Anniversary Dinner: Bar Room at The Modern or Annisa?

Suppose that you are celebrating your anniversary this evening. You don't have reservations, but your significant other gives you two options: The Bar Room at The Modern and Annisa. You should have no problem calling and getting a table at either, but which do you choose? Assume that you will be ordering a la carte at either restaurant. One has tarte flambee, lobster gnocchi, and duck confit a l'orange, and the other has foie gras dumplings, wild mushroom gnocco, and chicken served with truffles and pig feet. Place your vote below, and argue your case in the comments.