clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Pizza Favorite Scarr’s Eyes a Bigger Location on the Lower East Side

New, 1 comment

Plus, iconic West Village speakeasy Chumley’s is nearly 100 — and more intel

A slice of pizza garnished with basil, laid on a white paper plate
Scarr’s may be relocating to a larger location in the neighborhood.
Nick Solares/Eater

Scarr’s Pizza is expanding, again

Changes are afoot once again at top Lower East Side pizzeria Scarr’s. Following the announcement last month that the crowd-favorite pizzeria would be opening a new location at a food hall in Midtown this year, the business is now planning to relocate just down the street from its original location at 22 Orchard Street to 35 Orchard Street, near Hester Street, Bowery Boogie reports. The new location, which stretches through to Allen Street, will be larger than the current slender location, a spokesperson for Scarr’s tells Eater. It measures 1,400 square feet and will have about 40 seats.

Bowery Boogie first spotted the new development on Manhattan Community Board 3’s website, where the pizzeria has submitted an application for its liquor license to be transferred from its current spot to the new one. Scarr’s, named after owner Scarr Pimental, opened in the neighborhood in 2016 and quickly developed a loyal following. Both Eater and the New York Times have noted that the pizzeria has one of the best pizza slices in the city.

In other news

— Renowned West Village speakeasy Chumley’s is hosting a 20s-themed bash on March 23 in anticipation of the institution’s 100th anniversary in 2022 with dishes like oysters Rockefeller, finger sandwiches, deviled eggs, and Waldorf salad, according to a spokesperson for the restaurant.

— Staten Island icon Ralph’s Italian Ices and Ice Cream, which has more than 80 locations in the tri-state area, is opening a new spot in the East Village at 145 Avenue A, at East 9th Street.

— Sweets focused-festival Dessert Goals returns to NYC on May 2 and 3 this year. The Long Island City-based event will have vendors like Keki Modern Cakes Joey Bats Cafe. Ticket prices start at $13 per person.

— For the 13th year running, a festival featuring dozens of Upper West Side restaurants returns to the neighborhood this year. Taste of the Upper West Side will take place on May 15 and 16 with restaurants like Jacob’s Pickles, Calle Ocho, and Jing Fong.

— Greek yogurt company Chobani is partnering with mini cafe chain Maman to create limited menu items like orange chamomile oat loaf and blueberry oat crumble latte for the month of March. The menu items will be available at six different Maman locations: Soho, Tribeca, Nomad, Hudson Square, FiDi, and Greenpoint.

— English muffin brand Thomas’ is opening a pop-up cafe in Tribeca from April 23 through 26. The Nooks and Crannies Cafe will celebrate the 140th anniversary of the business that was started in a Chelsea bakery in 1880.

— A new vendor at Columbus Circle’s Turnstyle Underground Market called 2Dutcheese sells a large selection of gouda cheese.

— Everyone take a deep breath:

Scarr's Pizza

22 Orchard Street, Manhattan, NY 10002 (212) 334-3481 Visit Website

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Eater New York newsletter

The freshest news from the local food world