a blizzard. The chicken slice is another favorite: a diced cutlet, tasting fresh from the fryer, scattered across what would otherwise be a regular cheese slice. It’s like a deconstructed chicken cutlet parm hero. This place shares space with a Middle Eastern grocery store, which allows an unusual latitude in the selection of beverages.

32-04 30th Ave
Long Island City, NY 11102

19. Luigi's Gourmet Pizza

936 8th Ave, New York, NY 10019
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza Robert Sietsema

This commodious pizzeria just south of Central Park has deep Sicilian roots and the slices show it magnificently. The best offerings fall among the square-slices including the musketa, which features chopped tomatoes and onions on a thick bed of cheese; and the oxymoronic Sicilian margarita slice, which melts artisanal mozzarella and shoots splotches of tomato sauce over an exceedingly well-browned crust.

936 8th Ave
New York, NY 10019

20. Famous Amadeus

840 8th Ave, New York, NY 10019
Meat lover’s slice Robert Sietsema

This pizzeria not far from the Broadway theaters treats its output like a dramatic event. Dating from 1994, it flaunts a long glass counter with a ridiculous number of pie choices. Sometimes you just need lots of meat, and the meat lover’s pie features sausage, bacon, and pepperoni. Other sporadically available pies deploy Portuguese chorizo, Philly cheesesteak, lemony chicken Francese, and Tex-Mex jalapeños and seasoned ground beef.

840 8th Ave
New York, NY 10019

21. Belmora

139 E 57th St, New York, NY 10022
Belmora Robert Sietsema

This agreeable East Side pizzeria offers a larger dining room than most and a sunny southern exposure. The slices are about average in thickness and crispness, with a tomato sauce rich and herbal but not sweet. Its forte is unexpected combinations of ingredients, including a great pepperoni and black olive slice that turns out to be fantastic. Plus, it's open at 8 a.m., seven days a week — in case you'd like a slice for breakfast.

139 E 57th St
New York, NY 10022

22. Steinway Pizza

31-51 Steinway St, Astoria, NY 11103
Steinway Pizza Robert Sietsema

Wavy orange seats on the formica booths are classic neighborhood pizzeria décor, and often cue you that a great slice is on the way. And so are the gargantuan stacks of pre-folded pizza boxes at this classic parlor on a busy Astoria shopping strip. Go straight for the plain cheese slice, with a magnificently thin and floppy crust, large bone (the circumferential edge), and unusually large quantity of cheese, which is not a burden but a pleasure. One of the mellowest slices in Queens.

31-51 Steinway St
Astoria, NY 11103

23. Polito's Pizza

38-12 Broadway, Astoria, NY 11103
Polito's Pizza Robert Sietsema

Though it was established in 1981 and not long ago appeared timeworn, a more recent renovation has left this Astorian stalwart handsome and comfortable, a place to linger. The grandma slice is the one to get. Perfect for its type, it sports a lush and deep red tomato sauce, flecked with little bits of garlic and onion that add sweetness, and the cheese is exemplary, too.

38-12 Broadway
Astoria, NY 11103

24. Gianni's

81-13 Northern Blvd, Jackson Heights, NY 11372
Gianni's Robert Sietsema

Gianni’s is a classic 1980 Jackson Heights pizzeria, heavy on the Sicilian influences, with an ambitious menu, but a premises that says “pizzeria” rather than “fancy restaurant.” There’s a nice little backyard, and the thing to not miss is the Sicilian slice. The bottom side of the crust is brown and crisp, the crumb light as air, the sauce on the sweet side, and the cheese tumbles over the side like a waterfall.

81-13 Northern Blvd
Jackson Heights, NY 11372

25. Kiss My Slice

274 W 40th St, New York, NY 10018
Kiss My Slice Robert Sietsema

There is a kind of modern neighborhood pizza parlor that flaunts its creativity, turning out oddball slices that seek to compete with other forms of fast food, either by poaching on their territory, or just by jumping up and down and shouting, "Me! Me! Me!" The sassily named Kiss My Slice does both, as seen by a careful examination of its epic fried chicken and waffle slice. The waffle has been minced into individual boxes, the fried chicken cut in cubes, and a drizzle of pancake syrup, probably constituting the first time syrup has been put on a slice of pizza. Pineapple-and-pepperoni is another strange slice choice.

274 W 40th St
New York, NY 10018

26. Uncle Paul's Pizza

70 Vanderbilt Ave, New York, NY 10017
Uncle Paul's Pizza Robert Sietsema

Clad in green marble, why is this pizzeria directly across the street from Grand Central so elegant? The interior gleams and the patrons are often well-dressed businesspeople. Yet they’re ordering slices like more typical pizza parlor patrons, though these slices often seem denser and fresher than usual. Our favorite is the lasagna slice, which emulates a serving of lasagna with its rich sauce, ground beef, and ricotta cheese that plays second fiddle to lots of mozzarella. Open 24 hours.

