clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Totonno's Could Reopen in Coney Island in Mid-January

The family that owns the historic Coney Island pizzeria Totonno's had hoped to open by Christmas, but unfortunately that's not going to happen. Instead, they're now shooting for a mid-January opening. Serious Eats checks in on the progress at the Neptune Avenue icon, and, well, things aren't looking as good as they could.

Third-generation co-owner Antoinette Balzano estimates that the repairs to the restaurant?which took on four feet of floodwater?will cost around $100,000, which their insurance company is not going to cover. They've already been fleeced by one contractor who charged $6,000 to remove mold from the walls but half-assed it before taking off with the money. Another contractor, a self-proclaimed history buff, has come in to help restore the pizzeria to its previous, old-school greatness. Adding to the expense is the fact that much of the equipment purchased after the restaurant's devastating 2009 fire has to be replaced, again.

Balzano has applied for a $150,000 loan to cover the costs of rebuilding and reopening. The good news is that Totonno's is, in fact, coming back, doing so in a way that's honest to the 90-year-old institution's history.
· Restoring the Church of Pizza: the Rebuilding and Repairing of Totonno's After Hurricane Sandy [Serious Eats/Slice]
· All Coverage of Totonno's [~ENY~]

Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitano

1524 Neptune Avenue, New York, NY 11224 718 372 8606

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Eater New York newsletter

The freshest news from the local food world