clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Liveblogging the Debut of Monster Italian Superstore Eataly

New, 21 comments

Today, right this moment actually, Mario Batali and Joe Bastianich are opening their gazillion dollar 50,000 square foot culinary mecca Eataly. Will it be a game changer? Is it just an over-hyped Whole Foods with foreign signage? Now is not the time for these questions. Now is the time to document the opening day fracas.

3:45: And it looks like the wine store's open a bit early!

3:47: Our operative reports: "The wine store is acting as a waiting room before the main event debuts kinda small in comparison to the rest of the space. Pimping the Bastianich-owned Ferrari brand but good to see a selection of grappas and amaros."

3:55: The crowd at the door is now 50 feet deep, our tipster reports: "Good mix of fashionable young ladies, the elderly and wanderers off the street lured in by the Batali name."

3:59: A nearby office worker writes in to confirm that the line is "down the block."

4:00: As promised, the doors opened at 4 PM sharp, people are flowing into the building, picking up shopping baskets at the door, etc.

4:10: Batali is in the house, shaking hands and generally greeting the crowd. Our tipster overheard someone say " it's not as big as I imagined."

4:15: Our tipster confirms that every employee is wearing orange crocs.

4:17 Lidia and Joe are also there. Joe was seen "smirking like he knows they've got a hit."

4:20 Antipasti king Cesare Casella is there.

4:25: Those awesome individual pizzas from the pizza restaurant, Pizzeria Rossopomodoro? The ones made by the two guys that just got here from Naples? They'll run you $9-$20, depending on the toppings.

4:30: Of the vegetables, our tipster notes "Pricing isn't all that far off from any other upscale market. Heirloom tomatoes are actually under market at $4/lb!"

4:35: Here's the menu for Pizzeria Rossopomodoro:

4:40: Alan Richman is in the house, eating some seafood.

4:50: And here's the menu for La Pasta:

4:55: Our operative confirms that there's a great selection of obscure produce at Eataly.

5:00: Okay, now we're getting a peek at Manzo, the white tablecloth restaurant. The menus (above in the gallery) are broken down into a series of prix fixe and a la carte options. The antipasti are priced between $13 and $21, the primi are in the $17-$21 range, the secondi in the $25-$45 range (plus a $95 ribeye for two). There's a six course beef tasting menu for $75, a four course "Taste of Liguria" menu for $65, and a three course "Taste of Parmigiano Reggiano" menu for $50.

5:30: Our operative has left the building, but not before getting a look at the menu for La Verdure, the vegetable restaurant (in the above gallery). Antipasti at La Verdure are in the $9-$11 range, entrees $15-$21. Also, looks like there's some sick rotisserie chicken at Eataly. And we're out. Happy shopping and eating everyone!

On the scene reporting by Zachary Feldman
· All Coverage of Eataly [~ENY~]


200 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10010 Visit Website


200 5th Ave., New York, NY 10010

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Eater New York newsletter

The freshest news from the local food world