While the L's coverage was a far cry from perfect, and their Chowhound-inspired tack did not by any means have the scope of either of its much larger peers' versions, the Perfect NYC Menu approach sure as hell was efficient. It took NY Mag a page-long taste test ? in which they did not say anything that hasn't been said before ? to announce that their four-star pick for lobster roll was Brooklyn Fish Camp, whereas it took L a mere two sentences to deem their favorite a Brooklyn Fish Camp genetic predecessor, Pearl Oyster Bar. And if you're going to be predictable with your picks, as both NY Mag and, to a lesser extent, L were, at least be quick about it.