70 Vanderbilt Ave
New York, NY 10017

27. Daro's Pizza & Chicken

4425 Kissena Blvd, Flushing, NY 11355
Daro’s Pizza & Chicken Robert Sietsema

Surrounded by Northern Chinese restaurants, Daro’s is tasked with fulfilling two pressing neighborhood needs: pizza and fried chicken, a combination common enough in Brooklyn’s Afghani-owned fried chicken joints. Here it seems like the pizza predated the bird, because the list of pies is far more sophisticated than the chicken menu. A case in point is the grandma slice, thin-crusted and utilizing fresh mozzarella, premium tomato sauce, and fresh basil — an herb not easy to find in these parts. Hot heroes are another strong point, especially the iconic egg and peppers.

4425 Kissena Blvd
Flushing, NY 11355

28. Bravo Pizza

6 E 42nd St, New York, NY 10017
Bravo Pizza Robert Sietsema

This especially comfortable pizzeria is part of a Manhattan mini-chain, with a deep dark interior kept cool in sweltering weather, and mounts an enticing display of by-the-slice pies to lure passersby, some of them rather creative. Of several sampled, the one topped with pepperoni and canned jalapeños was the most enthralling, mouth-tingling in the best possible way.

6 E 42nd St
New York, NY 10017

29. Highline Pizzeria

503 W 28th St, New York, NY 10001
Highline Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

Proving again that even today neighborhood pizzerias are opening up, Highline appeared not too long ago on the edge of Hudson Yards, peddling a menu of predictable slices with a few new twists. The pale crust is distinguished, and one of the best uses is in a pie topped with cubed chicken cutlet and fresh ripe tomato. This place floods with construction workers from nearby high-rises in the post-noon period.

503 W 28th St
New York, NY 10001

30. NY Pizza Suprema

413 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001
NY Pizza Suprema Robert Sietsema

Located directly southwest of Penn Station since 1964, NY Pizza Suprema is undoubtedly one of the most celebrated neighborhood pizzerias in Manhattan. The lavish display of pies under glass right inside the front entrance provides a beguiling dilemma, but we generally spring for any of the Sicilian slices, which have a bit of oil in the dough and are thus crunchier than most. The sausage Sicilian is particularly dope, miring shavings of good fennel sausage in a profuse floe of cheese. Open until midnight, seven days.

413 8th Ave
New York, NY 10001

31. Mario's

77-09 37th Ave, Jackson Heights, NY 11372
Mario's Robert Sietsema

While most of the neighborhood pizzerias we extol originated in the ’50s, ’60s, and ’70s, when the neighborhood pizza parlor movement was at its height, here’s a new one — founded in 2015 in Jackson Heights — that proves the formula is still sound. The inside is brightly lit, the counter is at the rear of the space, and one wall is decorated with white paper plates painted by young Mario’s fans. Garlic knots and grandma slices are better than most, but the plain cheese slice is the real triumph here, more thin crusted than most, with a thick coating of slightly sweet and herby tomato sauce painted on the crust, and an average amount of cheese. A great slice to eat while walking down the street, not too messy.

77-09 37th Ave
Jackson Heights, NY 11372

32. Pizza Bella

8130 Broadway, Flushing, NY 11373
Pizza Bella Robert Sietsema

Flaunting a nautical theme, Pizza Bella stands out on Elmhurst’s Broadway among the mainly Southeast Asian cafes. The plain cheese slice is plain as plain can be, with a precise and carefully calculated inter-relationship of cheese, sauce, and crust. The crust itself is done to a premeditated brownness. This is pizza for folks who don’t like bells and whistles.

8130 Broadway
Flushing, NY 11373

33. Stella's

110 9th Ave #1, New York, NY 10011
Stella’s Pizza Robert Sietsema

Founded in 1997, this Chelsea mainstay seems far older. The regular slice is especially tomatoey and slightly salty, best enjoyed as part of the $5 lunch special (two slices and a can of soda). On the other hand, then you’d miss the dense white broccoli slice, which features cloudy masses of ricotta and mozzarella. Seating is limited to a gleaming metal counter, and you should see the line that winds out the door during mealtimes! Are those Roy Lichtenstein prints on the walls? He once lived nearby.

110 9th Ave #1
New York, NY 10011

34. Giovanni’s Pizzeria

45-59 47th St, Woodside, NY 11377
Giovanni’s Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

This Woodside pizzeria of ancient vintage always had a larger menu than most. On top of the regular pies, there are pastas, heroes, salads, steaks and chops, and belt-busting, all-in Italian dinners. But in addition, the place now serves Mexican food, so that you can have guac and chips alongside your Sicilian slice. The cemitas (round Pueblan sandwiches) have become neighborhood favorites. Hopefully, the Mexican and Italian menus will begin fusing, and we can expect a Mexican pizza strewn with chiles and cactus strips, or maybe chipotle chicken, in the future.

