clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Banned on Chowhound: The Lost Posts I

Today, we're going to start making good on our pledge to run posts in-full that were banned on the -- we're not going to use the word Nazi, but -- message board Chowhound. First up, a review of Brooklyn's Frannie's. STATUS: Inexplicably Banned.

Banned: I've been meaning to eat at Franny's in Prospect Heights for a few years now, ever since the owners had their column in the NY Times Dining In section. After hitting up the Brooklyn Museum today I did get around to stopping by with my girlfriend. It was, unfortunately, a disappointment. We arrived at 5:45pm (we both had light lunches and were quite hungry) and expected to beat the dinner rush.

Surprisingly the dining area was mostly full–a number of families were there with kids. There were a couple of four person tables open and one two person table, though. Instead of seating us at any of the open tables, the hostess
told us there would be a five minute wait, so we sat down on some stools by the window. After a few minutes the hostess came by with drink menus, though we weren't interested in ordering at the bar, and after another couple of minutes she decided that the time was right for us to be seated at the open two person table.

I ordered a Six Points ale at the table and my girlfriend had a glass of a chilled red wine. We also ordered our meal: sardines and butter crostini, the cured meat plate, and a clam pizza.

The crostini and meat plate arrived within three minutes of ordering them, which was nice as we were starved and Franny's apparently doesn't offer any complimentary bread or other snacks. Unfortunately, the crostini consisted of one slice of bread cut in half with about four sardines on it. It was very tasty, but for a $9 order, bringing out a single slice of bread is an insult. We were in a similar situation with the meat plate: it was tasty, and if served with some bread might have actually been a substantial appetizer. But the meat plate was inexplicably meant to be consumed without accompaniment, and at $15 could not be described as worth it.

Then the clam pizza arrived. Again, it was tasty, but at $16 for what turned out to be an individually-sized serving, there should have been many more clams on it. To contrast, the clam pizza I had not too long ago at Otto was cheaper, loaded with clams (in the shell, which is fun), and in my opinion, tastier.

At this point we were both still hungry, but rather soured on the Franny's experience and not in the mood to give them any more money towards another pizza.

Based on the crowd, the prices and serving sizes don't appear to be doing much to hurt it's popularity, and I appreciate what the owners are trying to do with organic ingredients, but I personally can't imagine going back for another meal there.

Have you been Banned on Chowhound? Send your banned material this way. We're waiting with open arms.

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Eater New York newsletter

The freshest news from the local food world