clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

The New York Times Brings Back Starred Restaurant Reviews After Pandemic Hiatus

Plus, New Jersey ice cream shop Coney Waffle expands to its namesake Coney Island — and more intel

A carryout tray filled with yellow rice and beans, and chopped roast pork with brown shards of crackly skin.
Wells awarded three stars to La Piraña Lechonera for its line-inducing roast pork, pulpo, and mofongo studded with pork and seasoned with “God juice.”
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

After a pandemic hiatus that lasted over two years, the New York Times is back to doling out stars for its restaurant reviews. Critic Pete Wells broke the news yesterday with an effusive three-star review of La Piraña Lechonera, a legendary South Bronx food trailer run by Angel Jimenez, who is famous for his juicy, fatty, sought-after lechón. Wells praised the spot for its glorious, machete-chopped roast pork and excellent rendition of pulpo, and included a brief line nodding to the return of starred restaurant reviews: “We suspended the stars back in March 2020, and although the pandemic hasn’t ended, people are going to restaurants,” Wells wrote.

Restaurant critics across the country paused their review ratings systems — and, for a time, reviews altogether — at the onset of the pandemic in 2020. At the Times, Wells’s last starred review was a praising one-star write-up of East Williamsburg deli Pastrami Masters in March 2020. At other publications, the break from stars led some to rethink the controversial ratings system altogether: Eater permanently dropped stars from its reviews starting in September 2021, and the Infatuation initially did the same, although it has since reversed course and started rating restaurants again on a 0-10 scale.

A New Jersey ice cream shop follows its namesake to Coney Island

Coney Waffle, a local ice cream chain with four locations in New Jersey, has finally opened up a spot in the summery location it was named after: Coney Island.

New bakery Butterdose slated for the East Village

Details are scarce on the newcomer just yet, according to EV Grieve, but one thing’s for sure: the neighborhood pastry competition is no joke.

A new way to snag NYC’s most elusive restaurant reservations

And it only costs (in some cases) $1,000.

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Eater New York newsletter

The freshest news from the local food world