45-59 47th St
Woodside, NY 11377

35. Marabella

4107 Greenpoint Ave, Sunnyside, NY 11104
Marabella Robert Sietsema

Debuting in 1984 and occupying a distinctive corner location in Sunnyside, Marabella is proud of its Sicilian roots, as evidenced by the choice of art and maps on the walls. The ovens stand right inside the front door to make it easy to dash in and out for a slice. You should look no further than the fine grandma slice, which is square and thin-crusted, sporting fresh mozzarella and thick, sweet tomato sauce. Unique to Marabella are sandwiches (the pizzeria calls focaccia) made by splitting a thick wedge of pizza and piling it with chicken parm and other fillings.

4107 Greenpoint Ave
Sunnyside, NY 11104

36. Village Pizza

65 8th Ave, New York, NY 10014
Village Pizza Robert Sietsema

We have a particular affection for pizzerias squished into tiny spaces, where the ovens dominated the visual landscape and a single employee serves as pie wrangler and clerk. Just down the block from an important subway stop, Village Pizza is just such a place, with a surprisingly large collection of slices for its cramped premises. The buffalo chicken is one the best, featuring a cut-up chicken cutlet and tart sauce that delivers a spicy and vinegary tang. Some say this slice was invented by pizzerias trying to get in on the football-party delivery action without actually doing wings.

65 8th Ave
New York, NY 10014

37. Gino’s Pizza

86-35 Broadway, Elmhurst, NY 11373
Gino’s Pizza Robert Sietsema

Since 1968, this quaint pizzeria has lingered beside Elmhurst’s busiest bus stop. Quaint because the limestone-faced walls and carriage lamps make it seem a bit like a village inside. Vegetarian is the way to go here, via a series of pies in a separate case of slightly smaller circumference, including an eggplant slice that looks to be almost a quarter of a pie — a bit more expensive than most slices, but also encompassing square inches of pizza territory.

86-35 Broadway
Elmhurst, NY 11373

38. Lunetta

245 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10010
Lunetta Robert Sietsema

The stylish pizzeria (the name means “Little Moon”) is on the verge of becoming an actual restaurant, but the emphasis remains staunchly on some excellent pies, with a sauce perhaps a little sweeter than usual. The margherita is a round, thin crust pie with fresh mozzarella and little wads of crushed tomatoes here and there, creating a prodigious mouth wallop. A larger than usual roster of apps, subs, hamburgers, heros, and cheesesteaks provide enhanced dinner options.

245 3rd Ave
New York, NY 10010

39. Triangolo Pizzeria

1017 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222
Triangolo Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

Located on the northern reaches of Manhattan Avenue, Triangolo is one of Greenpoint’s most distinguished neighborhood parlors. Look through the glass display counter and pick what looks best — on a recent visit, it was an extra thick slice with sauce and cheese, dotted with bacon, pepperoni, and ground beef. The cheese and spinach stromboli, with a particularly crisp crust, was also exemplary. Dig the lettering on the neon sign outside, and don’t miss the cryptic Steven Seagal shrine.

1017 Manhattan Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11222

40. Joe's Pizza

7 Carmine St, New York, NY 10014
A slice of pepperoni pizza on a white paper plate. Robert Sietsema

King of the neighborhood pizza parlors, Manhattan edition, Joe’s offers a slice magnificent in its plainness, appreciated by generations of New Yorkers and visitors. No frou-frou here, just a well-pureed sauce and just enough cheese — but not too much — and one of the city’s most perfect crusts. On the other hand, for just a bit more you can get the fresh mozzarella slice, with little annealed gobs of newly minted cheese. But the best-selling slice, according to a counter guy I talked to, is the pepperoni slice. Miraculously, new branches of this place near Union Square, Times Square, and in Williamsburg have not diminished its brilliance.

7 Carmine St
New York, NY 10014

41. Franklin Pizza

109 Franklin St, Brooklyn, NY 11222
Franklin Pizza Robert Sietsema

Yes, the swells head further down Greenpoint Avenue for Paulie Gee’s, a wood oven place with some weird and sometimes spectacular pies. Franklin is conveniently located just across the street from the historic Pencil Factory bar, so that you can see beer fans knocking off a slice or two before scampering across the street. Featuring both ricotta and mozzarella, the broccoli slice is a particular fave, and the drinkers all know that one constitutes a perfectly balanced meal.

109 Franklin St
Brooklyn, NY 11222

42. Italy Pizza

800 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222
Italy Pizza Robert Sietsema

Are you a fan of the white slice? This narrow pizzeria — with a stamped-tin ceiling and other features that telegraph its age — specializes in these slices, with a white pie always displayed on the counter. The cheese is profusely laid on, with so much garlic, you’ll be burping it for hours if not days afterwards. Lasagna, garlic knots, and salads are also recommended at this establishment in the Greenpoint business district, close to bars and clubs.

