clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

This Pizza Sandwich Has a Cheesy, Crispy Chicken Cutlet Inside

New, 5 comments

After a long search, critic Robert Sietsema (almost) finds a Pittsburgh sandwich he once had where the bread was made up of pizza slices

The pointed facade of the pizzeria with a blue sky in the background.
Marabella is a Sunnyside pizzeria shaped like a slice.

Years ago I was on assignment for Gourmet in Pittsburgh and stumbled on a very strange pizzeria. The place turned out the usual round Italian-American pies, but instead of serving them right away, they put them aside and used the slices later on to make wedge-shaped sandwiches, two slices per sandwich, which featured the usual cold cuts along with lettuce and tomato. Frankly weird!

I never went again, and now the place seems un-Googleable. Yet, the idea made an impression on me, and I kept on the lookout for something similar in New York City, where all forms of pizza are known to exist simultaneously.

Two pizza guys with a glass case in front of them stare at the camera.
Pizza sandwich in the foreground
Two tables of pizza eaters in front of a yellow wall.
Maps and pictures of Sicily line the walls.

I finally found something similar at Marabella, a pizza-shaped premises on Greenpoint Avenue in Sunnyside. This rollicking neighborhood spot decorated with maps of Sicily offers the usual assortment of slices, pastas, and sandwiches, but one displayed in a glass case on the counter caught my eye.

These were wedge-shaped sandwiches that seemed to be made with two slices of pizza. The slices were really a tomato-smeared focaccia cut in half horizontally and then further cut into wedges, but damned if they didn’t look like slices of pizza. The effect was nearly the same. The filling was breaded chicken cutlets with cheese melted on top, and arugula and tomato completed the illusion that it was a sandwich made with two slices of pizza.

The sandwich ($7), called a focaccia chicken cutlet sandwich, was popped in the oven and heated up — tomato, arugula, and all — before arriving to me on a white paper plate. The thing tasted great: The annealed tomato sauce and a bonus tomato wedge on top contributed lots of flavor and moisture, while the chicken cutlet retained its crunch even under a mantle of cheese. Still, I wanted to ask the pizza guys if they’d mind making me one with two slice of cold cheese pizza instead. 41-07 Greenpoint Ave, at 41st Street, Sunnyside

A wedge shaped sandwich with a split focaccia that looks like two slices of pizza on top and bottom.
The sandwich is delicious.

Marabella

4107 Greenpoint Avenue, Queens, NY 11104 (718) 786-4635 Visit Website

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Eater New York newsletter

The freshest news from the local food world