clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

This Week Killed 3 Longtime NYC Restaurants and Bars

New, 4 comments

One of them, Hudson Diner, had been open for 23 years

The now-closed Hudson Diner
The now-closed Hudson Diner
Photo by Robert Sietsema

2018’s restaurant massacre continues with the closure of three longtime places and a brand-new one: Red Hook dive bar Red Hook Bait and Tackle, West Village restaurant Hudson Diner, Upper West Side seafood spot Ed’s Chowder House, and West Village newcomer Icelandic Fish & Chips have all shuttered.

Red Hook is down a beloved dive bar with the closure of 14-year-old Bait and Tackle, which locals celebrated Sunday night. Even after police came, the party continued until 6 a.m. with a chili cook-off, concert, dancing, and lots of drinking. Owner Barry O’Meara pointed to the neighborhood’s “different financial demographics” as the reason for the shutter.

The West Village’s 23-year-old Hudson Diner cleared out its space this week, and the interior is already demolished. Diners are a rapidly endangered dining genre in New York City; the last couple of years have seen the closure of a handful of these old-school establishments.

Nine years is the limit for the Upper West Side’s Ed’s Chowder House, which opened in 2009 in the Empire Hotel with a varied menu of seafood. Owners gave no reason for the closure, simply posting a note on the website.

Further south, brand-new Iceland import Icelandic Fish & Chips lasted just six months on Seventh Avenue South before calling it quits. Eater critic Robert Sietsema was skeptical of the food when it opened.

2018 has already seen a high number of shutters, many for rent issues.

Icelandic Fish & Chips

28 7th Avenue South, New York, New York 10014

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Eater New York newsletter

The freshest news from the local food world