800 Manhattan Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11222

43. TuArepa Pizza Cafe

100-22 67th Ave, Queens, NY 11375
TuArepa Pizza Cafe Robert Sietsema

Taken over not too long ago by a Chinese-Venezuelan owner, this pizzeria just off Queens Boulevard in Forest Hills was already a historic and fully functioning institution. Now it also serves overstuffed arepa sandwiches, fried and baked empanadas, cheese-stuffed cachapas, and other Venezuelan fare as a sideline. The pizzas, though, remain uncommonly solid, including a plain slice with extra cheese, a narrow bone (the bare outside edge of the slice), and a bland tomato sauce that makes this example typical of great neighborhood slices. Other more contemporary slices include the baked ziti, the Hawaiian, and the bacon chicken ranch, the last slice gobbed with salad dressing.

100-22 67th Ave
Queens, NY 11375

44. Rosalia's Pizzeria

103-15 Queens Blvd, Forest Hills, NY 11375
Spinach and artichoke slice Robert Sietsema

Proving that old-style neighborhood pizzerias are not a bygone phenomenon, Rosalia’s opened not long ago in Forest Hills, with the same owner as Luzzo’s in the East Village and Gansevoort Market. You can tell the proprietor is a Staten Islander the minute you bite into the spinach and artichoke slice: wads of spinach, a strew of chopped artichoke leaves and choke, little hills of melting ricotta, and a soupy greenish sauce. In Staten Island, the semi-liquid slice is king.

103-15 Queens Blvd
Forest Hills, NY 11375

45. Rosario's Pizza

173 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002
Robert Sietsema

The crust is thicker, stiffer, and more browned at this Lower East Side stalwart founded in 1963. For the meat lover, there’s a slice with pepperoni and Italian sausage, buoyed by plenty of mozzarella. In fact, the pizzeria describes this slice and several others as deep dish, referencing a Chicago-style pizza rarely seen in New York, especially among neighborhood pizza parlors. We're lucky to be able to buy it by the slice.

173 Orchard St
New York, NY 10002

46. Gloria Pizza

108-22 Queens Blvd, Forest Hills, NY 11375
Gloria Pizza Robert Sietsema

This downtown Forest Hills fixture goes all the way back to 1960, but underwent a hiatus early in this century. Now it’s back and better than ever, offering a well-windowed dining room and the usual rich profusion of slice choices. Our fave is the grandma slice: a crisp, square crust with an impressive slab of mozzarella, a slice of fresh tomato, and strips of roasted red pepper, making for an unusual slice that tastes like an Italian street fair.

108-22 Queens Blvd
Forest Hills, NY 11375

47. Champion Pizza

187 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Champion Pizza Robert Sietsema

Proving that neighborhood pizzerias are still viable, even as more expensive and pretentious pizzerias have become common, Champion is a mini-chain with a newish branch in Williamsburg. Sold by the slice, most of the pizzas are square, the crusts relatively thin, and done to a dark brown. Toppings are innovative, too, including one slice that features alternate bands of green pesto and red tomato sauce, like a Morris Lewis painting in the Museum of Modern Art.

187 Bedford Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11211

48. Dona Bella Pizza

154 Church St, New York, NY 10007
Dona Bella Pizza Robert Sietsema

Holding down an incredibly expensive corner location in Tribeca, Dona Bella ("Beautiful Lady") puts an almost surreal amount of energy into its eye-socking window display. The crusts on the Neapolitan slices are a little thicker than usual, the toppings moister and more opulently applied. A case in point is the wonderful mushroom slice, to which a great heap of ‘shrooms has been applied, and plenty of cheese, too. The round fresh mozzarella pie is also great, with big splotches of sweet tomato sauce.

154 Church St
New York, NY 10007

49. San Marco Pizzería

577 Lorimer St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
San Marco Pizzería Robert Sietsema

Named after a famous piazza in Venice and dating to 1969, Williamsburg’s San Marco Pizzeria is perhaps the most beautiful and elegant establishment of its type. Seating is mainly at a polished granite counter that faces the pizza oven; a series of signs display the menu, for which there is no paper equivalent; and pies are restricted, for all practical purposes, to plain cheese and plain Sicilian. The cheese slice is austere, with a tomato sauce not the slightest bit sweet, and plenty of salty cheese, making it an entirely savory experience.

577 Lorimer St
Brooklyn, NY 11211

50. Sal's Pizzeria

544 Lorimer St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Sal's Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

This 1967 neighborhood pizzeria is more elegant than most, with views out the big picture windows (which open in fine weather) and good wine and beer available to wash pizza down. The eggplant slice features crisp, crumbed slices of vegetable, hillocks of ricotta, and a thin crust that invites you to eat the thing with a knife and fork. And nobody will laugh at you if you do.

544 Lorimer St
Brooklyn, NY 11211

51. Little Italy Pizza

11 Park Pl, New York, NY 10007
Little Italy Pizza Robert Sietsema

All Little Italy franchises are not the same. In fact, some are superb while others awful, with doughy crusts and lifeless tomato sauces. The City Hall branch is one of the great ones, and you can tell the minute you step inside and see the elated diners. A favorite slice is the carbonara, which features two kinds of cheese along with shards of prosciutto, making it one of the city’s few pies to utilize that cold-cut cooked. Open 24 hours.

