Skip to main content

Long Lost and Lamented: Lundy Brothers, 1920 - 1979

For the next hour of Classics Week, Robert Siestema pays homage to some of New York’s finest restaurants now lost to history.

Robert Sietsema
Robert Sietsema is the former Eater NY senior critic with more than 35 years of experience covering dining in New York City.

Power HourThis seafood restaurant opened in 1920 in Brooklyn's Sheepshead Bay, when that seaside neighborhood supported a giant commercial fishing fleet and the bay was lined with clam shacks, many on stilts. By 1934 the place moved into a vastly expanded premises filling an entire block with a two-story building in the Spanish Mission style. The place seated 2,600, making it the largest restaurant in the city, and it served 15,000 meals on Mothers Day. Lundy's closed in 1979, and subsequent attempts to revive it – ost recently in a small corner of the original building – have proven unsuccessful. The building is now occupied by a mini shopping center and a few restaurants.

See More:
From EaterExternal LinkEater
Our Editors’ Personal Favorite Amazon Prime Day Deals (We’re Picky)Our Editors’ Personal Favorite Amazon Prime Day Deals (We’re Picky)
From EaterExternal LinkEater
By Francky Knapp, Alex Zaragoza, and Hilary Pollack
Eater Archives
A Pioneering African Fast-Casual Restaurant Shuts Down in HarlemA Pioneering African Fast-Casual Restaurant Shuts Down in Harlem
Eater Archives

Teranga’s last day is Sunday, June 15

By Erika Adams
From PunchExternal Link
Is Fedora’s Obscure Martini the Next Bartender Flex?Is Fedora’s Obscure Martini the Next Bartender Flex?
From PunchExternal Link

New York’s recently reopened Fedora is betting on this low-alcohol martini from 1903.

From PunchExternal Link
We Run a Makeshift Bar Out of a NYC Diner. Here’s How.We Run a Makeshift Bar Out of a NYC Diner. Here’s How.
From PunchExternal Link

The team behind A Pop-Up Called Pancakes on milk crates as wells, Gibsons in syrup dispensers and “luncheonette ice.”

Eater Archives
The Eater Guide to Drinking in NYCThe Eater Guide to Drinking in NYC
Eater Archives

Pick from every kind of bar imaginable

By Eater Staff
Eater Archives
One of New York’s Essential Vegan Restaurants Is ClosingOne of New York’s Essential Vegan Restaurants Is Closing
Eater Archives

Modern Love will have its last day in June

By Nadia Chaudhury