clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

A Gravy-Drenched Brisket Sandwich Lies Hidden in an Old Irish Pub in FiDi

New, 3 comments

Blarney Stone’s sloppy brisket sandwich doused in gravy is a darn good relic of old pub fare

A green awning and green sign that says Blarney Stone, with a man walking away...
The Wall Street Blarney Stone is one of only two that remains.

It is my intention to celebrate the sandwich this year by finding as many tasty examples as possible, with a special emphasis on fringe styles, but also presenting sandwiches that were considered more normal 30 years ago that now seem quaint. I will do this weekly and periodically present round-ups of the ones I consider best.


Anyone who frolicked in Manhattan in the 1980s will remember all the Irish bars with “Blarney” in the name. There was Blarney Castle, Blarney Stone, Blarney Cove, and Blarney Rock, each representing a chain that was mainly located in commercial parts of the city, commemorating a southern Irish castle exceedingly popular with American tourists. This was way before Irish publicans began opening gastropubs in every neighborhood, with menus of burgers, nachos, and Caesar salads.

A darkened bar and dining room with people sitting on stools and in chairs, you can almost smell the mustiness...
The Blarney barroom
The menu includes mashed potatoes, meat loaf, pastrami, and about 20 other items of an old fashioned sort...
The chalkboard menu

These old Blarney places, of which few remain, fed the public with a steam table in their back rooms, from which fragrant meat odors arose. Typically, you could traverse their lengths and pick up a carved-to-order sandwich of hot pastrami, hot corned beef, or hot brisket, in addition to beef stew, corned beef and cabbage, meat loaf, and shepherd’s pie. Vegetables other than cabbage were in short supply. The roast brisket sandwich on either rye or a Kaiser roll came with a generous moistening of brown gravy. Where did the gravy come from? Who knew, though many suspected it came from a can. In those days, though, you could request that fabulous brown gravy be poured over almost anything.

I recently visited one of Manhattan’s last two remaining Blarney Stones near Wall Street at the entrance to the Brooklyn Battery Tunnel. The barroom was ancient, and behind that a small lunchroom with a steam table lurked. A chalkboard listed more meats than I was expecting. I ordered the brisket sandwich on rye with gravy and saw the steam table attendant cut it on the usual circular-bladed carver, pausing occasionally to survey his work, but then beginning again to pile on an almost obscene quantity of meat.

Then he unstintingly poured on the gravy with a ladle from a receptacle brimming with it. The sandwich came with a pickle and fork. I ate the pickle and threw away the fork. Part of the fun of a lush sandwich like this is figuring out how to eat it without getting gravy all over your shirtfront and sleeves. The sandwich was a bargain at $11.50, and so good I force-fed myself the whole thing. 11 Trinity Place, between Morris and Rector streets, FiDi

A giant heap of brown brisket smothered in gravy between two slices of rye bread with pickles on a plain round plate...
Behold the giant sloppy brisket sandwich at Blarney Stone.

Blarney Stone

11 Trinity Pl, New York, NY 10006 (212) 269-4988 Visit Website

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Eater New York newsletter

The freshest news from the local food world