11 Park Pl
New York, NY 10007

52. Sabrina's

294 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Sabrina's Robert Sietsema

Founded in 1977 in the shadow of the M and J tracks, this parlor is young in pizzeria years, but excels at all the classic pies and hero sandwiches. Some of the best things on the menu, though, show a Latin bent. For example, the miniature pie called an onion pizzette is about as close as you can get to a real Buenos Aires fugazetta. Other favorites include a spinach-ricotta slice that seems positively healthy, and an idiosyncratic take on a hot dog, wrapping it in pizza dough with melted cheese. Delicious!

294 Broadway
Brooklyn, NY 11211

53. Underground Pizza

3 Hanover Square, New York, NY 10004
Underground Pizza Robert Sietsema

How does a simple independent slice joint stay in business in the Wall Street area? By serving some of the best pizza in town in a somewhat shabby and abject location a few steps below street level. Nevertheless, this is a frequently recommended favorite among brokers, clerks, digital journalists, and non-profit wonks who labor in the neighborhood. The fresh mozzarella slice is especially enticing, with splotches of sweet herby tomato sauce, great mozzarella that doesn’t go all soggy, and a memorably crisp, browned crust.

3 Hanover Square
New York, NY 10004

54. Georgio's Pizza

20 Beaver St, New York, NY 10004
Georgio's Pizza Robert Sietsema

Founded in 2011, Georgio’s is master of the thick, lush pie, so expect to be fully fed on a single slice. The chicken and spinach, for example, matches breaded, fried, and diced bird with swirls of dense, dark spinach. This favorite of FiDi office workers is mobbed at lunch, nearly empty in the evening.

20 Beaver St
New York, NY 10004

55. Sal's Pizzeria

119 Wyckoff Ave #1, Brooklyn, NY 11237
Sal's Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

This antediluvian Bushwick pizzeria that resides above the DeKalb stop on the L dates back to the days when this was an Italian neighborhood and its sausage roll was fabled. In terms of pizza, go for the Sicilian slice. It's thick and square and brown as a beetle, with little rivulets of sauce and cheese and a generous sprinkling of dried Romano for extra saltiness and flavor. It's worth traveling from another borough to try!

119 Wyckoff Ave #1
Brooklyn, NY 11237

56. Pranzo Pizza & Pasta

34 Water St, New York, NY 10004
Pranzo Pizza & Pasta Robert Sietsema

This ancient pizzeria, shuttered for nearly a year by Hurricane Sandy tucks way downtown in a Manhattan maritime location, a stone’s throw from the Staten Island Ferry. Around lunchtime lines are long. Slices are noticeably lush, with an average thickness, an extra-crisp crust and a nicely-browned bone or cornicione. A favorite slice features spinach and a tidal wave of cheese — but no tomato sauce. It's fit for a full meal.

34 Water St
New York, NY 10004

57. Tony’s Pizzeria and Restaurant

443 Knickerbocker Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237
Tony’s Pizza Bushwick and DeKalb Robert Sietsema

Since the 1970s, when Bushwick was still an Italian stronghold, Tony’s Pizza has been turning out near-perfect pies on Knickerbocker Avenue, a stone’s throw from Maria Hernandez Park, once known as Bushwick Park. The slice is austere in its structure: the crust pale and thinner than most, but crisp; the sauce mild and only slightly sweet; the better-than-average cheese strewn with a generous hand. Devotees also extol the hot heroes, potato-lovers pie, and fried calamari.

443 Knickerbocker Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11237

58. Tony's Pizza Spot

431 Dekalb Ave # A, Brooklyn, NY 11205
Tony's Pizza Spot Robert Sietsema

This Clinton Hill pizzeria shows its extreme age, via a narrow sagging interior, intriguing clutter, and menu that doesn’t subscribe to the latest pizza fads (no buffalo chicken pizza, for example). This makes it a great place to imagine what neighborhood pizza was like 40 years ago, with a charming plainness in its sturdy crust, slightly sweet sauce, and liberal hand with the cheese. Want variety? Pile on the anchovies.

431 Dekalb Ave # A
Brooklyn, NY 11205

59. My Little Pizzeria

114 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
My Little Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

What pizza parlor boasts outdoor seating in the back? This one in downtown Brooklyn does, and also a large dining room perfect for accommodating lunchtime crowds. The supreme slice is the one to get, with an unusually thin crust for a fresh mozzarella slice, browned more than most and hence crisp. The cheese is cooked a little more, too. This is an atypical take on a classic slice, and six or seven more slices are commonly available at any given time.

