clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

The Last-Minute Thanksgiving Pie-Buying Guide

New, 6 comments

If you haven't placed an order for that delicious Thanksgiving pie yet, you better act fast — time is running out. Eater called around to many of the top bakeries in the city to find out whether they can still accommodate your pie order, and when you can pick them up this week:

2011_pie_guide1.jpgHill Country Chicken: You have until 9:30 PM tonight to place that pie order.
Magnolia: Some pies left, but they're probably going to stop taking orders around 11 AM tomorrow. The Grand Central, Rock Center, and UWS locations will be open (with limited hours) on Thanksgiving.
Blue Smoke Bakery: You gotta place that order tonight. Blue Smoke will be open on Wednesday (but not Thursday) for pick up.
Four & Twenty Blackbirds: New York's hottest pie shop is TOTALLY BOOKED for Thanksgiving orders, but there will be a select number of pies available on Wednesday and Thursday (starting at 8 AM). Note: there's a strict two pie per person limit — choose wisely.
Two Little Red Hens: This UES bakery is not taking any more pie orders for this week, but they will be open on Thanksgiving day from 7 AM - 2 PM, with plenty of pies to go around.
Sweet Melissa: Today's the last day for pie orders, but the Court Street patisserie will be open on Thanksgiving Day until noon.

The Little Pie Company: No more orders, but they will be open on Thanksgiving from 8 AM - 12 PM.
Billy's Bakery: Billy's has stopped taking orders, but the Chelsea and Tribeca locations will be selling fresh pies on Wednesday.
Clinton Street Baking Co.: The Baking Co. is taking pie orders until Wednesday morning. They'll also have fresh whole pies for sale on Tuesday and Wednesday.
Trois Pommes Patisserie: Today is the LAST DAY to order a pie, and they won't have pies for sale without an order for the rest of the week.
Sarabeth's Bakery in the Chelsea Market: Tomorrow is the last day that they're accepting Thanksgiving orders, but there will be a limited number of pies available on Wednesday and Thursday (8 AM - 1 PM).
City Bakery: No more pie orders, and they're closed on Thanksgiving, but City Bakery will have pies for sale on Wednesday.
Peels: All orders for pies, cakes, and holiday treats must be in by noon on Tuesday. Check out the order form for more info (PDF).
· All Thanksgiving Coverage on Eater [~ENY~]

Magnolia Bakery

401 Bleecker Street, New York, NY 10014 Visit Website

Hill Country Chicken

1123 Broadway, New York, NY 10010 Visit Website

Four & Twenty Blackbirds

439 3rd Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11215 (718) 499-2917 Visit Website

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Eater New York newsletter

The freshest news from the local food world