clock menu more-arrow no yes
Three burgers at the top, all different and glistening with grease, french fries and round potatoes at the bottom.
Three of the seven burgers offered at Smashed

Filed under:

Gloriously Greasy Burgers Are the Star at Four New Downtown Manhattan Spots

How do the burgers at Morgernstern’s, Bronson’s Burgers, 7th Street Burger, and Smashed stack up? Our senior critic weighs in.

During the past few months, four new burger restaurants have blossomed in adjacent downtown neighborhoods, including the East Village, Lower East Side, Nolita, and Greenwich Village. Each offered a pared-down menu emphasizing greasy burgers cooked to order in a manner that emulated working-class burger joints of long ago. All provided skinny fries, a narrow range of toppings, little seating, prices regarded as affordable, and in most cases, a vegetarian option. And all seemed calculated for franchising, making us wonder: Are they trying to duplicate Shake Shack’s success? Read on, burger lover.

Morgenstern’s

Ice cream parlor Morgenstern’s recently added a hamburger counter to its storefront, which Silver Spurs once occupied. These burgers are not the humongous, partly steamed patties of its predecessor, but modest-size burgers in the Shake Shack mode, only tidier and more austere. Every element of the “all-American burger” ($11) has been carefully contrived: An ample seeded bun carefully browned on its interior surfaces, American cheese that melts as the burger is served, shredded lettuce, assertive vinegar pickles, and chopped raw onions — a classic combination of flavors.

A cheeseburger with seeds on the bun and chopped onions spilling out.
The “all-American burger” at Morgenstern’s
A burger cut in half to reveal a pink middle of the patty.
Morgenstern’s burger in cross section

Break off a piece of the beef patty and find it medium rare and full of beefy savor. But there was a problem: In keeping the interior pink, the exterior failed to achieve brownness — mine was lightly seared on one side and nearly raw on the other, like a cross between a burger and steak tartare. The garlic fries ($5) with swatches of skin adhering were good. Having an ice cream parlor and burger joint in the same space is an obvious asset, and boozy shakes and cocktails are part of the formula. 88 West Houston Street, at LaGuardia Place, Greenwich Village

Bronson’s Burgers

Not yet two weeks old, Bronson’s Burgers is named, not after movie star Charles Bronson or rapper Action Bronson, but supposedly after a dog. It’s a project of Rivers & Hills Hospitality, the outfit behind Kimika and Wayla, though this place bears no resemblance to either. The burger dubbed “classic” ($12) is a compact affair, with a great bun that sits up high, and a relatively thick patty that’s been expertly cooked so that it’s darkly seared on both sides.

Two hands hold out a cheeseburger with pickles and sweating slice of cheddar visible.
The Bronson’s Burger “classic”

Trouble is, the meat lacks flavor. Two other defects plague it: The slice of cheddar sweats like a student taking a test, and the caramelized onions command too much attention, making each bite sweet. The fries ($3) are better than average, and don’t miss the root beer float ($5.50). 350 Mulberry Street, between Prince and Spring streets, Nolita

Smashed

In the current era, the “smash burger” has become a thing, accomplished by doing what we were once told never to do: Press the spatula down on top of the patty until all the juices have been expelled, resulting in a thin dark patty that produces a slight crunch when bitten into. I dutifully tried three of the seven burgers offered, including one that featured blue cheese and bacon, mainly because the place received a glowing review in the New Yorker, in which the Maillard reaction was prominently mentioned. I found the patties inconsistently smashed, with some of the sides deeply browned, others gray and soppy.

The seared meat is forward, the bun, cheese, and onions are fuzzy in the background.
Double patty “classic smashed” at Smashed
A brown cardboard box filled with french fries.
The fries at Smashed were the best I tried at all four places.

Nevertheless, the double-patty “classic smashed” ($12) on a puffy potato roll with an orange sauce like thousand-island dressing, proved to be tasty if not truly delicious. The wobbly brown fries outclassed the burger and were the best I tried among all four burger joints; but the “smashed potatoes,” made with miniature skin-on spuds, were disappointingly bland. Alcoholic beverages may eventually be available, giving “Smashed” a new meaning. 177 Orchard Street, between Stanton and Houston streets, Lower East Side

7th Street Burger

7th Street Burger opened in early June in the space formerly occupied by Caracas Arepa Bar, a fixture of the East Village since 2003. Now brighter and airier, the white box of a place is operated by Jersey native Kevin Rezvani. He previously owned a small burger chain called Diesel & Duke in New Brunswick. The new place retains the chain’s extreme simplicity, with a menu so pared down it only includes four food items: a cheeseburger, a double cheeseburger, an Impossible cheeseburger, and fries.

A homely, squished down cheeseburger on greasy wrapping paper.
Yes, 7th Street Burger’s cheeseburger is homely and greasy, but it’s also the best

The cheeseburger ($6) proved elegant in its unwavering simplicity, with a much larger ratio of meat to other ingredients than is usual, elevating beefiness almost to a religion. The beef brims with flavor and grease gloriously soaks the bun. Whether the bun is intentionally flattened by the grill cook or not, the squished bun further concentrates the flavors, with the supporting roles filled by lightly sauteed onions, yellow American cheese, and a sour-creamy sauce that tastes slightly of mustard. In its explosion of concentrated flavors, this burger is an absolute joy to eat.

A simple interior lit at night through big picture windows with little signage.
7th Street Burger’s interior is small, boxy, and white.

The fries are kinda meh, with a light starch coating to imitate true brownness. This path of decent-but-undistinguished fries is one that Shake Shack also takes, but here the burger is actually a shade better than Shake Shack’s. Burger blasphemy? So be it. 91 East Seventh Street, between First Avenue and Avenue A, East Village


Building a Better Burger

The reconfiguring of the city’s typical burger away from the lush, bulbous bistro variety that once held sway to a retro, fast-food model is typical of these times. Yes, the prices are lower, but the burgers are smaller, and most places charge separately for fries and other add-ons, side dishes, and drinks, which can inflate the price of a meal to nearly what a bistro burger, including fries, costs.

But there is one flaw in the new formula. While the ingredients are often distinguished, not enough attention has been devoted to grilling the meat patty, and some of those I tried were flaccid and poorly cooked. World-class searing takes times and effort and burger flipping is a high calling. Still, it’s exciting to have so many new burger choices, and these sorts of places are already popping up in other parts of town.

SMASHED

177 Orchard Street, Manhattan, NY 10002 (212) 945-8008 Visit Website

Smashed

177 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002 (212) 518-1804 Visit Website

Bronson’s Burgers

250 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10012 (212) 888-6280 Visit Website

7th St Burger

91 E 7th St, New York, NY 10009 (646) 490-6797 Visit Website
First Look

Sami & Susu Channels a 1960s Cartoon, but Its Food Is the Real Deal

A.M. Intel

Blue Hill at Stone Barns to Reopen ‘563 Evenings After Our Last Service’

A.M. Intel

Grand Central Terminal Lands New Steakhouse From Glitzy Italian Group Cipriani

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Eater New York newsletter

The freshest news from the local food world