114 Court St
Brooklyn, NY 11201

60. Pipitone's Pizza Restaurant

100 Dekalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201
Pipitone's Pizza Restaurant Robert Sietsema

This stalwart on the edge of Fort Greene Park popular with Brooklyn Tech students offers neighborhood pizza with a distinctly Sicilian bent. The upside-down Sicilian has become something of a local legend — with the copious cheese nestling next to the crust, to preserve its adamantine crispness under the onslaught of the sweet, deeply red sauce.

100 Dekalb Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11201

61. Caruso's

150 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
Fresh mozzarella slice with sesame crust Robert Sietsema

Proudly proclaiming itself the oldest pizzeria on Smith Street (there’s really not all that much competition), Caruso’s also functions as an a Italian restaurant, with an expanded roster of pastas and dinner entrees. These are all fine, but the pizza is particularly good, including several round pies featuring fresh mozzarella. The pie called “fresh mozzarella” is the most engaging, and it can be made with the restaurant’s signature sesame crust, whereby the ridge around the pie is implanted with seeds, probably a practice of Sicilian or even Greek origin. Whoever invented it, the slice is absolutely great.

150 Smith St
Brooklyn, NY 11201

62. Not Ray's Pizza

694 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Not Ray's Pizza Robert Sietsema

Making fun of the Famous Ray's and its imitators, Not Ray's is a normal neighborhood pizza parlor in a memorable, wedge-shaped space right on Fulton Street. The slice has a narrow "bone" (the bare circumference of the pie), the cheese is modestly applied, and the tomato sauce piquant and somewhat sweet. The slice is a little gloppier than usual and a molten cheese-sauce hybrid spills over the sides. Dying for novelty? Try the Buffalo chicken or Caesar salad pies.

694 Fulton St
Brooklyn, NY 11217

63. Armando's Pizza

1717 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11207
Armando's Pizza

This newish Ocean Hill establishment is a branch of a long-running Canarsie pizzeria that’s been in the D’Arpa family since 1968, now being run by a third generation. Like the sign outside says, the mini-chain’s specialty is the Sicilian slice (only $2.50!), and you’ve never tasted better. The bread is thick and bouncy, but paradoxically light-textured, and the sauce in the typical Sicilian style is a little on the sweet side. In addition, there’s a strong taste of oregano, which may or may not be due to the Greek origin of many Sicilians. Other specialties include a delicious, sesame-seeded ground beef stromboli, pepperoni pinwheels, and meatball rolls.

1717 Broadway
Brooklyn, NY 11207

64. Rocco Pizza III

330 Halsey St, Brooklyn, NY 11216
Rocco Pizza III Robert Sietsema

Some say this sunken pizzeria on a side street was the inspiration for Spike Lee’s Do the Right Thing. Whether it was or not, the pizzas are damn good, with a slightly thicker crust than usual, and some fairly creative toppings. The margarita slice is memorable, pooled with fresh mozzarella and dotted with herbs, while the lasagna slice mimics that casserole with an insane amount of delicately seasoned ground beef and wads of fresh ricotta.

330 Halsey St
Brooklyn, NY 11216

65. Bergen Pizza

67 6th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Bergen Pizza Robert Sietsema

This quintessential Brooklyn pizzeria has seen progress overtake it. Where once its main feature was proximity to a police precinct, now it’s being engulfed by the nearby Atlantic Yards developments. For a neighborhood joint, it sure has a nice dining room, though perhaps a little more lit than you might like. The thing to get here is the Sicilian slice, which is nicely salty with more cheese than you usually get. The crumb is dense enough that one’s a meal. Salads are unexpectedly spot-on here.

67 6th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11217

66. Pizza Town

85 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Pizza Town Robert Sietsema

This lively pizzeria with some nifty murals has been a mainstay of 5th Avenue in the Slope since before that thoroughfare was even considered part of the Slope. The regular slice boasts a thicker and crisper crust than usual, and many patrons go for the extensive collection of novelties — such as the Buffalo chicken slice, the vodka slice, and the square Sicilian fried-eggplant slice with fresh mozzarella, surmounted by a very large basil leaf. But best of all is the stuffed slice, which features Italian sausage, pepperoni, potatoes, and cheese pressed between a double crust — it’s double delicious, and identifies the roots of Pizzatown in Abruzzi, where such pizzas are a specialty.

85 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11217

67. Pizza Chef

1512 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11213
Pizza Chef Robert Sietsema

Occupying a prime location right on Fulton, Pizza Chef is an ancient pizza parlor taken over by Muslim proprietors, who have left the interior intact but removed pork products from the menu. Instead, they lavish each slice with extra cheese, and do a special job on such local favorites as barbecue pizza: chicken chunks swimming in sweet barbecue sauce positioned above the cheese so the slice doesn’t get soggy — brilliant pizza architecture.

1512 Fulton St
Brooklyn, NY 11213

68. Giardini Pizza

363 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Giardini Pizza Robert Sietsema

Proving how a pizzeria can anchor an entire neighborhood — in this case Carroll Gardens — Giardini is a daytime haven for hungry school kids, card-playing seniors, and shoppers dashing in for a fortifying bite. In the evenings, dating couples and families fill the space, which boasts an outdoor garden. The pizza is made with great thought and care; the grandma slice here is in the upside-down Sicilian format, with a wealth of cheese beneath the tomato sauce, and a crust so good you’d eat it by itself.

363 Smith St
Brooklyn, NY 11231

69. Tomato N Basil

226 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Tomato N Basil Robert Sietsema

This pocket-size pizzeria right above the R stop at Union Street in Gowanus excels at modern notions of neighborhood pizza. Consistent with its name, the square, compact grandma slice is the one to get, with the cheese on the bottom, sauce on top, and several basil leaves imparting sweet flavor on top. The eggplant and chicken-ricotta pies are also worth sampling.

226 4th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11215

70. Antonio's

318 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Grandma slice Robert Sietsema

An old newspaper article pinned beside the door proclaims Antonio’s 50th anniversary, so by now it must be much older. The Park Slope stalwart is all over the map pizza-wise, even making an approximation of deep-dish Chicago pies, and regular pies with Alfredo and vodka sauces, as if pizza were pasta. Amid the welter of pizza forms is a perfect grandma — a paradoxically square and thin slice, with the crust like a piece of delicious cardboard. Splotches of mutz and torn basil leaves powerfully scent the pie.

318 Flatbush Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11217

71. Tony’s

850 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225
Jerk chicken slice Robert Sietsema

Jeez there must be dozens of pizzerias in the five boroughs named Tony’s. This one distinctively occupies a rather grand corner double-storefront with plenty of windows, through which the snow looks rather dramatic as it falls softly on Crown Heights. The stacked ovens turn out all the usual pies, and there’s also a sideline in jerk chicken, a neighborhood favorite. Torn into pieces, that bird goes on a slice, with some barbecue sauce striped on for extra sweetness. Hey, it’s good!

850 Nostrand Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11225

72. Luigi's Pizza

686 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Luigi's Pizza Robert Sietsema

Just how many pizzerias named Luigi’s are there in the five boroughs? Plenty, we’re sure. Located in Greenwood Heights, this one (founded in 1973) functions as a sort of community center in a neighborhood increasingly uncertain how to define itself. The pizzas are especially good, with some relatively unusual toppings, including a wonderful pie with soppressata and jalapeños, fusing old and new aspects of the neighborhood.

686 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11215

73. Family Pizza

720 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225
Plain cheese slice Robert Sietsema

What could be more perfect than a plain cheese slice, fabulously rendered? That’s the main output of Family Pizza on Flatbush Avenue. The crust is thin, but manages to be soft on the top and crisp on the bottom, a miraculous stratification in such a thin-crusted slice. The sauce is memorable by having no trace of sweetness; the cheese plain as plain can be. It’s as if the god of all pizza had asked that a slice be reduced to its simplest and most perfect formulation.

720 Flatbush Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11225

74. Xochil Pizzeria

4613 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220
Xochil Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

This delightful Sunset Park pizzeria has been taken over by Pueblans, who have mounted a griddle in the window — actually, sticking out of the window — where tlaycoyos are grilled and then topped with queso seco and salsa. The conventional pizza slices are fine, too, especially an unusual stuffed-crust pie. Filled with sausage and potatoes, it probably originated in Abruzzo, where such pizzas are common.

4613 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11220

75. Rocky’s Pizzeria

474 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11218
Rocky’s Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

This Kensington establishment at the corner of Church and C.I.A. (Coney Island Avenue) has been around since the days of the original Rocky movie, and the interior — ablaze in neon — features boxing memorabilia. The plain cheese slice is great, but why not go for the more spectacular ziti slice. Contrary to type, it also features lots of meat sauce to go with the pasta, making it a real pizza-pasta hybrid. Just try to eat more than one slice.

474 Coney Island Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11218

76. Korner Pizza

226 Church Ave # 1, Brooklyn, NY 11218
Korner Pizza Robert Sietsema

Open since 1966 on Kensington’s main drag, Korner is a neighborhood pizzeria par excellence, with a corner location boasting garden-style concrete tables out front for scarfing your slices, calzones, pastas, and heroes in fine weather. The inside dining room with the usual wavy-benched orange booths is equally comfortable, the walls plastered with photos and other reminiscences of Sicily. The regular cheese slice is perfection itself, with a lighter-than-air crust, thin coating of tomato sauce, and an extravagance of good cheese. For vegans, the broccoli rabe hero is recommended.

226 Church Ave # 1
Brooklyn, NY 11218

77. San Remo

1408 Cortelyou Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11226
San Remo Robert Sietsema

Established in 1976, San Remo offers a deep dining room favored by Ditmas Park families, and all the usual modern pies, including lasagna pizza, the everything pie, deep dish veggie (Chicago style), Buffalo chicken pizza, and vodka pie. The best, though, is the grandma, a variation on the regular Sicilian with a thinner crust, a more herbal sauce, and black pepper. It’s scrumptious.

1408 Cortelyou Rd
Brooklyn, NY 11226

78. Original Pizza

6823 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220
Original Pizza Robert Sietsema

Was the name, like Not Ray’s, created to thumb its nose at the once-mighty Ray’s Original chain? The pizza here is far better, with a thinner crust though still of the plain, old-fashioned slice sort. As in many neighborhood joints, the cheese is the thing — a lake of it, ramping up the protein component and the richness so that one slice is likely to do you for lunch. The location directly over the R train stop at Bay Ridge Avenue is a big asset.

6823 4th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11220

79. Bari Pasta & Pizza

596 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10304
Bari Pasta & Pizza Robert Sietsema

In an iconic Stapleton location across the street from Tappen Park, Bari’s specializes in an indigenous type of Staten Island pie that features dense, dairy-driven toppings. Shown here are two representative slices: One is a pizza-fication of the Philly cheesesteak, swamped with thin-sliced steak, caramelized onions and peppers, and a Whiz-type cheese; the other attempts to mimic a pasta Alfredo in slice form. Both are rich and taste better than they look. The pizzeria is named after the capital of Apulia, the homeland of many Staten Islanders and Brooklynites.

596 Bay St
Staten Island, NY 10304

80. Pizza Wagon

8610 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
Pizza Wagon Robert Sietsema

Placing it among the most ancient and venerable of early neighborhood pizzerias, which saw their heyday in the 1950s and 1960s, Pizza Wagon was founded in 1966. It possesses one of the most convivial dining rooms in Bay Ridge, and doesn’t bother with a vast range of pie choices. Thus, most slices are served still warm from the oven, and a favorite is the Sicilian (only $2.50!): with a crisp and light crust, plenty of sweet tomato sauce, and a thick mantle of cheese. Open late.

8610 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11209

81. Mr. Phil's Pizza

7212 New Utrecht Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11228
Mr. Phil’s Pizza Robert Sietsema

The upside-down Sicilian is star of the show at this classic Dyker Heights pizzeria (established in the ‘90s), which is more glitzy and comfortable than its brethren along New Utrecht Avenue, an ancient Dutch thoroughfare that dates to the 17th century. The slice in question is square, thinner, and crisper than most Sicilians, with the mozzarella next to the crust; the rich, thick, sweet tomato sauce on top of that; and a scatter of parmesan on top for enhanced saltiness and cheesiness. The garlic knots are especially good and so are the outsize, deep-fried rice balls, once again demonstrating Sicilian heritage of this excellent place.

7212 New Utrecht Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11228

82. Espresso Pizzeria

9403 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
Espresso Pizzeria Robert Sietsema

This Bay Ridge pizzeria elicits hyperbolic praise from its many fans, especially for its standard thin-crust cheese pie, with tomato sauce not too sweet, mozzarella not too rich or profuse, and a very light hand with the herbs. In fact, if we were to select a candidate for best cheese slice in Brooklyn, Espresso might win, representing a Platonic ideal of plainness. Says one fan, "It's pizza done simple, good, and right."

9403 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11209

83. King's Pizza

1688 East 16th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11229
King's Pizza Robert Sietsema

Located right around the corner from Kings Highway — hence the name — this grandstanding pizza parlor is especially orange in décor and delivers equally bold flavor. The bacon slice is wondrous, carpeted with smoked and crumbled pork belly, a greater quantity than you’d expect. The standard slice is of average thickness, with more cheese than usual and a little less sauce. Between 3 p.m. and 4 p.m., a tsunami of students, construction workers, and tradespeople blow in and throng the tiny shop.

1688 East 16th Street
Brooklyn, NY 11229

84. Pizza D'Oro

3115 Victory Blvd #1, Staten Island, NY 10314
Pizza D’Oro Robert Sietsema

Lush, lush, lush, and thick-crusted, too, is the style of most Staten Island pizzerias (if you leave out places like Lee’s and Denino’s that specialize in cracker-type bar pies). Several notches above its neighborhood brethren, deades-old Pizza D’Oro (“Pie of Gold”) displays a glass case filled with pies that ramp up pizza’s richness, many available by the slice. One of the favorites is the lasagna pizza, multiplying cheeses and meats heaped high on the crust. Located in an old house now surrounded by a strip shopping center on the northwestern part of the island.

3115 Victory Blvd #1
Staten Island, NY 10314

85. Bad Boys Pizza

2313 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11214
Bad Boys Pizza Robert Sietsema

Situated in the midst of what is rapidly becoming the city’s fifth Chinatown, Bad Boys is a classic full-service pizzeria, rolling out such sidelines as baked manicotti, pepper-and-egg heros, and fried calamari. But the star of the show remains the pizzas, especially the fresh mozzarella pie with a soupçon of olive oil dribbled atop the cheese, and the square Sicilian, with a crust a little thinner and crunchier than most and a fragrant scatter of dried herbs.

2313 86th St
Brooklyn, NY 11214

Related Maps